50 Best American Restaurants near New Middletown

“First time here! Came in a little more than an hour before closing. End of their busy hour, seated promptly and waitress was very accommodating and sweet! Ordered cheeseburger platter and also the honey mustard chicken sandwich with fries! Honey mustard chicken sandwich was very good! Next time I get it, I’ll ask for no tomato as it was messy. Entirely on me. Bacon on the sandwich was perfect.

Both platters were nicely presented! If we had to complain about one thing, it would be that the burger didn’t seem to have any seasoning. Would have been nice if it had a little more flavor, but overall not a bad sandwich.

Love the batter dipped french fries fries they were very good!

The wait was a little long, about 35 minutes! Everything was very hot tho, which made up for the wait!

Definitely will be back and can’t wait to bring my husband with me to try out some of their other selections.“

“I love there burgers, a bit sweet and topped with an olive. Always fresh and hot. The shakes are good and the variety of flavors are great. I am a traditional chocolate lover but opt for the flavor of the month. I am never disappointed 😋“

“Our favorite to go place Everything from appetizers, meals , desserts & beverages- amazing!“

“Wonderful luncheon menu everything full of flavor and very filling price point was perfect“

“Josie’s is my go-to restaurant in town. The staff is super friendly, food is reasonably priced, generously portioned, and delicious to top it all off!“

“Very good wine, food and cake! My first time there. Server was very gracious. Atmosphere was relaxing. Will definitely be back! A gem in a small town!“

“Met there for a group meal. Good location “not far off the beaten path”. The main dining area was busy and lively. The separate meeting room was small but perfectly sized for our group of 20-30. The waitress was incredibly attentive to our drink and food orders, and the meals were served quickly after ordering. I had spaghetti and meatballs which, judging by the way everyone else raved about their meals, was a mistake. My meal was fine, but lacked any distinguishing flavor — just so-so. If I go again, I’ll steer clear of the Italian food and go for a meat or fish dish.“

“Been here twice going and coming back from Pigeon Forge. Food and service is fabulous! Highly recommend and will be back.“

“Been coming here many years with family on our way back home to pa to see family and this is always our first stop before we go“

“Had the best time in their beautifully decorated igloo. Wonderful food and service.“

“My son reserved the larger room for his engagement party. It was perfect. The staff was wonderful to work with, the food, drinks, decor…all fantastic. We had a wonderful time. It could not have been nicer. Thank you so much for everything you did to make our evening so memorable.“

“This is the best family owned restaurant in town. You get to know the regulars and the staff who are fantastic. We go every weekend and love everything about it. The food is great and the prices are good. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants a close, family style place to dine.“

“You can’t beat a meal at Knoll Run Golf Course. I believe now it is officially called The Double Eagle at Knoll Run. I’ve been here more that a few times & have never had a bad meal or experience. They have some awesome hamburgers & pasta dishes. I was craving a deli sandwich this day & was interestedto see what they offered. I saw a Philly steak sandwich and know that was the winner. Our seating options were tables or at the bar, I figured a beer with my sandwich would be nice, so we chose the bar. The barmaids/servers were very cool, we had playful banter & they were very friendly. They took our drink & food orders & had our beers out quick. A few minutes later our orders were up, my Philly steak was perfectly prepared. A nice heaping of steak, lots of cheese, nicely sautéd onions on a toasted hoagie bun. I very much enjoyed my sandwich & beverage , even had a couple more beers for good measure. I must say that I really liked the atmosphere as well, a good crowd of locals, everyone was in a good mood & it felt like cool local bar. I noticed at least 5 TV’s, so definitely a good place to enjoy the game & great food. The bar was also properly stocked, I’m certain that they have your favorite beer or liquor. Again, this is one of my local haunts, so stop in and check it out, you won’t be disappointed.“

“The food is fantastic. I also like the atmosphere“

“I grab SM when I am in Boardman and always wished it was in Trumbull county..I tried the Howland location today wonderful food very fresh and quick during lunch hour!!! Also thank you Riley for answering any questions I had!“

“We had an event at the hotel that required not only catering but audio visual equipment. The staff was great to work with and made sure we had what we needed. The ballroom was perfect and they listened to our requests. Food was served on time and they helped us have a fantastic event. Would not hesitate to go back for the next one!“

“The second best steak I’ve ever had in my lifetime. Great service and selection of food/drinks. A definite recommendation.“

“❤️ the arancini and V2 salad“

“Hot dogs are excellent here. The famous dog has very tasty chili.. The cheese dogs with liquid cheese are to die for. Fries can be a little bit greasy buuuut they're French fries. This is the way. Everyone who is complaining about grease is used to how fast food joints leave them in the tray. My fries were freshly prepared. Plus if Chris Yambar liked them you know they're good“

“Megan the queen always knows got a cute hat on and always is friendly! She has my drink already being made before I touch my seat she’s always on it! Megan is the best!“

“I am biased but think the DC and the staff are amazing! Can’t wait to watch this keep growing to bring more healthy products to our community!!“

“I had a 5-star experience at this location. My server, Samantha, was wonderful
She knew exactly what to recommend, showing both excellent menu knowledge and the ability to read her guests.

I ordered the filet mignon from the premium cuts menu, and I have to say, it was cooked to perfection. In my experience, medium-rare steaks often come out either overcooked or underdone, but the chef here truly knew what they were doing. It was spot-on.

I personally enjoy A1 steak sauce with my steak, and usually I can’t eat steak without it. But this filet was so flavorful that I barely used any sauce at all, and honestly, it would have been just as delicious without it.

The food looked as good as it tasted, and the décor created a very pleasant dining atmosphere. What really stood out, though, was the service. Managers were walking around greeting guests, checking on servers, and making sure meals were enjoyable. You could tell the staff genuinely cared about their work and even seemed to enjoy it.

Thank you, LongHorn, Samantha, and the chef, for a truly wonderful dining experience. I would absolutely recommend this restaurant 100%.“

“This establishment came from a recommendation from the clerks at Target!! One of the best breakfast places in Youngstown!! Hands down!!! If you're in Youngstown/Boardman area, don't bother with IHOP or the new Dennys. C's is the place!!! Service was incredible!! Best eatery in a while“

“Natural herbs have cured so many illnesses that drugs and injection cant cure. I've seen the great importance of natural herbs and the wonderful work they have done in people's lives. I read people's testimonies online on how they were cured of herpes, hiv, diabetics etc by Dr. MOMOH herbal medicine, so I decided to contact the doctor because I know nature has the power to heal anything. I was diagnosed with hiv for the past 7 years but Dr. Momoh cured me with his herbs and I referred my aunt and her husband to him immediately because they were both suffering from herpes and they were cured too .I know it is hard to believe but I am a living testimony. There is no harm trying herbs. He is also a spell caster, he casts spells to restore broken marriages and good luck spells to prosper and excel in life. Contact Dr MOMOH“

“First place I ever recommend to anyone new to, or visiting, the area! Fantastic atmosphere, food & service.“

“All five stars? Well, it must have been Saturday, I must have gotten a rack of ribs with extra sauce that were smoky good, and the bartender must have done a great job taking my order and getting me a beer.

Seriously, I was absolutely impressed by the ribs. Cooked over charcoal or wood because the smoke ring was perfect, as were the ribs. No fat (NO fat!) and just a slight char on the ends. There are a lot of great rib joints around Youngstown, and since it's harder and harder to find roast lamb on Saturdays, ribs are my safety pick. The ribs at the Royal Oaks were perfect, better after I got them home and slapped them in a casserole and baked at 250 tightly wrapped for like 40 minutes. Absolutely great flavor that will impress anyone who likes a nice rack of ribs.
(A comma can change the meaning of a sentence, but not always) $25 for just a rack, no sides.“

“It’s like walking in a candy land in Danalyn’s Tindahan. Food is excellent“

“2nd time our friends group met there Excellent service Delicious food and prices are very reasonable“

“As first time customers to any Twin Peaks, we had a 100/10 visit! We noticed the 29° cold beer sign and that was our cue to visit. The hostesses were kind, the food was delicious and the beer was COLD- that was the seller to return, then we met Emma, our waitress! Emma was beautifully kind inside and out. I could have given a lesser review only because of the “attitude” of the hostesses and a few other waitresses but Emma made it 100%. We will be back to visit Emma! I hope she sees this and is recognized for her over the top customer service and kindness!“

“The cigar bar is the best! Thursday nights with friends and great service and staff make it the best night of the week.“

“Visited Crickets while in town for YLive. Food and service were both amazing! the pomegranate honey flavored wings and Handel’s ice cream/brownie were so so good! Our server Katie was top notch!! We are looking forward to our next visit!“

“This was our first time visiting and we will definitely be back! Valerie was so friendly and helpful! The food was delicious! We had the lamb dinner, lasagna roll-ups, and filet tip sandwich - made with locally-sourced meats and vegetables! 10/10 recommend!“

“Thank you so much for our wonderful cupcakes for our wedding! They looked, and tasted absolutely amazing!! She was so quick to accommodate us for our out of town wedding; she had just taken them Out of the oven when his niece and nephew came to pick them up, she entrusted us to take the muffin tins up so no one would have to wait. She has gone above and beyond, we will continue to recommend Maggie to everyone!!“

“This is our 3rd time having dinner here, the food is outstanding! Wings are flavorful and crunchy and the Philly is delicious!“

“Would highly recommend to everyone I know as long as Jen is not working. She is bottom of the barrel. she is rude, loud and fowl mouthed. There is nothing professional about her. She talks about others non stop and shouldn't be in the public. The owner could care less. He allows this to go on. Makes for a very uncomfortable setting. Lisa is by far the fastest friendliest waitress in Ohio. There is another waitress there that is amazing I do not remember her name but her husband cooks there. Have never had bad food but the owner needs to get Jen under control or out of there before he loses employees and customers.“

“A friend and I went and we had there Tuesday Pizza Special. An 18 inch pizza with 3 toppings of your choice, a family sized mixed garden salad, and endless Soft Drink refills for $22. A very reasonable deal and their Pizza is right up my alley. It's a thin crusted pie and their sauce is more on a sweeter side than Tart.
In an area that has wonderful Local Pizza Shops they compete very well. 👍“

“Food was ok service was horrible waited 5 min to be seated with only 12 customer's people were waiting just as long to pay their bill waited half an hour for food to come then my food was barely warm and my dates order was wrong will never return to that store again“

“Worst service I've had in a while. We waited so long for our food and they served people that came after us long before we finally got ours. This place is definitely much different than the original. Pricing on food was stupid and somehow it cost almost $40 for a few basic sandwiches and a lemonade. Won't be back“

“We eat here a lot ,, last night we dined here again ,food is great 😋
But ,ordered a piece of carrot cake to take home ,was good ,but it was extremely SMALL, I would have thought that for $9 it would have been shareable, it werent !“

“Karaoke is awesome. me and my coworkers favorite spot! super cool guy owns the place, and the guy that runs karaoke is phenomenal. plus kim the bartender is like no other. if you neet her you'll understand lol.“

“We had a beautiful party at the club last night. The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Thank you for a memorable evening.“

“This place has me in a chokehold…..I mean literally. We are newbies and the waitresses already know our drinks and more than likely what we are ordering. Love this place no I won’t tell a lot of people about it because I’m selfish and I don’t want nobody taking over my new favorite place 🥰🙄“

“At first glance you wouldn't even know this place exists in the back of a gas station. It's cool they have a little bar too! I was hesitant to try the food thinking it would be gas station food but ill tell you what it was darn good! I had an excellent salad and gyro. close go to especially if your staying at the hotel nearby. Give it a shot!“

“First of all, welcome to historic and homey! This place is our go to for some awesome pizza!!! They have a great selection of food and beers. The atmosphere, side conversations, and of course on the bartenders, MAGGIE, are absolutely something to experience. One app recommendation would be the hot pepper cheese balls! Also the pizza sauce is made with green peppers, so be prepared for flavor. This place is ALSO from 1945. So stop, love it, come back.“

“Food was phenomenal and staff was awesome. Highly recommend.“

“Today was my first time eating here and I ordered 'The Tavern', as was recommended to me by an employee, and it was delicious! I'll definitely be back!“

“Fridays fish special was excellent service was also excellent and management was very friendly. Can’t wait to go back to try their wing special. Would highly recommended it.“

“We always start our golf weekend here, nice course and Another Round is a great place to have drinks and food for the 19th hole.“

“I ordered a Philly beef sandwich & my son got the grilled chicken sandwich, they were big & delicious! They gave more than enough fries & onion rings too! Our waitress was very kind & attentive. We needed takeout containers because we couldn't that much food!! Very reasonably priced even if you're on a budget.“

“Pretzel for appetizer - chicken tenders fries and chips with dip was delicious! Alissa/Alyssa/Aliessa Marie - our server was great! Took great care of us and we will absolutely return ❤️“