14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newark

Pizza Nerds Pizza Takeaway • $
2050 Cherry Valley Rd, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Garlic Cheese Bread
Large Garlic Bread
Kenny Rogers Pizza
Large Donkey Kong
Homemade Cookies
Medium Big Daddy
Specialty Pizza
L Tommy Pickles
Large Kramer

“Only thing missing from Pizza Nerds is dine in. The atmosphere, people and PIZZA are out of this world amazing! If you think Pizza Nerds isn’t the pizza spot, you’re “killing me Smalls!” And if you don’t get the reference, you don’t deserve Pizza Nerds pizza.We get the same pizza every time, and sometimes add cookies to our order, because those are also INCREDIBLE, too!!Wheelchair accessibility: The space is wheelchair accessible for pickup. The entrance is zero threshold, but the counter is a little high. There is no space for someone in a wheelchair to sit and wait, as it’s a small pizza spot without a dine in option….as of yet! But you could definitely, without much issue or frustration roll in and pickup your pizza. Honestly, they’re so nice if you let them know you needed accommodations, they’d probably bring it out to your vehicle.“

4.9 Superb133 Reviews
Old Fool Brewery Brewery • $
17495 Pinewood Trail Rd NE, Newark

“Ok! I came, I saw, I conquered!! Or, Veni, Vidi, Vici if you’re Julius Caesar! ? I’ve been saying I wanted to go check this place out for MONTHS and I finally made it in!!! I had looked up the menu and a couple things caught my eye that I wanted to try but mostly I was interested in the Root Beer on tap and the Homemade Cheesecake!!! I did try a couple items on the menu that were really good but I have fallen in love with the Root Beer and Cheesecake and will for sure return for those! ❤️❤️❤️ Thank you so much for the little visit, I know I was quiet tonight but I’m typically not!!! — Signed, Coriander ?“

5 Superb43 Reviews
Carmen's Pizza Pizza • $
106 W National Dr, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Personal Pepperoni Pizza with Meatballs
Big Meaty Pizza
White Pizza

“Excellent. Such a breath of fresh air to still have non-chain options for pizza. The value here is off the charts. I recommend Carmen's!We need to make it a priority to support these types of places... In this case, their good pizza makes it easy. They earn the support!“

5 Superb22 Reviews
Elliot's Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap Pizza • $
16 W Main St, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Elliot’S Meatball
Chicken Quesadilla
Classic Pepperoni
Wood Fired Pizza
Chips and Salsa
Goat Cheese
Pizza Oven
Greek Salad
Deep Fried
Meatballs

“A fantastic place to enjoy more than just pizza! However I must admit I'm partial to the chicken quesadilla pizza with the addition of pepperoni and Sriracha drizzle. I went today with my son and the waitress was spectacular! I'm saddened I didn't remember her name but she spent more than enough time making him feel special during the meal. Including jokes, special handshakes, individual conversation about his favorite Nintendo games - she was fantastic. That aside Elliot's has a fantastic menu beyond pizza - subs, smash burgers, even a fried rice option! If you're a fan of beer they always rotate their selection so the choices never stagnate. Give it a try I promise you won't be disappointed.Kid-friendliness: Wonderful staff and kids options. I will advise chicken tenders are 'off' the menu but still available to order.Wheelchair accessibility: There's several ramps leading onto the sidewalk to accomodations wheelchairs but the inside of the restaurant has higher than average tables for the majority of it's seating options. However. In the back are 2 or 3 regular height tables that can accommodate wheelchairs.“

4.5 Superb71 Reviews
Christy’s Pizza Pizza • $
15 E Church St, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Mini Any of Our Speciality Pizzas
Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Cheese
Baked Garlic Bread with Cheese
14 Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza with Chicken
Cheeseburger Pizza
Pepperoni & Cheese
Half and Half
Italian Pizza
Bread Sticks

“Delicious, consistent pizza. They use a sweet pizza sauce and the cheese is always perfect. I'm not a fan of their sausage but that's ok. Also their bread sticks without cheese are craveable!Parking: The location is downtown Newark. Depending on whether there is a show at the Midland or not you may be walking a few blocks to get to the restaurant.Kid-friendliness: The atmosphere is super friendly and clean with a table of simple kid toys as well.“

4.5 Superb63 Reviews
Bavellie's Pizzeria Pizza • $
2066 Cherry Valley Rd, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with a Side of Marinara Sauce
Double Pepperoni Pizza
Large Cheese Calzone
Supreme Pizza
Italian Sub
Side Salad
Meat Pizza
Dressing

“During our weekend getaway to Newark, from Columbus, we wanted to try a local pizza spot. Bavellies is a small establishment with great customer service. We decided to eat in their dining room. Ordered a small veggie pizza, steak sub, and small salad. The sub was delicious as the bread was really fresh. I enjoyed the thi. crust of the pizza and toppings were fresh. I would visit again if in the area.“

4.4 Superb47 Reviews
DeFelice Bros Pizza - Newark Pizza • $
1976 Granville Rd STE B, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Large Pepperoni and Banana Peppers
Cheese Breadsticks
Everything Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Spinach Ricotta
Pepperoni Roll
Italiano Sub

“Definitely not for the donatos crowd. This pizza is saucy and has an incredible thicker buttery crust. It honestly reminds me of how pizza hut pan pizza used to taste in the 80s. It's a very distinctive style and none of the places around newark make a pizza like this.“

4.4 Superb34 Reviews
SONNYS PIZZA AND SUBS Pizza • $
391 W Main St, Newark

“Tried a larg b.l.t. pizza and it was good and had a very fair share of toppings...... So the next day decided to try some wings bone in and bone out the garlic Parm sauce was fire. Potato wedges and cheese bread was fire to..... Oh and got delivered in like 40 minutes food was plenty hot when it arrived!“

5 Superb9 Reviews
Creno's Quickfire Pizza Pizza • $
1265 Log Pond Dr, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Make It Your Way Supreme Pizza
11 Build Your Own Pizza
Double Pepperoni Pizza
Everything Meat Pizza

“This is probably the cleanest food place I have ever walked into! Somehow I missed that they have been in that location almost 6 yrs. Because my first question was did you just get this location it’s so clean! The 2 ladies working were absolutely wonderful very pleasant, I was greeted at my entry and they both were very kind “good cs skills”“

4.4 Superb31 Reviews
Panther Pizza & Bakery Pizza • $
2448 W High St NE, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Crazy Bread to Die for It's Worth Driving from Blacklick Just for the Crazy Bread
Carlic Parmesan Crust Pepperoni and Mushroom Pie Cut
Pepperoni Pizzas Baking for School Order
Traditional Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza for School Order
Cheese Pizza for Booster Order
Stuffed Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Chicago Deep Dish Taco Pizza
The Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
Chicken blt -75 Favorite

“Delicious! Quality taste and ingredients. I don't live close so it's not often I get to visit. But it's well worth the stop. The employees are courteous and about pleasing the customer. The wings are nice size. The Stromboli was excellent. The dough and sauces are very good!“

4.3 Superb29 Reviews
Too Talls Pizza Pizza • $
529 E Main St #6619, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sub
Too Tall Sub
blt Sub
Pizza
Salad

“Past 30 yrs I've lived in Pataskala and Glenford , and I'll drive here without any regret. Won't find better prices . The best Italian sub I've ever had . Dressing absolutely amazing. Good variety of ice cold beverages. Have always treated me wonderfully .“

4.3 Superb28 Reviews
Debra's Pizza Pizza • $
318 Hudson Ave, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Mushroom Onion Pizza
Potato Wedges
Taco Salad
Italian
Sub
blt

“Love dans family pizza subs but they closed down sadly...but found Debbie's pizza and there subs are just like dans...amazing...out with Dan and in with debbie!...update..just had there pizza and it's not bad...thin crust is best in my opinion“

4.3 Superb24 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
1226 N 21st St, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Deluxe Pizza
Tater Tots
Lava Cake

“I've been enjoying pizza for decades, and I've encountered some impressive pies along the way. However, Domino's Pizza on 21st Street in Newark, Ohio, takes the cake—or rather, the crust. Their pan, crispy crust sets the stage for an exceptional pizza experience. The tangy and flavorful sauce, combined with gooey, delicious cheese, creates a symphony of taste in every bite. Toppings are consistently fresh and abundant, elevating the overall flavor profile to new heights. While the mushroom pizza holds a special place in my heart, the sausage and mushroom pizza is a close contender. If you're on the hunt for the pinnacle of pizza perfection in town, look no further. Domino's on 21st Street delivers an experience that will leave you craving more with each bite.“

4.2 Good46 Reviews
Slingin’ Pizza Pizza Delivery • $$
1234 W Church St, Newark

“I've ordered from Slingin' Pizza several times and have never been disappointed! The pies are baked to the perfect crispness and they certainly don't skimp on the toppings. Stop ordering overpriced pizzas from chains and support this place!“

4.5 Superb11 Reviews
Loading...
map Map