25 Best Pizza Restaurants in Zanesville

“Really neat bar-n with a wild eclectic sports, aviation, motorcycle sorta theme. We ordered wings and pizza, the pizza was the better choice.

Staff was laid back and helpful.

Bet this place is a riot on the weekends!“

“Such great pizza!! Love the vibe. Evan was fantastic and our first visit will definitely not be our last!“

“My go to pizzeria, my absolute favorite!“

“the food is always yummy!!“

“Good drive thru. But picking up food orders should be done inside or have special parking. Otherwise it turns into a parking lot inside and you end up sitting there forever.“

“Friendly staff, good food“

“We had the blt pizza which was very delicious. our waitress was super friendly“

“Ordered two Italian Subs to-go, they were good. I don’t know what kind of Italian dressing they use but it is really good. Haven’t tried anything else yet but will be back. ☺️ 🍕“

“Very Good Pizza, especially the thin crust we Ordered. the Toppings were Excellent especially the Cheese. Employees were friendly and professional. Thank You Donatos Pizza for a Great Experience. Im Giving you a 4.5 out 5 Star Rating. Definitely Recommending. 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻“

“Order the other night and was not disappointed! Not only was my pizza beautiful and hot as sin. It’s was delivered so fast I didn’t have time to get hangry and check my phone to see how long it had been since I placed my order. Great job!“

“It's one of my favorite places to go. My only complaint is when I get a sub. Sometimes, I get something that tastes funny on it. Like lettuce or the onions have gone bad. Don't know which one. It's only been recently. The best cheese sticks ever!!!“

“Our food was amazing! Our business loves your $10 lunch specials. Being able to order online works out well for us. The food is always correct and delicious. I’ve already told 2 people how great the lunch specials are and the price is perfect. Even the soda is nice and cold! Lol We will be ordering again soon! Thank you,
Angie and The Insight Surgery and Laser Center Team“

“Absolutely the best pizza I’ve ever had!!“

“Tonight was my first time dining. We ordered pickup and it took about 45 minutes to be ready. We ordered 2 pepperoni pizzas, 12 plain wings, 12 mild & deep fried pickles. Our total was something like $60. Okay I’ll start my actual review now lol I’ve heard these guys are the BEST wings, so of course I’ve been wanting to try. They absolutely did NOT disappoint. They were DELICIOUS & for what I consider to be a reasonable price 9/10. The fried pickles were also super good and, as was their ranch 9/10. Now to the pizza. Well it’s definitely different than most would expect I’d imagine. The sauce seems to have a sweeter taste. I still liked it, but I could see why someone may not. 7/10 I know I’m writing this review like Keith Lee, but I wanted to give my honest thoughts because if you’re anything like me you read reviews & the help you with your decision. To summarize, we will definitely be going back. I’m excited to try the different appetizers& I really think their pricing is very reasonable.“

“Thanks for the fast delivery! Less than 30 minutes and our pizza was delivered :)“

“We ordered the new flips and they were delicious. I couldn't eat the whole thing so I know what I'm eating for lunch tomorrow. We'll worth the cost.“

“I’ve been ordering here a lot at this specific location and I give them a 9.9 out of 10 stars the only messed up one time and they made it right the next time I came and gave it to me for free so like I love the workers I love the food can’t say enough about it“

“Taste is consistent and the cup / mini pepperoni are my favorite. We usually get the Calzone or Stromboli unless we have a larger gathering. Crust is still very good but it has been a bit more chewy on the latest orders. Prices have increased which wouldn’t be a big concern if the bottom crust wasn’t dripping with oil. This is still my favorite in the local area.“

“I ordered a pizza today from the Maysville Ave. spot in Zanesville, OH, and it was absolutely incredible! I went for the stuffed crust, which I’d never tried there before, and I was a bit hesitant. But with a 50% off promotion going on, I figured why not? Let me tell you, it was phenomenal—way better than I expected, especially since I’m not usually a fan of Domino’s hand-tossed pizza. I typically stick to their thin crust, which never disappoints, but this stuffed crust was next-level. It’s only available in medium, so it’s not a huge pizza, but that crust is packed with gooey, cheesy goodness. Pro tip: grab some dipping sauces. I got marinara, and it was the perfect pairing. Highly recommend!“

“Their food is usually ways great. I did have one order that wasn't good at all the wings were over cooked and didn't have enough sauce on them. I do like their cheesy bites but I wish they made them off of a pizza I didn't care for the pizza that was attached. I hope that they will make an option where you can just order the cheesy bites.“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Best salads anywhere! The Pepperoni Pizza never disappoints. But, if you wanna try something new, get the Meatball Pizza! Yum! (And it just happens to be where my wife and I went on our first date 40 years ago….so it’s a Good Luck spot!)“

“We often go to Rooster's when we can't figure out what else we want lol. It's always a great repeat restaurant. Friendly staff and great selection for food and beverages. We always have a good time. Fun for all ages. We even had my dad's 60th birthday gathering there and they were really accommodating! We will always return!“

“Tonight was my first time dining. We ordered pickup and it took about 45 minutes to be ready. We ordered 2 pepperoni pizzas, 12 plain wings, 12 mild & deep fried pickles. Our total was something like $60. Okay I’ll start my actual review now lol I’ve heard these guys are the BEST wings, so of course I’ve been wanting to try. They absolutely did NOT disappoint. They were DELICIOUS & for what I consider to be a reasonable price 9/10. The fried pickles were also super good and, as was their ranch 9/10. Now to the pizza. Well it’s definitely different than most would expect I’d imagine. The sauce seems to have a sweeter taste. I still liked it, but I could see why someone may not. 7/10 I know I’m writing this review like Keith Lee, but I wanted to give my honest thoughts because if you’re anything like me you read reviews & the help you with your decision. To summarize, we will definitely be going back. I’m excited to try the different appetizers& I really think their pricing is very reasonable.“

“We dined in yesterday and it was amazing! The dining room was clean and so nice! As soon as we walked in I was like this is the best pizza hut I have been in in a long time. Service was spot on and it was even decorated for halloween!! Great job!“