15 Best American Restaurants near Wellsville

“I recently started worked in the Wellsville area, but I have always lived in Mahoning County. I love this little restaurant! The owner comes out of the kitchen regularly and chats with customers. The service is fast and the prices are very fair. Much better than what I'm used to up north.“

“Sad to not being visiting anymore, Things have really been bad, never receive bread anymore, didn't get our appetizer the last 2 times we ordered one ( it was forgotten or the wrong thing was put in) and the last time we were there we were charged gratuity on our check ( party of 5) then charged for paying with our debit card.“

“We decided instead of ordering pizza to get some take out!! Great idea on our part... The vegetable soup was so good! I decided to pair it with a grilled ham n cheese sandwich, he had chicken parm sandwich!! Wish I had more soup to graze on later! YUMMY ?“

“we ate thier yesterday for the 1st time,it's very cozy,friendly the waitress,was very ,sweet kind. my fiancee had sausage Gravy biscuits, with eggs,hash browns he said it was really good,big portion he can eat alot he had trouble finishing it lol, I had 2 pieces of Frenchtoast & bacon I had trouble finishing mine as well. highly recommend to go thier excellent service & food.“

“The food here was wonderful! I had the homemade noodles and filet tips with brown gravy. We had three in our party and all three of us had fantastic meals. They tasted homemade. The place was packed. We had to wait for a table to be cleaned off. The staff was exceptionally friendly and made you feel at home.“

“Stopped at 7pm after a Wednesday softball practice. Was busy, and they could probably use an extra hand, but they did a great job getting food out to us. My burger's taste was solid, with a nice crust. Kiddo's shrimp dinner disappeared quick, and my wife's steak salad was big enough that I got to `help' with a couple delicious bites. They were so good if I don't do steak, next time, shame on me! Fried dill pickles & hot cheese balls were fantastic, and the Miller Lite couldn't get any colder, trust me!“

“This Gem of Toronto, Ohio is quite the precious jewel!! My family has eaten there numerous times!! Too many to count!My husband has also often gone to Tuckers for lunch with co- workers and customers. All who have raved about their food! We have had a variety of their offerings from the menu and on the specials board!! Everything is made with care and an accent on details!! Absolutely delicious!! Very friendly atmosphere!! I have recommended Tuckers Tavern to many - all who were appreciative after their great experiences there!! You are missing something special if you don’t visit this hometown eatery!! Awesome!“

“We came and got an assortment of cupcakes for our nieces birthday! Yummy deal! Great prices for a dozen delicious sweet cakes. I also love the maple doughnut sticks. May have to come back to dine in. No pics because they were a gift and we were ravenous“

“Wow! This place is phenomenal! Fast service, delicious food and milkshakes! We will definitely be back. Our waitress Lauren was great too. I was hoping they had everything to make my favorite drink, a tiramisu martini. They didn't, but the bartender went over and above, and made me something really close. It was great! No idea what she put in it, but I commend her for going out of the way to try to make something I liked!Kid-friendliness: Restaurant side and a bar side. Great for people with kids, like myself“

“Wonder lunch with my wife. Great waitress. Food was good. Owned came to our table to greet us. Made sure our food was hot and to our satisfaction. Prices good. 1 appetizer, 2 sandwiches, 2 sides, 2 soft drinks. $35.00. We highly recommend this restaurant. Ernie and Shirley “

“Toni helped me pull off a fabulous band reunion for our Director who is 81. The tables were set up and she and her staff went beyond my expectations. They made amazing appetizers and food and were attentive and fun. I am so happy with her vision and I truly needed her help as I was freaking about the What Ifs of this Meet and Greet. Thank you Toni and Saddle for a memorable beautiful and yummy food night. Loved it. I recommend you EVERY TIME . Ty . ❤️“

“We stopped after a game, had no idea it was there. Friends of ours suggested it. The service was great and the food was excellent! There was a minor hiccup but we let the waitress know and she acknowledged it and took care of it. It is a nice place for family and it was clean! Definitely worth stopping in!Parking: Parking is across the street or in front of the building.“

“It’s hard to find a wing night in 2023 that’s going to beat 50 cent chicken wings! We drove about a half hour to check out the White Stallion and the place was slammed! All of the waitresses and bartenders were working at full speed. We had to wait a little for our wings but it was expected as busy as they were. We had 4 different flavors and no complaints at all. The wings were very good. We will be back“

“We get takeout here once a week, on average. My boyfriend always gets the same, I always change it up. Everything I've ever had has been excellent, but my recent favorites are the chicken philly sandwich and the lasagna. He loves the Italian chicken sandwich. Affordable, super big portions, and the food is always so good!“

“I got the hot turkey sandwich and it was very good. It was a very generous size. The mashed potatoes were good.The only problem I had was that I didn't know how to order. There aren't any signs to direct people like myself what to do. I stood in front of the counter and there were 2 ladies working behind the counter. Neither of them acknowledged me or asked if I needed help. Finally a couple came in behind me and asked if I was in line. I said I think so. They were the ones who told me what to do. The ladies behind the counter were very defensive and acted like they didn't know how to smile. While I was eating I did see another lady who appeared friendly and smiling behind the counter briefly. (A cook maybe ?)Vegetarian options: I can't say there were many vegetarian options (lucky for me I'm not vegetarian.) They do have pescatarian options.“