DiCarlo’s Pizza - Westerville
CLOSED$ •
About DiCarlo’s Pizza - Westerville
Recent Reviews
98 ratings
We stop here every time we come through back to Cincinnati. Pizza is always perfect and reminds me of back home. I’ve never had an issue and we will always make the trip off the highway to make time to support this business and enjoy amazing DiCarlo’s Pizza. If you aren’t getting this pizza Ohio Valley Style, you are missing out.
This last time I called in and ordered ahead. I was an hour out. I got there and the pizza was not ready. The guys working said “I didn’t...read full review
This last time I called in and ordered ahead. I was an hour out. I got there and the pizza was not ready. The guys working said “I didn’t...read full review
We just did carry out this time.But the pizza was absolutely delicious.Everyone loved it and it was the right price. We'll definitely be visiting there again
Oh man is this amazing pizza!! The crust is crunchy, and chewy at the same time. Not too thin, Not too thick, just right. The Sauce is wonderful, full of fresh tomato flavor, and not overly seasoned or sweet. Just high quality tomato flavor with some garlic, and maybe a hint of green pepper. The Cheese, and Pep get put on after the bake, and just get melty in the box after a minute or two. The difference it makes to the flavor is something special. Not burnt, just gooey...read full review
DiCarlo’s Pizza offers an Ohio Valley Style pizza that is always perfect and reminds customers of back home. The pizza is absolutely delicious, with a crust that is crunchy and chewy at the same time, not too thin, not too thick. The sauce is wonderful, full of fresh tomato flavor, and not overly seasoned or sweet. The cheese and pep get put on after the bake, and just get melty in the box. The pizza is a pan pizza with good crunch, medium thickness, and tons of flavor. The sausage and the hot peppers are very good. Customers appreciate the great customer service and knowledge on how the DiCarlo’s pizza should be served, with nice cold toppings as it was designed. The people are very nice, and the pizza tastes just how it did growing up. One can order with the cheese melted or added after the bake. The online ordering process is simple and easy. Everyone loved the pizza, and it was the right price. Customers will definitely go back and make the trip off the highway to support this business.