10 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sherrodsville

“We ordered for the first time today. We have been wanting to try it for a while. We got a Margherita pizza, and picked it up. The place was clean, friendly and pizza was ready on time. Probably the best pizza we have had in this area. Prices are fair. Crust sauce and toppings were all fresh and delicious. Will definitely be ordering again soon. Thank you for bringing your business to the area! Would highly recommend.“

“Had the french bread pizza today Best i ever have eaten. I live 6 mile from a good pizza shop in sugarcreek but will continue to drive 13 mile for this pizza. Well worth it. Great people. Great pizza“

“We decided to visit the Millstone during a family vacation this week, and everyone was impressed! The food was absolutely delicious, the coffee even better. The owner (I'm assuming) was so personable and made the experience that much better! We will absolutely be back! 10/10 recommend checking this place out.“

“We couldn't say enough terrific things about Pangrazio's. Service was prompt, courteous and friendly. The spaghetti and lasagna were tasty, large and steamy hot potions. And the side salads were generous and tasty. I only wish they sold their homemade creamy garlic dressing in bottles. It was amazing.“

“As a frequent customer, I recommend this establishment to everyone.. dine in, carry out, delivery, lunch or dinner. We love supporting our local businesses and this one has been around for quite some time. Not to mention, possibly the best meatball splash in the area (pro tip : put Colby cheese on the pizza or splash)“

“What a great little gathering place! We needed a place, on short notice, for a celebration of life for our Grandmother and Pangrazio's came through in a big way! The staff were all amazing and the food was absolutely wonderful! Eating buffet style straight out of the kitchen was such a fitting meal to honor our Italian Grandmother. Great food, great atmosphere, and wonderful staff! Thank you Pangrazio's for everything!“

“I can always count on hot and delicious food every time from Domino’s. Fast delivery. Best pizza shop around Gnadenhutten!!“

“If there is a better pizza out there, please let me know. The quality and quantity of ingredients is unmatched. Love this place.“

“Great Pizza ! Carry out, or it's a really "cozy" atmosphere to "eat in" ! 🏆 5 out of 5 ⭐ 🎯“

“My buddy from Texas came into town and we went to the yard. Everything was great from the food to the drinks. The service was great too.“