26 Best Pizza Restaurants in Zanesville

“Such great pizza!! Love the vibe. Evan was fantastic and our first visit will definitely not be our last!“

“Cannot speak on their food as I only come in at night for the drinks and good vibes. Recently moved out here and was hunting for a new friendly, safe feeling and chill barbm to attend. I go out for a couple of drinks at least 3x a week.

Have had the same bartender almost every single night that I have been here with my coworker. He is top notch! Super friendly, remembers details of almost every convo we have and will incorporate them into the next visit, and knows mine and my coworkers order off the top of his head and even how many/how long we end up being there.

Whole place and customer base seems chill, happy, and most importantly safe.

Thanks to Brodie and the rest of the staff for running great night shifts and knowing their regulars! Truly will not change up bar spots now that I've found a good one!“

“Very clean and exceptional service.

The food rating is only based on pizza as that is all we had. The crust was not really a pizza dough; it was more like a cracker dough. Though that seems to be typical of most small town pizzerias in Ohio, so maybe someone else would give it more stars.

The server was bringing someone else a salad that looked great! 😸

I would definitely recommend this restaurant to everyone!“

“Ordered two Italian Subs to-go, they were good. I don’t know what kind of Italian dressing they use but it is really good. Haven’t tried anything else yet but will be back. ☺️ 🍕“

“the food is always yummy!!“

“Super fresh clean ingredients makes for Great Food. We will go nowhere else. The Wife and I Eat/cook a lot and know good food. Their food is consistent, fresh, clean and so close to Cultural simplicity. Which means for us: Delicious fresh ingredients= No upset stomach Simple wins And they have never changed“

“Friendly staff, good food“

“My wife and I stopped here to celebrate our first date 8 years ago on 9-11. The first date was in Lancaster, but we decided to be content with going to another Pizza Cottage and forego the 2 hour drive. The waitress was extremely friendly, attentive and she made sure that the order was absolutely perfect! Pizza Cottage is one of the best pizza restaurants that I can recommend!“

“Very Good Pizza, especially the thin crust we Ordered. the Toppings were Excellent especially the Cheese. Employees were friendly and professional. Thank You Donatos Pizza for a Great Experience. Im Giving you a 4.5 out 5 Star Rating. Definitely Recommending. 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻“

“Order the other night and was not disappointed! Not only was my pizza beautiful and hot as sin. It’s was delivered so fast I didn’t have time to get hangry and check my phone to see how long it had been since I placed my order. Great job!“

“It's one of my favorite places to go. My only complaint is when I get a sub. Sometimes, I get something that tastes funny on it. Like lettuce or the onions have gone bad. Don't know which one. It's only been recently. The best cheese sticks ever!!!“

“Good drive thru. But picking up food orders should be done inside or have special parking. Otherwise it turns into a parking lot inside and you end up sitting there forever.“

“Tonight was my first time dining. We ordered pickup and it took about 45 minutes to be ready. We ordered 2 pepperoni pizzas, 12 plain wings, 12 mild & deep fried pickles. Our total was something like $60. Okay I’ll start my actual review now lol I’ve heard these guys are the BEST wings, so of course I’ve been wanting to try. They absolutely did NOT disappoint. They were DELICIOUS & for what I consider to be a reasonable price 9/10. The fried pickles were also super good and, as was their ranch 9/10. Now to the pizza. Well it’s definitely different than most would expect I’d imagine. The sauce seems to have a sweeter taste. I still liked it, but I could see why someone may not. 7/10 I know I’m writing this review like Keith Lee, but I wanted to give my honest thoughts because if you’re anything like me you read reviews & the help you with your decision. To summarize, we will definitely be going back. I’m excited to try the different appetizers& I really think their pricing is very reasonable.“

“Dine in. I had recently had knee surgery so the stools at the counter were uncomfortable. The siting area is very small, it was a very cold day when the door was open. Great service. Great pizza and pasta. Next time would try a different locatiion for better seating.“

“Thanks for the fast delivery! Less than 30 minutes and our pizza was delivered :)“

“I ordered a pizza today from the Maysville Ave. spot in Zanesville, OH, and it was absolutely incredible! I went for the stuffed crust, which I’d never tried there before, and I was a bit hesitant. But with a 50% off promotion going on, I figured why not? Let me tell you, it was phenomenal—way better than I expected, especially since I’m not usually a fan of Domino’s hand-tossed pizza. I typically stick to their thin crust, which never disappoints, but this stuffed crust was next-level. It’s only available in medium, so it’s not a huge pizza, but that crust is packed with gooey, cheesy goodness. Pro tip: grab some dipping sauces. I got marinara, and it was the perfect pairing. Highly recommend!“

“Food was ok. But my family didn't want to try the pizza at first, . Because they didn't recognize what the sausage was because it was shaped kind of like worms on the pizza. Seriously. And had some chunks of gristly fat in it that was not chewable. Good thing we ordered extra cheese, that made it like a normal pizza . They had a 5 topping special. The crust was delicious. But I've had better with Dominos, & I've had worse. Can't get a home run Everytime, I guess. The employees were really polite and helpful. I feel like they were afraid of using cheese though. The only bad thing about franchises is inconsistent product. The reason the atmosphere didn't get a higher score is its depressingly dark in there. Not unclean.... Dark.“

“We ordered the new flips and they were delicious. I couldn't eat the whole thing so I know what I'm eating for lunch tomorrow. We'll worth the cost.“

“It was the easiest I’ve EVER ordered food online! The female employee at the pick up window at the South Zanesville location was very pleasant and knew what she was doing! Subs were PERFECT and much much better than Subway will ever be! Thank you!“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“When Old Market House Inn unexpectedly closed just before our rehearsal dinner, Mr. Adornetto personally called to explain and offered to help us make new arrangements. We decided on Giacomo’s Bread & More, where Vice President Jessica helped us plan a menu featuring dishes from both Giacomo’s and Adornetto’s Pizzeria. The food was delicious, the service excellent, and everything went smoothly. We’re so grateful for their support and will absolutely continue supporting both restaurants in the future!“

“Their food is usually ways great. I did have one order that wasn't good at all the wings were over cooked and didn't have enough sauce on them. I do like their cheesy bites but I wish they made them off of a pizza I didn't care for the pizza that was attached. I hope that they will make an option where you can just order the cheesy bites.“

“Sad to see pizza hut on the decline. They used to be THE place to be on a Saturday night. The pizza quality has Never stopped. Still one of the best pizzas around. If you haven't tried it in a while, stop back. You'll remember why they are an icon.“

“Tonight was my first time dining. We ordered pickup and it took about 45 minutes to be ready. We ordered 2 pepperoni pizzas, 12 plain wings, 12 mild & deep fried pickles. Our total was something like $60. Okay I’ll start my actual review now lol I’ve heard these guys are the BEST wings, so of course I’ve been wanting to try. They absolutely did NOT disappoint. They were DELICIOUS & for what I consider to be a reasonable price 9/10. The fried pickles were also super good and, as was their ranch 9/10. Now to the pizza. Well it’s definitely different than most would expect I’d imagine. The sauce seems to have a sweeter taste. I still liked it, but I could see why someone may not. 7/10 I know I’m writing this review like Keith Lee, but I wanted to give my honest thoughts because if you’re anything like me you read reviews & the help you with your decision. To summarize, we will definitely be going back. I’m excited to try the different appetizers& I really think their pricing is very reasonable.“

“Food & service has always been amazing! Always love coming here. Bartenders are always so great and food is always spot on. Only reason I gave 4 stars instead of 5, actually should be 2 stars based on what I am about to say, but, there is a waitress there named Amber and twice, I was in the restroom when she was and she did not wash her hands after using the restroom. Absolutely nasty. Hence why I have so appropriately nicknamed her McNasty. She is not a bartender and we always make sure to sit at the bar.“

“I can not say enough about the service and the staff of this location. They continue to go above and beyond to make sure my family is fed (more times than I should probably admit) a week! They greet me every time I walk in their door, always with a smile. Its the little things that mean a lot. I can't give them all the stars they deserve!“