13 Best Bakeries near Middletown

“Shopped here for the first time today with my daughter. We bought a large variety of pastries and everything we ate was the best of its kind--ever. We'll be back.“

“My daughter, I and a friend ate at the Calypso Café today. I had an iced Frappuccino. It was great, but the outstanding thing was the white chocolate macadamia nut cookie. It was fabulous. My daughter had a cake. I can’t remember the kind, but it was really good. She loved that. I am looking forward to eating there again. I highly recommend this place.“

“Seriously addicting! We love everything you make! Even got my mom hooked! :-P“

“I came a day early for a cookie cake I thought I ordered and Arora and Natalie G. were so kind and accommodating! They quickly made the cake and were so kind about the mistake I had made! 5 star service and I will absolutely be back for amazing cookie cakes!“

“We always get our cakes made from Schucky’s Sweets, LLC she hands down has the best cakes we have ever tasted! Every year getting her cakes are one if the best parts about our birthdays. We highly recommend her!!“

“Strato is a delight to the tastebuds and the eyes! So many beautiful and delicious treats to choose from. Their macarons are delicious (and beautiful) as are the variety of chocolates, gelatos and pastries. The place is welcoming, beautiful and the owner, Marina, always greets us with a smile. I absolutely love this place. My new favorite is the cold foam macha - refreshing and delicious! I highly recommend it.“

“I had never tried Milton's before and I have to say they are delicious! I set my alarm so I could be there early. I am not disappointed!“

“The blueberry streusel muffins and bars were so great!! A lot of blueberry in each bite!! Will try others soon. Thank you for dropping them off!!“

“Had a mobile order at this location for the first time and the employee who helped us was so friendly! I only knocked off one star because I wasn’t familiar with this location and I wish there were better directions on how to find it inside the building (referring to the confirmation email with brief directions). I wish it would’ve said first floor, etc“

“The Peach Cobbler cupcake was so Delicious😋 The Cupcake was very Moist the icing was great the Cupcake literally taste like Peach Cobbler, The Sweetness was Perfect.I literally had to stop myself from eating the whole cupcake. I didn’t think it would taste as good as it did. I was so Impressed. This place will definitely be my place to hide to have me some me time😂😂“

“A small town bakery with delcious that is run by some hardworking women. I live nearby and treat myself and loved ones to an assorted box of sweet goods a few times a year. never disappoints, ever. Good selection for the size of the store. Anything cheesecake related is a safe selection 🤤“