23 Best Pizza Restaurants near The Plains

“Great thin crust pizza! Well done guys! Worth the wait!“

“I infrequently get to the Athens area, but always get a take and bake pepperoni or margarita pizza. ***** 5 star rating.“

“it's a very good place to get sum to eat“

“The pizza is excellent and the prices are very reasonable...highly recommend!“

“They have the best Pizza subs around“

“Food was ready on time and everything was delicious! ⭐️“

“Had their pizza at my 40th Birthday Bash yesterday. They even delivered and didn’t charge me a delivery fee!!!!“

“Fantastic food, very flavorful and good value for your money. Staff was super friendly and had no problem explaining a few menu options that I was unfamiliar with. Bathroom and dining room were both very clean. Plenty of seating. Will be back.“

“We order a few times a month from Little Italy in New Straitville. It's also very fresh and the delivery drivers are also so kind and appreciative of any tip! We love the dill pickle pizza and the Cheesy potato pizza 🍕 The cheesy bread is also 10/10 !“

“Best pizza in town!!!!!!!!“

“Great Service and Great Food! We will definitely be going back! We were shown that they have a Top Notch golf simulator in the back that they can rent out and also a part/meeting room for all your gathering needs! Would highly Recommend this place to anyone!👍🏻👍🏻“

“The food is amazing! I highly recommend the brussel sprouts appetizer. Everything was great from the service, the atmosphere, to my Stabby Cat beer. We will definitely be back.“

“Best pizza in Athens County imo“

“We order a few times a month from Little Italy in New Straitville. It's also very fresh and the delivery drivers are also so kind and appreciative of any tip! We love the dill pickle pizza and the Cheesy potato pizza 🍕 The cheesy bread is also 10/10 !“

“Mid afternoon on Saturday has limited crave options in this small town of 1,400 ppl, got hot wings, cheeseburger and pizza, better than 7/11 in larger cities, without a hitch. Stays open until 11a, coupled with a convenience store/gas station. Been here a few times.“

“My fiancé and I were trading in our points for a free pizza. Got in for pickup. This girl says "they're remaking it. The halves weren't even (red pepper on right, tomato on left)" We get both pizzas. For free. Definitely tipped that goddess. A++ customer service.“

“Just moved to the area & Papa John's is my kids favorite... It was definitely worth the 30min drive from our house because they said it was it was the best they ever had. Staff was friendly inside despite us getting there super close to closing time, everything was great.“

“Good but overpriced gluten free pizza. Dining room is usual empty so it's a nice quiet place to sit and enjoy your meal but the table we choose had not been wiped after the last custumer. Employees were friendly but screwed up the half-pizza toppings, thankfully it was a veggie that could be picked off and moved to the other side.“

“Great for those late night cravings !!! There Calzones are always filling..and that garlic butter mixed in with the marinara sauce, oh my delish !! Roni Rolls are delicious as well. I got the Speed Zone, Bro Zone and one other one..like a Chicken Bacon Ranch. Me, My Son and Friend love DP Dough !! ✌😁“

“Good folks! Excellent food and service.“

“not happy with our order. Our salads had not much in them and all the lettuce was brown.“

“Amazing experience from beginning to end. Online ordering was easy, picking up my order was easy, and the environment inside the store was so upbeat and positive! I loved it! Drove 20 minutes home and our food was still piping hot. It’s never been this easy to award 5 stars!“

“Frustrating that 3x in a row our orders made incorrectly and pizza sauce sides are forgotten. When you send someone else to pick it up, we have to hope that the business can read a receipt and falls back on them. I can't count the money I'm lost out on due to paying for items I never received like tonight“