24 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newark

“The best pizza in town! Not to mention the torpedo sub! Always amazing!“

“Great wood fired pizza and service.“

“Excellent. Such a breath of fresh air to still have non-chain options for pizza. The value here is off the charts. I recommend Carmen's!We need to make it a priority to support these types of places... In this case, their good pizza makes it easy. They earn the support!“

“I have loved this place since they opened.. My absolute favorite pizza!“

“Excellent food and service every time I visit. Absolutely love this place! Also prices are great! You get your monies worth and in this day and age that isn't easy to come by. Thank you Christy's Pizza for the great food and service!“

“Everything that I have ordered and had delivered is absolutely delicious! My mom and I love Debra's food. We have tried many different places. We like Debra's the best above anyone else's. The delivery person is always very polite, professional, and usually delivers before the given time. The person taking the calls and orders is also very polite and professional. You definitely deserve the 5 star rating. Thank you all so much for your services.“

“We love their pizza and get at least one a week good stuff!“

“New to the area so trying all the local spots. All I can say is, "Wow!" I ordered the Margarite. The pesto instead of regular sauce was off the charts. My husband had a what I'll call meat lover, he said it was the best pizza he ever had. Fresh ingredients make all the difference.“

“Great pizza with plenty of toppings. A really good value, prices are reasonable. Not much seating for dine in“

“Alley cat subs and pizza is a fantastic Atmosphere And I really enjoy going there , always smiles and all my orders are cared for , if anything is wrong it’s always fixed I’m happy to say alley cat subs and pizza is one of my favorite casual spots to eat , they don’t pressure you , they let you take a long look at the menu and enjoy your experience, I recommend alley cat anywhere I go , much love to alley cat subs & pizza & the crew“

“New to the area, so trying all the local spots. 2 weeks ago I ordered a tomato and mushroom. Crust was good and baked properly, but the canned tomatoes and mushrooms made it so bland, threw most of it away. My husband had a meat one, he said it was fine.“

“My heart and soul are with this business. I have been eating pizza from them for 30+ years. Three different locations that I can remember. This newest location is super neat. Retro vibes, sports memorabilia, and lots of automotive themes are present. When I moved back to Columbus after many years, Don and Sue's was at the top of my list to enjoy. Great pizza, excellent beer variety, and kind smiling faces. Thank you for keeping fond memories alive!“

“Absolutely love the pizza and salads. our delivery orders always arrive quickly and are piping hot. We even got a surprise upgrade with our order tonight. My family and I highly reccomend.“

“the pizzas and beer are amazing and it's a great place to sit and relax , listen to some good music or sit out on the patio with a beautiful peaceful view. The people who work here are so friendly and helpful, just like visiting old friends. I highly recommend this place.“

“My wife and I just ordered dominos she had a free pizza from rewards and we both got wings.I would like to thank the team and our friendly driver for our delicious dinner.Thanks again will order again real soon.“

“Love the food and the small town vibe! Great pizza. Always recommend the Twisted Twins BBQ“

“The staff and owner is amazing and everyone at my sons graduation party loved it“

“Dirko’s provided outstanding assistance providing food for a local family. With a short notice. Their employee’s were extremely helpful and the pizzas were delicious. If you’ve not tried Dirko’s, give them a call. Thanks so much! Kim ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Great food! Neighborhood atmosphere & always friendly.“

“Great experience at this Creno’s location. We’ve never been to a pizza place where you selected your toppings from a “Subway sandwich “ type counter. The two of us ordered slightly different toppings, which these half&half selections were received and executed by the employee with willingness and friendliness. The pizza was cooked and ready within 5 minutes from the large pizza oven. Oh my! it was yummy! Toppings hot, melted (cheeses), with flavors nicely blended. The crust bottom was delightfully crunchy.Since we live near Zanesville we discussed the other Creno’s locations with the employee who told us this is the only location that he knows of that has this type of “build your own pizza”.We’ll definitely go back!, so much so that it’s worth driving the extra 10 miles.“

“I live in Mount Vernon Ohio and I drive all the way to North just to get their Pizza. Their Pizza is completely covered in pepperoni and cooked to a crispy perfection. We finally got a Pizza Cottage in Mount Vernon where I am from in the service is horrible as you can see on the reviews I live 10 minutes from Mount Vernon Pizza Cottage I ordered a pizza they told me it would be ready in 20 minutes this is when they very first opened at 11:00 in the morning. I got there within 10 minutes was very surprised that my pizza was ready. When they handed me the Box through the window I found it odd that it was cold. When I got home the pizza was cold as though it had been refrigerated overnight and they didn't even take the time to reheat it it just gave it to me as a cold leftover from last night I'm not joking it was literally refrigerated cold the pizza crust was super rubbery from being stored in the refrigerator. The customer service there is appalling. I will continue to drive to Newark from Mount Vernon to get the greatest Pizza in the world from that Pizza Cottage. Even by the time I get home from there my pizza was hotter than it was from Mount Vernon where I lived 10 minutes away nor have I ever been given cold leftover night pizza from Pizza Cottage of Newark. I would recommend them a thousand times over great customer service very clean restaurant great food always. Mount Vernon is the worst I would never recommend it to anybody not with their childish behavior on the inside nor their cold leftover pizza they didn't even bother to heat up before giving it to me when they first opened. Hopefully it closes down before it gets Pizza Cottage a bad name“

“Great service. The inside of the shop seemed dead/soulless. The salads were fresh. The stuffed crust was not great, sadly. The classic pep was just okay. They definitely changed something that took away that "wow this is awesome pizza"“

“Marco's pizza is so good i want to live it. I want to blend it down into a liquid and bathe in it. I wannna take that golden circle of flavor, melt it in a spoon and mainstream it into my veins. I want to make an honest woman outta that pizza, settle down and have little marco pizza bagels with it, send them off to pizza school so they can grow into smart happy fulfilled pizzas someday. We would age together gracefully and become more fond as the years go by. A happy pizza house filled with love. Thank you Marco's. I love you“

“Love their chef salads and boneless barbecue wings. And I love the fact they stay open until 4am. When every one else in this town has closed before 11pm, they dear to be different and stay open all night . Thanks for caring enough about us third shifters so we have some where to grab a meal on are way home from work.“