3.4
Good
164 Reviews
5760 Frantz Road, Dublin · 10.53 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Bagel & Flavored Cream Cheese
- Egg and Cheese Bagel
- Matzo Ball Soup
- Veggie Sandwich
“I LOVE kettle-boiled bagels. There is nothing like them in the world. When found Barry’s Bagels, I thought I’d died and gone to heaven. For the most part their bagels are light, puffy, super soft and full of flavor. However, I can’t tell you how disappointing it is to go in and order a dozen or half dozen bagels and they’re burned, flat, crunchy. The vanilla cinnamon when done right are the absolute BEST bagels in the world followed by the chocolate chip. In October 2025, I brought it to the attention of one of the owners that the bagels are literally burned, flat and crunchy. She kindly apologized, told me they had a new baker and gave me a card to get a dozen free bagels whenever I wanted. So last Sunday I used that card to get the dozen free bagels to take to my church small group-ugh, but the bagels were overcooked. Again! I wish they were more consistent with not overcooking the bagels. If I could trust they would be the same, soft, puffy bagels all the time, I’d go there every single day. My other pet-peeve is that they close at 2 or 3 pm every day. Why not stay open until at least 4 or 5 pm? I can’t always get there before 2pm and it seems way too early to close a business down for the day. I’m from Vermont. We eat bagels of every kind in every way for breakfast, lunch and dinner. It’s weird to me that I can’t get a bagel sandwich for dinner. Again on Sunday I ordered poppy seed bagels as a part of my dozen. It was the saddest poppy seed bagel I’d ever seen. There were maybe 10 poppyseeds on the entire bagel. I’ve never seen anything like that. Cc I’m nn think they need to hire a quality control person to make sure their bagels are the same light, puffy(not burned) bagels consistently. Also, their fountain soda dispenser has been “out of order” for nearly a year now. Frustrating. Otherwise it’s a very clean, friendly place.”