Restaurants near New Straitsville

Browse menus, reviews and photos of the best places to eat near New Straitsville.

Showing 30 of 30 restaurants

Bar · $
1 1884 New Straitsville Moonshine Co

5.0 Superb 8 Reviews

105 West Main Street, New Straitsville
- Delivery
- Drive-Through
“Highly recommend New Straitsville Moonshine Co. The atmosphere is very relaxing . We hosted our annual Christmas party at the NS Moonshine Co this past weekend and it was perfect with plenty of room for everyone. Rich Stephanie and Tonya made us feel so welcome the entire night helping us with anything we needed and was very quick with serving such a big crowd. We definitely look forward to spending many more weekends at the New Straitsville Moonshine Co. Parking: Street parking in front of the NS Moonshine Co and there is also parking across the street and beside the building”
Menu
Salad · $
2 Little Italy Pizza

4.0 Good 104 Reviews

110 West Main Street, New Straitsville
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Cheesy Potato
- Cheesy Bread
- Pepperoni Cheese and Mushroom Pizza
- Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
“We order a few times a month from Little Italy in New Straitville. It's also very fresh and the delivery drivers are also so kind and appreciative of any tip! We love the dill pickle pizza and the Cheesy potato pizza 🍕 The cheesy bread is also 10/10 !”
Menu Order
Bar & Grill · $
3 The Mine Tavern

4.6 Superb 228 Reviews

14 Public Square, Nelsonville · 8.13 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- The Mine Burger
- Onion Rings
- Hamburger
- A Craft Beer They Put Out Different Craft Beers and Rotate Out Frequently
“The Mine Tavern is owned, operated and staffed by some of the best people around. They always support the community , you can tell how much love and pride they have for Nelsonville. They offer mouth watering food and beverages in a fun and friendly atmosphere!”
Menu Order
Cafe · $
4 FullBrooks Cafe

4.7 Superb 123 Reviews

6 Public Square, Nelsonville · 8.14 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Bagel
- Scone
- Egg Sandwich
- Egg and Cheese in Wheat Toast and Caramel Macchiato
“Absolutely unbelievable, best tasting lemon blueberry scone I’ve ever had. FullBrooks never disappoints, what I love most is you never know who you’re going to run into while grabbing coffee. Love this little cafe.”
Menu
Barbecue · $
5 Starbrick BBQ

4.6 Superb 156 Reviews

45 East Canal Street, Nelsonville · 8.26 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Chips
- Brisket Sandwich
- Side Salad
- Mac N Cheese
“The best BBQ around, the servers are really sweet and the food is amazing 👏 🤩”
Menu
Pizza · $
6 Pizza Place & Restaurant

4.5 Superb 235 Reviews

100 West Broadway Street, New Lexington · 9.95 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Pepperoni Pizza
- Everyone's Favorite Chef Salad
- Tossed Salad
- Lasagna
“I love the food never had a bad experience”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
7 Dodson's On Broadway

4.5 Superb 240 Reviews

313 West Broadway Street, New Lexington · 9.89 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Meal
- Chicken Livers
- Hot
- Taco
“Love the people and the food. Great place to eat”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
8 Alfonso's Italian Kitchen & Bakery

4.8 Superb 76 Reviews

19 West Columbus Street, Nelsonville · 8.15 miles
- Delivery
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Strawberry Shortcake
- Meatball Parmigiana
- Cheesecake
“the food is great and the bread pudding is well worth it”
Menu Order
Family · $
9 Tammy's Country Kitchen

4.5 Superb 270 Reviews

1333 East Canal Street, Nelsonville · 9.41 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Sandwich
- Mushroom Swiss Burger
- Biscuits and Gravy
- Sausage Gravy
“Absolutely love Tammy’s! Nice size portions, friendly wait service, great prices. Best country diner I’ve ever ate at. Very busy little place, which means good food.”
Menu Order
Fine Dining · $$
10 Rhapsody Restaurant

4.4 Superb 338 Reviews

18 Public Square, Nelsonville · 8.12 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Beignets
- Pan Seared Scallops Orange Beur Blonc and Fish and Chips
- Spinach Artichoke Dip
- Hot Fudge Spoon Cake
“Fresh delicious and balanced!”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
11 Stan's Bake Shop

4.8 Superb 55 Reviews

111 West Broadway Street, New Lexington · 9.92 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Regular Donuts
“Stan’s bake shop made me four dozen beautiful chocolate and vanilla cupcakes with buttercream icing for a baby shower. They looked irresistible, so I had to try them before the event and they were delicious. The buttercream frosting was perfect and the cake very moist. The cost was fair for the quality. I’m sure the guests will enjoy them.”
Menu
Gastropubs · $
12 Black Diamond Tavern

4.5 Superb 130 Reviews

106 Main Street, Shawnee · 2.26 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Pizza
- Pretzel Bites
- French Fries
- All American Lemonade
“Nasty food and they have birds flying in and out of the upstairs behind the building can't believe the health department don't shut them down. Nothing like getting your mail and watching birds fly in and out of a place that cooks your food.”
Menu
Pizza · $
13 Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle

4.4 Superb 192 Reviews

23 Public Square, Nelsonville · 8.12 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Sauce
- Chef Salad
- Italian Sub
- Bread Sticks
“it's a very good place to get sum to eat”
Menu Order
Bar · $
14 IceHouse Tavern

4.6 Superb 72 Reviews

725 Jackson Street, Nelsonville · 8.68 miles
- Delivery
- Drive-Through
“An experience for real people looking to have a good time. 💪❤️”
Menu
Chinese · $
15 Cheng's Gourmet

4.4 Superb 140 Reviews

311 West Broadway Street, New Lexington · 9.89 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- General TSO’S Chicken Combination Fried Rice
- Chicken Chow Mein
- Cashew Chicken
- Shrimp Lo Mein
“We ordered from here for the first time in about a year and it was the best chinese food we have ever had. The hot and spicy beef was actually spicy as was the orange chicken. Everything was cooked perfectly and the portions were huge. I was told it would be 20 minutes after I ordered and it was done exactly on time. The cashier was also very friendly. We will 100% be ordering again!”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
16 Panther Drive In

4.6 Superb 46 Reviews

600 South State Street, New Lexington · 9.14 miles
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Fresh Cut Fries
- Soft Serve Vanilla & Chocolate
- Cheeseburger
- Hot Dog
“Wife and I got 2 Sowers Farms burgers, fresh cut fries, and some ice cream. We didnt want to cook dinner that night. Tasted amazing! They were so sweet and kind too us. Really good service. Good people. Highly recommend ya try them. They have a pretty extended menu.”
Menu Order
Family · $

17 Shawnee Crossing

4.7 Superb 19 Reviews

317 Main Street, Shawnee · 2.21 miles

“Our family of 6 ordered dinner from tonight. We ordered a little of everything, wings, sub, salad, burger, and chicken strips. Delicious! The fries were just as great! Thanks for everything, definitely will be a repeat customer!”

Menu
Pizza · $
18 Pizza Stop

4.3 Superb 89 Reviews

1228 Chestnut Street, Nelsonville · 9.03 miles
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Taco Salad
- Italian Sub
- Pizza Ever
- Club Sub
“We've tried all the local pizzas in Nelsonville & this is by far the best. I'm not a fan of thin crust; but, theirs is amazing. The overall flavor of the pizza was delicious. Highly recommend. Just wish they had a decent eat-in area, instead of the two little tables at the entrance.”
Menu Order
Mexican · $
19 Los Mariachis

4.2 Good 304 Reviews

99 Watkins Street, Nelsonville · 8.38 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Margherita
- Chimichanga
- Chirizo w Blanco Cheese Sauce and Refried Beans
- Rice and Beans
“The food is always hot and fresh. Staff is super friendly!”
Menu
Family · $
20 Wild Willy's Roadhouse Grill

4.3 Superb 57 Reviews

11345 OH-37, New Lexington · 10.73 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Garlic Cheese Bread
- Chicken Wings
- Chili Cheese
“My husband enjoyed his 60th birthday here getting his favorite thing, PIZZA. This quaint little roadhouse right off route 37 is a fun place to get some good pizza, subs and other pub type food. The restaurant wasn't busy at the time we ate there, so I was able to get some good pictures of the whimsical, saloon decor. The owner was so pleasant to talk to about his restaurant they built eight years ago. He gave us some cool information and stories about the place. He also told us they're currently planning to add a gift shop/ general store next door. I definitely want to go back to hear some live music and maybe try their steaks and salad bar. They are also welcoming to fur babies on their outdoor patio.”
Menu Order
American · $$
21 Urban Grille

4.2 Good 188 Reviews

14405 Country Club Lane, Logan · 8.68 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- French Onion Soup
- Sweet Potato Fries
- Onion Rings
- Asiago Mushroom Melt with Homemade Chips
“Good food, nice prices and great service”
Menu Order
Mexican · $
22 Los Mariachis

4.2 Good 183 Reviews

550 West Broadway St A, New Lexington · 9.92 miles
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Chimichangas
- Chips and Salsa
- Quesadilla
- Taco
“We eat there often. Always great service, clean facility, and awesome food. Definitely a must have when in New Lex Ohio.”
Menu
Cajun · $

23 Cajun Island at The Bridge

4.2 Good 34 Reviews

15100 OH-278, Nelsonville · 5.37 miles

“Great food and fair prices.”

Menu
Fast Food · $
24 Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

4.1 Good 131 Reviews

440 West Broadway Street, New Lexington · 9.92 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Pretzel Sticks
- Chicken Strips
- Cheeseburger
- Royal Ultimate Choco Brownie Blizzard Treat
“Food wasn’t completely cooked. Made a phone call and manager Natalie made it right.”
Menu Order
Diner · $
25 Hocking Hills Diner

4.1 Good 455 Reviews

2217 East Front Street, Logan · 8.12 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Toast
- Mashed Potatoes
- Breakfast Sandwich
- Biscuits and Gravy
“I LOVED EVERYTHING ABOUT IT”
Menu Order
Chicken · $
26 Champs Chicken

3.0 Average 4 Reviews

149 West Broadway Street, New Lexington · 9.91 miles
- Delivery
“their chicken tenders and fries are the best. and I like the potato wedges”
Menu
Bar & Grill · $
27 Trotter’s

3.9 Good 134 Reviews

123 North Main Street, New Lexington · 9.58 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Trotter's Trash Fries
- Cheese Burger Deluxe
- 12 Oz New York Strip
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap
“Trotter’s is always a solid choice for good food. The wings are great as are the burgers and sandwiches. I’ve never had the pizza, but I’m sure it is good too.”
Menu Order
Fast Food · $
28 Sonic Drive-In

4.0 Good 213 Reviews

1025 East Canal Street, Nelsonville · 8.87 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Fries
- Double Sonic Smasher
- Chili Cheese Tots
- Breakfast Burrito
“Fantastic! Excellent service and great food”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
29 Little Italy Pizza Inc

3.9 Good 143 Reviews

488 East Canal Street, Nelsonville · 8.43 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Wings
- Cheesy Bread
- Cheesy Potato
- Pizza Sub
“We order a few times a month from Little Italy in New Straitville. It's also very fresh and the delivery drivers are also so kind and appreciative of any tip! We love the dill pickle pizza and the Cheesy potato pizza 🍕 The cheesy bread is also 10/10 !”
Menu Order
Sandwich Shop · $
30 Subway

3.6 Good 88 Reviews

140 West Broadway Street, New Lexington · 9.96 miles
- Take-Out
- Drive-Through
Customers’ favorites
- Savory Rotisserie-Style Chicken Caesar Signature Wrap
- Chocolate Chip Cookie
- Turkey Cali Club
- The Outlaw
“Today wasn't the best visit for me, out of tomatoes, out of tea, and their register was acting up. No fault of the sandwich makers, just some poor inventory management by the leadership and mechanical issues out of their control. But all and all, it's a clean place to get good food with a smile”
Menu Order