7 Best Mexican Restaurants in Reynoldsburg

Check out our list of the best Mexican restaurants in Reynoldsburg.

El Asadero bar and Mexican Grill Mexican • $$
8050 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Flaming Cheese Fajitas for 1
Baha Tacos Grilled Shrimp
Ground Beef Chimichanga
Sunset Margaritas Peach
Mangonadas Margherita
Table Side Guacamole
Mexican Street Corn
Jalapeno Margherita
Birria Quesadillas
Barria Quesadilla

“Loved this place completely until today. I've been here probably 40-50 times in the last 2 years. It's always been pretty good and good service. Today I met a friend there for dinner and we got Ismaelas a server. He got mad at us because our drinks weren't right. All we did was ask for something different. He did not like that. We got our new drinks after about 10 minutes. We ordered our food and he even repeated back to us what we were ordering as he was writing it down. Once our food came mine had onions and pico. Neither of which I eat. We waited a few minutes for him to come back around and I told him about my issue. He looked mad that I did not want the onions on my food. Literal just gave me a dirty look.I told him to just take it back and I do not need a replacement. My friend did eat his tacos. He didn't come back over to our table for a while. My buddy ran out of his drink for maybe 15-20 minutes. We told the lady at the counter but she didn't seem to care. Hopefully someone does. I've brought a lot of people to this establishment and I myself have spent a ton of money there bringing my family of 5. Ive left good reviews and always spoke highly of this place. I've always bragged about how they have it figured out. Well, today has somewhat ruined it for me. Never once were we rude or out of line. I'm guessing Ismael was having a bad day. Maybe I'll come back later in the future, maybe not. That's sucks because I really like their food.“

4 Good386 Reviews
Taqueria El Fogoncito Mexican • $
1909 OH-256, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Tacos El Pastor Dine in: Yes Takeout: Yes Delivery: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes
Fish Tacos Large Veggie Quesadilla
Pastor Tacos 2 -- 1 on Thursday
Al Pastor Tacos a Plate of 8
Tacos Al Pastor Asada Taco
Tacos De Carne Asada Torta
Al Pastor Tacos Al Pastor
Tortas with Vegetables
Smokey Chipotle Sauce
Guacamole and Chips

“Hace tiempo que no iba , pero volví a ir ya que sus tacos y todo era muy rico, me gustaban mucho sus tacos recién cortados del trompo, el señor que los cocina y corta realmente sabe hacer su trabajo. Pero esta vez que volví a ir , los tacos muy buenos, pero me recibió una muchacha que desde que llegamos estaba como enojada su servicio mal, y no se diga la salsa estaba servida en vasitos parecía agua, ya no es nada igual que antes ojalá pongan más atención“

4.3 Superb64 Reviews
El Burrito Loco y Pupuseria Mexican • $
1361 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Cheese and Chicharron Pupusas
Mariscada Seafood Soup
Yucca and Chicharrón
Pupusas Revueltas
Fried Plantain
Chicken Pollo
Carne Guisada
Chicken Wings
Chicken Soup
Empanadas

“Food = ����� Service = ����� #pupusas #columbusohio“

4.6 Superb32 Reviews
El Portal Mexican • $
6999 E Main St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Enchiladas Super Rancheras
Fajita Burrito with Chicken
Enchilada Rice and Beans
Rice & Refried Beans
Enchiladas Verdes
Fried Ice Cream
Fajita Nachos
Taco Salad
Cheese Dip
Quesadilla

“Good food, reasonably priced!“

3.9 Good45 Reviews
Antojitos Ramirez Mexican • $
7770 E Main St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Barbacoa Burrito Special
Three Tacos 3
Quesadillas
Jarritos

“So good! We got several tacos, burrito fruit smoothie and the pineapple water. Everything was incredible!!!! I will return again!“

4.7 Superb14 Reviews
La Jalisciense Mexican • $
6529 E Livingston Ave, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Pastor Pork Tacos Al Pastor
Mexican Taco Traditional
Pastor- Seasoned Pork
Carne Molida Torta
Quesadilla Supreme
Asada Taco Salad
Barbacoa Burrito
Asada Quesadilla
Chicken Tamales
Pollo- Chicken

“The best Al Pastor tacos in town! Highly recommend!“

4.1 Good16 Reviews
Los Pinos salvadorean and mexican food Salvadoran • $
1780 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Menú Pollo Cortinas Frijolitos Y Plátano Fritos
Variety of Things from the Food Line
Pupusas Las Mejores
Burrito Los Pinos
Chicken Fajitas
Breakfast Combo
Papas Locas
Taco Combo
Camarones
Steak

“me encantó excelente servicio el personal muy sonriente y amables la comida es muy buena 😊“

3.8 Good42 Reviews

You May Also Like