Over The Counter

5596 N High St, Worthington
(614) 846-1107

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Patty Melt Hamburguesa Fundido
Chicken and Waffles
French Onion Soup
Huevos Rancheros
Grilled Cheese
Route 23 Salad
Pretzel Bites
Loaded Chips
Fried Veggies
Onion Rings

Menu

Appetizers
Chicken Tenders/Ofertas de pollo
Juicy tempura-breaded tenders with buttermilk ranch
Fried Pickle Spears/Lanzas de pepinillos fritos
Tempura-breaded Kosher dill pickles with buttermilk ranch
Fried Veggies/Verduras Fritas
Crimini mushrooms, dill pickles and broccoli with buttermilk ranch
Pile of Fries/Pila de Papas Fritas
Pretzel Bites/Bocados de pretzel
Salted soft pretzels with Guinness beer cheese

Sandwiches and More
BLT/Tocino lechuga tomate
Brown sugar and cayenne spiced bacon, lettuce, tomato, red pepper aioli on multigrain bread
Counter Burger/Hamburguesa
1/4 lb. 88% Lean beef patty, lettuce, tomato, red onion and pickle chips with Mad sauce on a grilled split-top bun
Fried Egg Sandwich/Sandwich de Huevos
2 fried eggs, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on multigrain bread
Grilled Cheese/Queso a la parrilla
Cheddar, provolone, swiss, grilled tomato and spicy mayo on grilled sourdough
Italian Chicken Sandwich/Pollo Italiano
Patty Melt/
1/4 lb. 88% Lean beef patty, swiss and bourbon caramelized onions with Thousand Island on grilled sourdough bread
PB & J/Jalea de mantequilla de mani
Crunchy peanut butter, strawberry jam and fresh sliced strawberries on grilled sourdough
Sloppy Joe/Joe Descuidado
Tuna Melt/Atun derretido
Dolphin-safe Albacore covered with melted cheddar and Swiss on grilled sourdough
Tuna SALAD Sandwich/Ensalada de atun
Dolphin-safe Albacore, lettuce and tomato on multigrain bread
Where's Waldo/Mortedala
Wrap Chicken Buffalo/Wrap de Pollo Bufalo
Wrap Chicken Caesar/Wrap de Pollo Cesar
Hot Chicken Sandwich

Sides
Chips/Papas Fritas
Kettle Chips
Cole Slaw/Ensalada de col
Fresh and creamy slaw with green peppers and red onions
Fruit/Fruta
Fry Basket/Canasta de Frituras
Fresh cut fries with rosemary oil and seasoning salt
Mac & Cheese Full/Macarrones con Queso Completo
House made cheese sauce, cavatappi pasta, topped with buttery herb bread crumbs
Mac & Cheese Half/Medio Macarrones con Queso
House made cheese sauce, cavatappi pasta, topped with buttery herb bread crumbs
Onion Rings/Aros de Cebolla
Dipped to order in tempura beer batter
Side Sauce/Salsa de Acompanamiento
Veg: Skillet Corn/Sarten de Maiz

Soups
Cup Chicken and Rice/Taza de Pollo y Arroz
Bowl Chicken and Rice/Tazon de Pollo y Arroz
Cup French Onion/Taza de Cebolla Francesa
Bowl French Onion/Tazon de Cebolla Francesa

Soup/Salad Combo
Soup & Salad Combo

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+20 photos
Photo credit: google
+19 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We really enjoyed our meal and the service. The restaurant is really clean, the servers are quick and friendly. Do yourself a favor and get the sweet & spicy blt. We will definitely be regulars going forward
July 2025
Waited over 1/2 an hour for a tuna melt sandwich and fried fish dinner at 3 . Our waitress was great, but the kitchen was extremely slow. Sandwich & pretzel bites were delicious and plentiful for the money; there was confusion on the sides (I wanted veggies instead of fries; I was charged extra for the veggies without being told beforehand.) The fish dinner was over priced for the amount (or lack) of fish
June 2025
Over the Counter is a great spot for brunch. The atmosphere is lively, the restaurant is clean and the staff is helpful. It is always busy when I come in. Came here on a busy Sunday morning, and I ordered the OTC breakfast with a Bloody Mary. Delicious. I have also had the burger here. Another great choice. It can be difficult to find parking in the main lot if it's crowded, but there's plenty other places to park around the restaurant on side streets.

Thanks!
February 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Kitty Bubble Cafe & Bar - 5568 N High St
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Cafe
Villa Nova Ristorante - 5545 N High St
Italian, Bar, Pizza, Vegetarian
Tim Hortons - 5470 N High St
Coffee & Tea, Coffee Shops, Coffee, Bakery

Over The Counter

5596 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085
(614) 846-1107