18 Best Italian Restaurants near Sheffield

“Finally, a pizza place in Northeastern Ohio that's worthy of praise. My wife and I recently moved to the area and are pizza snobs. We have tried many pizzas in the area and all were below the bar. The crust got better as I neared the edge. It also had a crispiness every other pizza up here lacked. The sauce was tart but had a slight sweetness that lent balance to the slice. They didn't skimp on the cheese which was chewy goodness. All in all, I think we found our pizza go-to place. Their Italian food menu looked mouthwateringly good, so we will be back for some of that, too. But their pizza is the best we've found so far. Follow me for more updates.“

“We can't say enough good things about this restaurant, from the service to the food and drinks it was on point! We were seated quickly and had the pleasure of being served by Angela. She was friendly, knowledgable, accommodating and very attentive throughout our meal. We started with dirty martinis that were prepared perfectly. Our appetizer was the burrata and it was delicious, followed by Veal Piccata and Chicken Marsala. Both were excellent but the Veal Piccata was melt-in-your mouth perfect. I don't know if I could ever order anything else! This was our first visit at Antica and since we will be moving to Avon soon, it will be our go-to fave!“

“A little hidden gem in Avon Lake, Ohio. Friendly staff and polite hardworking employees everywhere you turn. We made reservations and they were accommodating. It’s a family friendly or date night kind of place. They have a small bar area up front with wine bottles every where, really cool vibes. The fresh bread and garlic butter are amazing. The Chicken Alfredo can easily feed 3-4 people, it’s HUGE! The grouper dish was good too. We had side of shrimp and calamari as well. Next time will save room for those delicious looking desserts. Clean and cozy spot!Parking: Parking lot upfront the restaurant.“

“We ordered the scampi pasta special it was delicious. Our friends got brocollini and spaghetti & meatballs. It was the largest meatballs weve seen. Everyone was happy with food. Bread was yummy too. The restaurant was very welcoming and service was great. I would definitely go back.“

“You're gonna love this place! My husband and I were so impressed. The food is delicious and the service is friendly. I have eaten in Rome and Florence, so I am picky with Italian food and this one is amazing. We started with iced tea and basil lemonade. Although that sounds simple, it was perfect. We had the soft and crispy focaccia with oil dipping sauce followed by a salad with romaine with pepper dressing and shaved Parmesan. Then we had arancini for an appetizer and my husband was sold! He had chicken Parmesan and it was wonderful. The best lasagna I have probably ever had. You have no doubt those pasta sheets are fresh and homemade. Here's my tip.., come early or get a reservation.“

“The employees know how to do their job!!! They are pleasant and actually listen. The pizza is amazing!!! I always get the taste of Coz and a pepperoni pizza and have never been disappointed. They even have apple or cherry pie pizza which is sinfully delicious. The dining room is small but serves its function.“

“Everything tastes like it is made from fresh ingredients. Both New York style and grandma crust have a nice crisp to the crust. Sauce has excellent taste and just the right amount spread evenly throughout the pies. The pepperoni rolls while good didn't impress me. Garlic bread was just that as well. Pizza was fair price but apps overpriced for the amount of food you receive. Will definitely be back for another vist“

“I stopped by WB Pizza yesterday during lunch I ordered a large meat lovers pizza, pan crust, which is their thick crust. I had a few questions. The manager answered them, she was very polite and took time to take care of me. I was very pleased with my choice. The food was amazing. I will be returning.“

“Almost definitely the best salad I ever had. Very friendly service and I’ll say it again, absolutely top-tier ingredients!Dietary restrictions: The salad dressing was made in-house so they were able to communicate with us regarding some allergies. No corn!“

“Absolutely delicious. I had the spaghetti with meatballs with Alfredo sauce. It was terrific. My mom and grandma had the lasagna. They said it was delicious. The food was terrific ! The service was amazing and the prices were reasonable. I will definitely come here again.“

“went here with a group of family for a birthday. I did not like my food (cheese ravioli) but tried others in the group and theirs were good. here are my opinions on each food I tried:cheese ravioli is one of my favorite foods but it can be different everywhere. this one was bad and I definitely would not get it again. they were very small and thin like frozen ones you could buy at the store with a very tomato tasting sauce, not marinara. even if I tried a different sauce, I don't think it would be worth it because the ravioli itself was not good.calzone with sausage- amazing, very flavorful and soft, will definitely come back for itstuffed peppers- amazing, would get againbolognese- goodprime rib- not bad but not greatbread and butter was plain and average“

“Best pizza in town. Everyone else is a flip of a coin wether you'll get good food. The prices here reflect the quality and consistency. This is the only place making pizzas like you would expect; a true old-school pizza place.My 4 stars (not 5) is a reflection of some of the slightly confusing menu and Angelina's wings. The wings are the 5 star breaker. Sold by the 1/2 pound, this itself is deceiving, especially when you find out that that 1/2 pound of wings you bought are just 4 wings. I don't think anyone paying their wing prices expect only 4 wings. For the price, I'll pass on these. They really should sell by the half dozen for the price they charge for 4.“

“Wonderful experience! We enjoyed several different dishes that they easily made gluten free for us. Everything from the service to the food was amazing! I was so happy that they have a good amount of gluten free choices and were very accommodating with any questions we had about ingredients in different dishes. Highly recommend for a great date night! 1st floor so easily handicap accessible and also had handicap accessible parking available right outside.“

“Enter Olive Garden and prepare to be enchanted by Cali's exceptional service. With a smile as warm as the Tuscan sun, Cali effortlessly transforms each meal into a culinary journey to remember. From expert recommendations to personalized attention, Cali's commitment to hospitality ensures that every visit is a delight. Whether you're a regular or a first-time guest, Cali's welcoming demeanor and professional demeanor make dining at Olive Garden an unforgettable experience.“

“I ordered two pizzas from Angelina's for my first time. One was a garlic butter based pizza with some veggies. It was tasty and perfectly cooked. I also ordered a take-n-bake red pizza with pepperoni. I think the sauce is a bit sweet for my taste and the pepperoni were nothing too special. But for both pizzas, the crust was the show stopper. Excellent crust with amazing flavor and texture will keep me coming back.“

“Horrible establishment, horrible customer service, I ordered an online order when I went to pick up at the establishment. My order was wrong when I told the cashier if they could just add pepperoni to my pizza the cashier refused and said it was company policy if I wanted to get pepperoni in my pizza. I had to go ahead and re-order online and repay again. None of this made any sense to me so tomorrow morning I will make sure to call the management to get to the bottom of this because that is horrible customer service, and at this point I am going to tell anybody I know never to go there ever“

“The owner Tom is a very friendly guy that delivers quality food ever time. I highly recommend the BBQ corn pesto chicken pasta bowl! 5/5 from me and I'm a frequent customer because of his quality and kindness. Great business, and awesome location especially for the winter time next to the fireplace in Crocker.- Kris“

“The food is amazing! A meatball like nana would make is a meal. Pick your sauce. Had the 2 palm house salad w blue cheese and housemade champagne vinigrette. Our server was friendly and mentioned the specials right away. The place is clean and rustic w an open kitchen. Portions are large and priced reasonably. Been here twice and will chose them again. Full bar but also family friendly.Parking: Trader Joes free parking garage right across from restaurant.Kid-friendliness: Picnic style tables. Family style, 2 tops, 4 tops and high tops“