Beer Bars in New Philadelphia, OH

Mustards @ The Wine Rack Beer Bar • $
150 S Broadway St, New Philadelphia

“Food: 5/5Service: 4/5Ambiance: 4/5My friend and I decided to pop into Mustards after a quick game of pickleball at the Tuscora Park. I have been here a few times for some wine (which is always delicious, btw) but this was my first time sitting down for a full meal. Instead of wine today, I went for the fruit beer they currently have on tap. I was too quick to take a sip or two before snapping the pic, but it was delicious! We split the Bavarian soft pretzels which I would HIGHLY recommend. They were warm and soft and come with a delicious dipping mustard with a thick texture. I ordered The Wall Street, which is Mustard's take on a Reuben. It was definitely one of the better ones I have had; each ingredient ratio was perfect (some places go a little too heavy on the sauerkraut imo). My friend ordered the Tummy Pleaser. She said it was also delicious and was a perfect light sandwich to order if you're not looking for anything too heavy. The sizes of each dish were also quite reasonable for the price, as you can see from the photos.Our server was kind and timely, but did not provide any sort of exceptional service. Just the basics. The atmosphere inside is rather calm and warm. I'm giving only 4 stars because of the music; I love 90s rap, but it does not fit the vibe. Overall, I would definitely recommend Mustards if you're looking for a low key lunch or some drinks!“

4.8 Superb24 Reviews