12 Best Bakeries near New Carlisle

Cake Creations Bakery • $
11983 W National Rd, New Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Mixed Cupcakes Peanut Butter Red Velvet Reeses Lots of Choices When You Go In
1 4 Chocolate Sheet Cake with Whipped Icing
Hand Made Power Ranger Birthday Cake
The Bomb Apple Fritter
Chocolate Cupcake
Cookie

“We used them for our wedding back in October 2024 and was absolutely delicious! We did a small round cake and cupcakes and was a huge hit, amazingly priced and seriously the best cake and cupcakes I've ever had! 100000% recommend them!“

4.8 Superb47 Reviews
Crumbl - Huber Heights Bakery • $
8288 Old Troy Pike, Huber Heights - 7.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oreo Bday Cake Cookie Cinnamon Cookie Maple Cookie
NY Cheesecake Chocolate Chip Cookie Birthday Cake
Peanut Butter and Jelly
Four Gormet Cookies
Key Lime Pie
Mini 12-Pack
Mini 3-Pack
Party Box
Doughnut
4-Pack

“The cookies are always amazing. But just had the Butter Cake and that is the best thing I have EVER eaten!!!

Parking: Enough parking

Kid-friendliness: Everyone friendly. Smells amazing inside

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible“

4.7 Superb335 Reviews
The Neighborhood Nest Gluten-Free Baked Goods, LLC Bakery • $
313 W Main St, Fairborn - 7.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Chocolate Cake with GF Macarons
Gluten Free Birthday Cake with GF Macarons
Mini Pineapple Upside Down
Butter Cream Birthday Cake
Little Chocolate Roll
Apple Cinnamon Muffin
Wedding Cupcakes
Strawberry Donut
Cherry Cordial
Dulce De Leche

“Quaint and charming bakery with some of the nicest staff! My kids loved the strawberry donuts and cupcakes...and I think the cinnamon rolls are ::chef's kiss::“

4.9 Superb80 Reviews
Schwebel's Bakery • $
1306 Brandt Pike, Dayton - 11.85 miles

“Those Tots mini donuts are SO goooood.Awesome bread selection- of course. The crock pot seasoning packets ( Pork & Beef are my faves ) Sooooo good.Snacks from JJs, UTZ, Hostess & Little Duchess cookies will satisfy any sweet tooth or need for crunch.I miss the Cinci store.“

4.7 Superb42 Reviews
Fur the Luv of Dogs Bakery Bakery • $$
317 W Garland Ave, Fairborn - 8.97 miles

“Kind people. Amazing treats for the puppies. Highly recommend.“

4.8 Superb32 Reviews
Yellow Springs Baking Company Bakery • $
305 N Walnut St, Yellow Springs - 11.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cranberry & White Chocolate Scone
Chocolate Croissant
Chicken Empanada
Veggie Empanada
Almond Croissant
Blueberry Scone
Beef Empanadas
Cinnamon Roll

“I had never been in before and tried one of your iced cinnamon rolls. It was SO good! Delicious with light icing that was tasty and totally complemented the roll without being heavy or greasy! Looking forward to my next visit!“

4.6 Superb19 Reviews
Stevens Orchard Bakery • $$
7344 Thackery Rd, Springfield - 9.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Apple

“We absolutely love this family owned apple orchard.“

4.5 Superb14 Reviews
La Michoacana Mexican Market #10 Mexican • $
6220 Chambersburg Rd, Dayton - 7.89 miles

“Many many items to choose from!“

4.4 Superb78 Reviews
Bootleg Bagels Bakery •
1310 Shawnee Dr, Yellow Springs - 12.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bagel

“we LOVE these bagels! we have had bagels for breakfast, bagel sandwiches, bagels as snacks, and bagel desserts. if shrimp is the fruit of the sea, bootleg bagels are the fruit of our kitchen. thanks BB!!“

5 Superb4 Reviews
Panaderia El Ranchito Bakery • $
2528 Valley Pike, Dayton - 11.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“wow the cake we had at The Cottages of Clayton. delicious.“

3.8 Good22 Reviews
Kona Ice of Central Dayton Ice Cream • $
Dayton - 8.89 miles

“Our school has been using Kona Ice for several years now. We booked them for Friday before spring break and had to make a change due to the rain. Sarah and Molly quickly made some adjustments to their schedule, helped us advertise the change, and still were able to accommodate all of the prepay orders. This team is wonderful to work with and provide everything you need to make your function a huge success. Thank you Kona team for taking care of our students.“

5 Superb16 Reviews
Matria Patisserie former La pampa mobile gril Bakery • $
600 Dayton St, Yellow Springs - 11.26 miles

“Tried Matria pastries at the Second Street Market and they were delicious! The non traditional pain au chocolat had a scrumptious brownie in the middle for extra chocolate. And the German chocolate cherry had a layer of cherries inside. Scrumptious!“

3 Average2 Reviews