Italian Restaurants near Bethany

“Never have a problem at this little Caesar’s, they always try their best to help the customers. I’ve noticed that some of the customers are real disrespectful to those poor kids. I hope they know they don’t have to be stuck there forever wish them the best in life. Other than that I love this location.“

“You have to leave town to find a comparable Italian Restaurant to Primo's“

“Thoroughly enjoyed our lunch. Great, friendly and knowledgeable service with a smile. Went the extra mile. Took care of dietary needs making all feel welcomed and comfortable. Food was amazing!“

“Dishes we tried were delicious. Welcoming atmosphere, great service and friendly staff. Definitely a new favorite!“

“My husband and I tried Luigi’s Bistro for the first time the other day for lunch, and we were absolutely blown away. I ordered the Florentine pasta and my husband ordered the chicken Alfredo. The food was incredible. You can tell the recipes are authentic and family-owned, and the Alfredo sauce is hands-down some of the best we’ve ever had. It was so good that we literally went back the same night for dinner just so we could order the Alfredo again! Not only was the food amazing, but the service was excellent as well. Everything felt welcoming and genuinely cared for. I’ve been craving that Alfredo sauce ever since and cannot wait to go back again. If you’re looking for delicious, authentic Italian food with great service, Luigi’s Bistro is a must.“

“We went tonight got our 48th Anniversary. I had pecan crusted Salmon with fresh steamed vegetables, my husband had the lasagna. Both meals were perfect. Delicious. We had the chocolate cake (wow great) and the hot seafood dip was unbelievable. The staff was amazing and the atmosphere was perfect. Thank you we will be back.“

“When we entered, we were greeted by a very friendly person and taken to our seat. They have quiet 4 top booths that are really private cubbies. The decor is very warm and inviting. Our service by Marsala was outstanding. We shared bruschetta (might have been among the best I've ever had). My wife had lasagna and I have the veal piccata...both were excellent. Nice portions and cooked to perfection. We shared a brandy ice...and it was also one of the best we've had. Nice wine selection. I can't believe this place has been here 6 years and we hadn't heard about it!! We'll be back...and will be bringing friends!!“

“Our experience was overall very good and we will be back, hopefully for a five star experience instead of a four star. The food was excellent, everyone enjoyed their ravioli, the inducer, carbonara, and custom pastas. Special shout out to the inducer. Service was amazing until we said we were ready for the check. 30 minutes later we received our checks. That was so bizarre. We had plans to go to a couple more places before picking up the kids from the babysitter, but had to reduce our plans based on the extra half hour we spent here. There is definitely room for improvement on the end of seating experience.“

“It was delicious!! Service was amazing“

“Olive Garden's lighter portions and buy one take one home deals are perfect in this challenging economy. The food is tasty and the atmosphere hasn't changed much since my childhood, and I'm okay with that! We always receive good service here.“

“From the moment we walked into Johnny Carino's, we knew we were in for a treat. The inviting ambiance combined with the aroma of authentic Italian cooking set the stage for a fantastic dining experience. I decided to indulge in the Johnny’s Burger, and let me tell you, it was nothing short of amazing! Juicy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection, it was a gustatory delight that left me fully satisfied. My wife opted for the create-your-own dish, selecting the Reggaetoni paired with creamy sauce, and she couldn’t stop raving about the freshness of the pasta and the rich flavors in every bite. Our son chose the Parmesan chicken, which he devoured gleefully, leaving no morsel behind. What truly elevated our experience, however, was our server... Jeff! He took the time to offer recommendations and truly tailor our meal according to our tastes. His attentive service and friendly demeanor made us feel like valued guests rather than just customers. He also was a manager which added to the overall feeling of exceptional hospitality. Overall, Johnny Carino's delivered an excellent dining experience with delicious food, impeccable service, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. We left with full bellies and happy hearts, eagerly planning our next visit. If you’re looking for a place where you can enjoy comforting Italian cuisine while being treated like family, look no further than Johnny Carino's. We can’t wait to return!“

“Try the squid ink pasta, you won’t be disappointed. Everything we have had here is top notch. We wound up being there well after closing time and the staff was gracious and joined us in conversation. Truly a first rate, top notch experience. I would recommend to anyone.“

“Dropped by for lunch. Excellent salad, lettice crisp and cold. Pizza just perfect. Waiter wuiet and efficient. Thanks for the dining experience“

“Everything was great! FOOD was really good. Service was wonderful (even suggesting food choices, that we loved). Rolls are extra special. I experienced a delightful meal and plan on going back often! Like tonight!!!“

“My wife and I went there for our anniversary. The atmosphere was really good. Loved hearing Dean Martin and Frank Sinatra playing while we ate. Our server, Chase, was very friendly, very attending. He even gave us a free cheesecake of our choice when finding out it was our anniversary. The only flaw was the taste my wifes fettuccini alfredo on the Tour of Venice was flat tasting. Everything else was delicious. I had the veal cacciatore and it was outstanding. Let me tell you that you get your moneys worth on the portions as well. So much food! We will go back again. Highly recommend.“

“Great food and service! Definitely recommend, will be back.“

“Fantastic dinner! This was our first try but we love Italian food. Highly recommend, service was amazing and food was on point“

“Delicious food and service. Try the jalapeno tilapia! Fantastic! Shout out to server Renee, who is efficient and attentive.“

“Really liked the salad, service and bar area. Food could have been hotter and the Alfredo was bland. Had gorgonzola steak pasta and it was good but sauce lacked flavor. Staff in bar area and host boy were perfect. I had jot tried an Olive Garden since the 80s. Enjoyed it.“

“I stopped here and had dinner with my 13 year old daughter. It was a wonderful experience the server was great the atmosphere was comfortable and food was outta sight!! I had the braised beef tortelloni and it was an amazing experience. One of the best plates of food I've had in a long time. We don't get out much as I am a single father but this was an exceptional use of our splurge night. Thank you for a great experience.“

“Fantastic experience from beginning to end! Great cocktails, great meals, and excellent deserts. The service was friendly and professional and the ambience was upscale yet fun with decor that recalls the 60s. The pasta dishes are some of the best I've had in Oklahoma. In truth, it was quite unexpected. Likewise, I haven't had tiramisu this good in quite some time. I can't recommend Mary Eddy's enough. Go, enjoy, mangiare!“

“Love it all especially the Italian Nachos“

“shrimp fettuccini chicken Alfredo chicken express. chicken marsalla. chicken parmesa. SPECIALTY pizza express White pizza 🍕 pizza chicken Alfredo calzone stramboli.“

“Eli was terrific, Friday night curbside pickup, and he went above and beyond for us. Thank you, Eli!“