50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Montgomery

“Best NY style pizza in the area!“

“I eat here occasionally. Service has always been good for me. They have several styles of pizza to choose from including their deep dish or thin or hand tossed round pizzas, NY bold fold or gluten free if you want. My favorite is their Aloha BBQ Chicken, hand tossed round. Yum! They've got nice deals on slices and you can get some sandwiches, too. They have good salads to go along with their pizzas, although I haven't seen too many people getting them.“

“Mouthwatering and delicious. Drove 20 minutes just to try this place. We will definitely be back. They only have two small tables outside so plan for take out! Best pizza I’ve had in Cincinnati.“

“Strong's new Newport location has noticeably "upped their game". I've been there the last two Fridays with a group for lunch and EVERYONE agreed that their pizzas were PHENOMENAL. The ingredients and flavor profiles were distinctly fresh and you could tell they aren't aiming to be "just another pizza joint"! 👍“

“I absolutely love everything on the menu! My favorite is the Meat Lasagna. I also enjoy the 'Old World Italy' feel and the friendliness of the staff.“

“Trophy pizza is amazing. The staff is great and the pizza is 10 out of 10!!! Make sure you try the garlic knots!!! They are delicious!! I just had knee surgery and Trophy pizza was our first stop before we headed home. The staff was awesome and helped me get out the door while my husband got the car. I even got a sweet treat to enjoy while I heal. If you haven't tried this pizza you are missing out. Stop in enjoy great pizza and an awesome staff!!“

“Nice quaint pizza spot. Good food“

“These guys are true artisans“

“Today’s visit was terrible. Pizza had huge bubbles that were charcoaled and bottom wasn’t baked. Service was not good either. A small place that somehow accommodated a party of 10, 8 of which were loud teens. We were moved to accommodate these guests and they didn’t behave like someone their age should. Ruined a Sunday evening meal.“

“Best authentic ny style pizza!“

“We had a wonderful experience visiting this spot on Madison Road. Everything we ordered was prepared perfectly and tasted incredibly fresh.

The pizza was delicious with a great crust, and the salad was crisp and well-dressed. You can really tell they care about the quality of their ingredients here. We will definitely be back soon.“

“We ate at Caruso’s for the first time July 3, 2024. My wife and I thought our meals were 5 star, delicious! She had the Chicken Marsala and I had the Rigatoni Rustica. We asked our waiter Sam for his recommendations and we’re so glad we took his advice. Best Italian dishes we’ve ever enjoyed. We can’t wait to return with good friends. Excellent! Denny & Barb G.“

“The vegan pizzas and tempeh hoagies are delicious and they have yummy crafty cocktails too. Highly recommended!“

“The food was amazing! Eli’s BBQ and Pesto Plus was the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time! It’s a must eat“

“My husband and I stopped in today for lunch after seeing it recommended on Google. The fresh focaccia with olive oil and balsamic were hands down the best I’ve ever had. My husband enjoyed his wedge salad and we split a highly delicious pepperoni pizza. Mike and Maddie were so welcoming! We even got to enjoy their brand new outdoor umbrellas which gave such a nice touch to their outdoor dining patio. We will definitely be back sooner rather than later! 🥰“

“This place is great! We come here often just me and hubby and sometimes with friends. It's close to home but that's not the only reason. They have live music, trivia nights, outside patio and volleyball. The manager is always walking around helping and smiling. Don't know his name but we say hello often. Perhaps he remembers us? The servers are very nice, fast and accommodating. We've gone there for just drinks, or to watch the Bengals games, soccer games Reds games, and they will accomodate if you ask. All in all. I recommend. Very decent food (though I feel they over cook the wings- my friend says they're perfect). You judge.“

“Fantastic pizza! Fresh, hot and delicious!“

“I have been meaning to stop by since they opened, finally had a chance tonight. Casual atmosphere of a neighborhood place. Warm greeting upon arrival. You order at the counter and the food is brought to your table. I had garlic knots and a small pizza and both were delicious. The pizza was a 10” pie the size of a paper plate. The toppings were fresh and evenly spread over the pie which was perfectly cooked. The crust was the perfect consistency. The pizza really did taste like a traditional pizza I use to have when I was young and we lived next door to a family from Italy. It’s a can’t miss experience, and I will definitely dine here again.“

“I’ve been coming to Pasquale’s/Fessies since I was a child. All the staff are amazing but I have to give a special shout out to Connie, she is the best! She always has a smile on her face, and she’s always treated us like family. You’re a star, Connie!“

“Authentic pizza and pasta. Staff is customer focused and quality minded. You got to get some of this!“

“Fantastic pizza! Fresh, hot and delicious!“

“Been wanting to try this place for a while. It did not disappoint!! So good and the Hawaiian pizza was 10/10. Will definitely be back!!“

“THIS is for the College Hill location... that Big Gripp is absolute ⛽ 🔥 👀 🤤“

“That pic on the home page isn't staged.....your pizza comes out exactly like that! Great pizza!!“

“My family and I moved to the Cincinnati area from Northeast NJ about 7 years ago and have tried most of the pizza places that advertise themselves as NYC/NJ pizza. None of them were quite as good as the pizza we were used to.

Until we tried Fratelli's. I walked into Fratelli's and was greeted with a wonderful and familiar smell which took me back to NJ. There's something about the smell of the dough/crust of NYC/NJ pizza that I can't quite describe, but when you know... you know.

This place is the real deal. It's a shame it took us 7 years to find them, but I'm so glad we did. I rate their pizza as good or better than the pizza we were used to having in NJ and can't wait to try some of their other menu items.“

“Very very good pizza and salad!! Such a treat!!“

“We had a friend in need of a nice cheesey covered pizza and y'all did not disappoint Turned out our friend had lost his sense of taste for most things after covid a few years ago. We brought him your pizza and it was one of the few meals he could actually taste. What a joy for him.

Thanks for being a great part of our neighborhood!“

“We drive from Lexington, Ky every few months just to eat at Newport Pizza Company. Everything is made fresh. Meatballs are great and the hoagies are delicious. Also their Cincinatus pizza puts a whole new spin on my favorite chili. Visit them, you won’t be disappointed.“

“Wonderful group of ppl with some awesome pizza and calzones. Only thing I wish they also had would be some wings but other than that great experience with my coworkers from Central Window Cleaning out of Columbus“

“We ate there a month ago for the first time, and one of the guys working told me he was sure we'd be back again. He was so right, it's worth the hour drive! They definitely have the New York City pizza touch.“

“Went here for a online order pickup on 12126 got the correct order. It was amazing. The restaurant was very empty at the time I walked right up. Seen a young man. He got my name. Checked the food. It looked good. He passed it on. All was great. The online experience was so easy to order from. The in-store experience was great and the food afterwards was as expected top notch“

“We had 4 different pizzas, street corn, crab Ragoon, ricotta and hot honey and figgy. They were all delicious. We look forward to coming back!! Thank you“

“While visiting the Cincinnati area, we ordered pizza from La Rosa's! From the encounter on the telephone where I received impeccable customer service, to the very kind, efficient and professional delivery driver, to the most delicious and affordable pizza we've tasted! Our family was very happy to eat Larosa's Pizza! It's a shame that we don't live here because Larosa's is our new favorite pizza joint!“

“One of the best pieces in Cincinnati, Ohio, beautiful“

“The pizza was absolutely delicious! Kara, our waitress and bartender, was amazing — friendly, attentive, and made the whole experience even better. Highly recommend this place!“

“I am so disappointed and embarrassed. I had family coming from out of state. 3 hours before they arrived we ordered a cheese pizza and grape walnut salad for our vegetarian family. We went to pick up the pizza 3 hours later. When we got back with the pizza,we found that it was a pepperoni pizza. The salad was not grape walnut, but it was topped with bacon. It was too late to switch out due to the fact that they were already waiting on dinner! So disappointed! I cannot reccomend them any more.“

“Coming all the way from Houston to try this pizza among other things was definitely one of the highlights to my trip.
Pizza looked so good I didn't even take the time to take a picture of it.
I had a small Deep dish pizza with chicken spinach n jalapenos. Hats off to the chef because that was the best pizza I've had in a long time n I'm a very picky eater. Saucey cheesy and delicious.“

“We randomly ate Big Dog’s Pizza at my daughter’s school, as they were the food vendor for the “Family Picnic Night”. It’s been three days, and I can’t stop thinking about their pickle pizza. We got ours without onion and without bacon, and I swear it’s the best one I’ve been able to find in Cincinnati. We also ordered cheese curds and pretzels with cheese. All of the food was really, really good! I’m hoping to find them again this week for another pizza! 🥒🍕“

“Hometown food and more. Miss the popcorn but still a fav“

“Classic Americana and textbook friendly neighborhood bar-restaurant! Newtown Village Tavern pizza is everything LaRosa’s wishes it was and it is the superior “Cincinnati Pie” in every way. Cold beer on tap, sports on the tube. What more could you want?“

“Hands down, best hoagie I have EVER had! Pizza was AMAZING!! And he has some homemade Cincinnati style chili in there!!!!!!!! 100/10 recommend visiting Village Pizza Sharonville!!“

“If you haven’t had a steak hoagie from Jacob’s Pizza, you truly do not know what you’re missing!“

“Just got my pizza
Ordered 16” pepperoni
Only half has pepperoni

I’m still gonna eat it because it’s good but I’m sad it’s not all pep

All other times it’s perfect“

“Fantastic atmosphere, employees. Appetizers were great, Pizza was fantastic. Definitely give this place a try! If we weren't from 5 hours away this would be our go to spot...“

“I grew up eating this pizza. The thin crust with the sauce and cheese as the base and the toppings on top is unique and delicious. The pizza is cut into small squares which makes it easier to eat without dropping the toppings. They have been a delicious treat for me for over 50 years.“

“Had Lucy Blue last night for our Friday Happy Hour. So delicious. Especially love the Lucy Blue tomato sauce!“

“This place was great. Tried it for the first time yesterday. Our waitress was top notch (thank you Rachel)! But also the food was great, and the beer went down great as well. Sounds weird, but try the Grape, Gorgonzola, and Rosemary pizza! Delicious! Have them drizzle vinaigrette on it as well! Was delicious!“

“My 7 year old grandson and I go here for our "date nights". The staff is always super friendly and prompt. The food it hot and delicious. I highly recommend this place.“

“Fun activity and good beer selection“

“We love Ali’s!! The food is great. The atmosphere is relaxed, clean, and fun for all ages. And the staff is amazing!! What’s not to love there? Ali is a staple of our community and she puts everything she has info her business and her customers. That’s the best part.“