50 Best American Restaurants near New Middletown

“Friendly service, great breakfast and squeaky clean dining room! French toast was delightful as were the crispy hash browns. All the staff were warm and welcoming to us first timers, and everyone that walked through the door. Daisy was our server and she was exceptional. We will definitely return!“

“I'm not too sure what Ella is speaking about but I can’t say enough great things about our experience at Swenson’s, and it’s all thanks to our phenomenal waiter, Matty C! From the moment we arrived, Matty went above and beyond to make sure we had a perfect dining experience. Their energy was contagious, their attention to detail was impeccable, and their kindness made us feel truly valued as customers. They anticipated our needs before we even had to ask, offered fantastic recommendations, and made the entire meal seamless and enjoyable. It’s rare to find someone who is not only excellent at their job but also radiates such warmth and enthusiasm. If you’re lucky enough to have Matty as your server, you’re in for an unforgettable experience! Swenson’s is lucky to have them!“

“Traveling through town and staying at hotel close by. Tired and grabbed what was closest. Picked up a Club sandwich and appetizer. All was good but the Club sandwich was one of the best- the bun and pesto mayo was amazing flavors. Wish they weren’t five hours away from me; I’d be back to try more.“

“Our favorite to go place Everything from appetizers, meals , desserts & beverages- amazing!“

“Visited the Boardman, OH location and Annelyse was the best waitress Her kindness and her service was 5 star!! She made our experience so great visiting our son from college!!“

“Josie’s is my go-to restaurant in town. The staff is super friendly, food is reasonably priced, generously portioned, and delicious to top it all off!“

“I love this place great fish in my opinion“

“Very good wine, food and cake! My first time there. Server was very gracious. Atmosphere was relaxing. Will definitely be back! A gem in a small town!“

“Had a soup n crab cake. Yummy on A cold night, Hit the spot. Hard to believe I was in the Yo- so good, great service too.“

“Met there for a group meal. Good location “not far off the beaten path”. The main dining area was busy and lively. The separate meeting room was small but perfectly sized for our group of 20-30. The waitress was incredibly attentive to our drink and food orders, and the meals were served quickly after ordering. I had spaghetti and meatballs which, judging by the way everyone else raved about their meals, was a mistake. My meal was fine, but lacked any distinguishing flavor — just so-so. If I go again, I’ll steer clear of the Italian food and go for a meat or fish dish.“

“I like O Charley s Restaurant they have good food, the waitresses are very nice I just went there to day“

“This is the best family owned restaurant in town. You get to know the regulars and the staff who are fantastic. We go every weekend and love everything about it. The food is great and the prices are good. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants a close, family style place to dine.“

“The food is fantastic. I also like the atmosphere“

“You can’t beat a meal at Knoll Run Golf Course. I believe now it is officially called The Double Eagle at Knoll Run. I’ve been here more that a few times & have never had a bad meal or experience. They have some awesome hamburgers & pasta dishes. I was craving a deli sandwich this day & was interestedto see what they offered. I saw a Philly steak sandwich and know that was the winner. Our seating options were tables or at the bar, I figured a beer with my sandwich would be nice, so we chose the bar. The barmaids/servers were very cool, we had playful banter & they were very friendly. They took our drink & food orders & had our beers out quick. A few minutes later our orders were up, my Philly steak was perfectly prepared. A nice heaping of steak, lots of cheese, nicely sautéd onions on a toasted hoagie bun. I very much enjoyed my sandwich & beverage , even had a couple more beers for good measure. I must say that I really liked the atmosphere as well, a good crowd of locals, everyone was in a good mood & it felt like cool local bar. I noticed at least 5 TV’s, so definitely a good place to enjoy the game & great food. The bar was also properly stocked, I’m certain that they have your favorite beer or liquor. Again, this is one of my local haunts, so stop in and check it out, you won’t be disappointed.“

“Fresh and delicious! Highly recommend.“

“We had a great time. Not your ordinary food but something special. The bathrooms are beautiful as well as the plants. Three of us had salmon and it was delicous!“

“Excellent service great atmosphere.Great food. Although the Elk was ruined by peppercorns that made my tender tasty steak unbearably crunchy. I had srcape them off as much as I could. I'd recommend it to anyone, just not the peppercorns.“

“❤️ the arancini and V2 salad“

“I am biased but think the DC and the staff are amazing! Can’t wait to watch this keep growing to bring more healthy products to our community!!“

“First time going here and definitely not disappointed. I went in and ordered a Hungry Jack to go. Homefries were so good, eggs cooked perfect, French toast was delicious, my side of thick toast was great. An excellent breakfast that was affordable. I think my server was Jess, she was awesome, I hope I get her next time I go back. Great service and great food (thank the cook).“

“Awesome Hotdogs!!! Very flavorful, not garlicky, cooked perfectly too. The chili was very good, albeit strange!! (shredded hotdog pieces in it). Fries were also really tasty.
Staff was also friendly. $5 credit card minimum enforced.“

“My husband and I very much enjoyed the food. Our server was excellent! (Sorry, I don't remember her name.) However, we have one suggestion that would have made this a 5-star review. Please consider installing sound dampening panels. Even during the quieter moments, the combined cacophony of TV and customers talking was overwhelmingly LOUD. If there were more items on the walls and especially a few panels on the ceiling, it would help absorb the noise.“

“We had an event at the hotel that required not only catering but audio visual equipment. The staff was great to work with and made sure we had what we needed. The ballroom was perfect and they listened to our requests. Food was served on time and they helped us have a fantastic event. Would not hesitate to go back for the next one!“

“I was in the Boardman area to buy a car. It was getting late my wife had lunch and I had a snack before the 1.5 hr. drive., so after the purchase I googled restraunts near me . I thought everything was delicious, the fries are saltier than I would have liked. Now my wife thought everything was over seasoned for her liking, She scraped some off her food . I was satisfied with everything and our waitress was outstanding, checking on us quite frequently.“

“this place has the best food, I ever put in my mouth“

“The cigar bar is the best! Thursday nights with friends and great service and staff make it the best night of the week.“

“Natural herbs have cured so many illnesses that drugs and injection cant cure. I've seen the great importance of natural herbs and the wonderful work they have done in people's lives. I read people's testimonies online on how they were cured of herpes, hiv, diabetics etc by Dr. MOMOH herbal medicine, so I decided to contact the doctor because I know nature has the power to heal anything. I was diagnosed with hiv for the past 7 years but Dr. Momoh cured me with his herbs and I referred my aunt and her husband to him immediately because they were both suffering from herpes and they were cured too .I know it is hard to believe but I am a living testimony. There is no harm trying herbs. He is also a spell caster, he casts spells to restore broken marriages and good luck spells to prosper and excel in life. Contact Dr MOMOH“

“My first visit definitely not my last.Salted Carmel Muffin Coffee paired so well with ButterPecan Coffee.*****“

“Karaoke is awesome. me and my coworkers favorite spot! super cool guy owns the place, and the guy that runs karaoke is phenomenal. plus kim the bartender is like no other. if you neet her you'll understand lol.“

“Working here for two years has been the most invigorating, rewarding time of my life. The owners and management staff are always willing to help and teach. I’m forever grateful to call this place my second home! #hulkamania #stevenshear #wrappunch #howsthistvwork #thepriceisright #wherestheschedule #bradscheeseplate #heybartender Love you all to bits and pieces! My forever home !!!!!“

“First place I ever recommend to anyone new to, or visiting, the area! Fantastic atmosphere, food & service.“

“Amazing food Amazing people“

“I wish we had gas stations like this in PA! Had a gyro it was fantastic and got a piece of baklava to take homa it was the best I've ever had my whole life. I want to go back amd try the rice bowls

Kid-friendliness: Thay have a full Kids menu“

“Loved fish night here, wanna come back on wing night. Food was so good.“

“When you ask someone where are the best burgers in Youngstown you should definitely try here. Where can you go for $20, 2 burgers 2 fries, and 2 beers? I say WHAT, WHAT!!! Chrissy our server, was wonderful. Nice cozy atmosphere. Nice mix of neighborhood people.“

“If you know you know best barbecue in town... great atmosphere one of those places you don't find too much anymore..... Everybody's friends and everybody knows your name... Still bringing live music a lot of bands that people don't know but need to be heard they've always been on The cutting edge I would highly recommend this place if you want to go try some ribs or wings hear a good band or drink a Pabst Blue ribbon... This is the place these guys are like family“

“I ordered a Philly beef sandwich & my son got the grilled chicken sandwich, they were big & delicious! They gave more than enough fries & onion rings too! Our waitress was very kind & attentive. We needed takeout containers because we couldn't that much food!! Very reasonably priced even if you're on a budget.“

“Worst service I've had in a while. We waited so long for our food and they served people that came after us long before we finally got ours. This place is definitely much different than the original. Pricing on food was stupid and somehow it cost almost $40 for a few basic sandwiches and a lemonade. Won't be back“

“I live in Bowling Green Ky. and was in town visiting family when I mentioned how bad pizza and wings are in BG so my parents took me here. It is kind of small inside but clean and the server had a great personality. I got hot wings and pizza and let me tell you this place was worth the 7-hour drive.

Parking: Plenty of parking across the street.“

“Today was my first time eating here and I ordered 'The Tavern', as was recommended to me by an employee, and it was delicious! I'll definitely be back!“

“The Endress and Feld families would like to thank Haley and Todd for helping us make Kathylynn’s celebration of life so special. Haley was so kind in helping us pick out the perfect menu. Todd is an excellent chef. Everyone enjoyed all the food (it was all very fresh and tasty). We definitely recommend them for any party or gathering you may have. It was nice having our family gathering in Kathylynn’s home, surrounded by all of our memories. Haley and Todd made it even more special. Thank you again.“

“I don’t live in the area BUT every time I visit the area PB here I come. Do forget they have 1/2 off on wings Sun and Mondays. Also they have a membership please join it. Finally while at the airport by all means go by the restaurant and grab a sandwich. Don’t forget to get your condiments because that’s on you to ask for. I have never been able to eat their sandwich in one setting.“

“Great place to bring family and friends. Been coming here for over 40 years. I mean it when I say all the food is good. You don’t have to worry about choosing something new.“

“I’m an extremely picky eater and this was the best burger I’ve ever had. Adriana was super friendly and attentive even though they were a little busy at first and I can’t recommend coming here more!

Vegetarian options: Black bean burger option“

“My faith in wing preparation has been restored. During the pandemic, most place I tried wings at, the wings were very dry, which means they were overcooked, and I mean a LOT. But, Town and country has renewed my faith in the process. Their wings are juicy, yet fully cooked(no pink or red near the bone). I'm not a HOT wing fan, and their mild buffalo are outstanding, but a friend I produced me to a new dry rub that is even better. I'm a huge Cajun fan, and their Cajun dry rub hit the spot dead center. Even though it's a dry rub, it doesn't dry out the meat, which is huge. I most definitely be back to my new favorite wing joint, ESPECIALLY if they put Blue Moon on tap(hint, hint).“

“Great view, great food, beautiful venue! What a great way to relax. You don't have to be a golfer to enjoy it here!“

“Food was ok service was horrible waited 5 min to be seated with only 12 customer's people were waiting just as long to pay their bill waited half an hour for food to come then my food was barely warm and my dates order was wrong will never return to that store again“

“We went here on a whim it was very good I had the fish sandwich it was Delicious very good waitress nice atmosphere you could tell it was a local hang out very friendly people!“

“Food as always was amazing. We had to wait very long for our table and then longer still for the waitress to take our order. We weren't in a hurry which was good but there were a lot of other diners complaining about how slow everything was going.“

“Would highly recommend to everyone I know as long as Jen is not working. She is bottom of the barrel. she is rude, loud and fowl mouthed. There is nothing professional about her. She talks about others non stop and shouldn't be in the public. The owner could care less. He allows this to go on. Makes for a very uncomfortable setting. Lisa is by far the fastest friendliest waitress in Ohio. There is another waitress there that is amazing I do not remember her name but her husband cooks there. Have never had bad food but the owner needs to get Jen under control or out of there before he loses employees and customers.“