16 Best Ice Cream Shops in Broken Arrow

“I wish this allowed for stars and not just "recommend" and "not recommend." I chose the recommend option because it is still a good place but I've been super disappointed the last couple times I've gone/attempted to go. The last time I went in, the ice cream was visibly soft. I tried a couple samples and it was more foam than ice cream. I like frozen solid ice cream. My husband got some but I passed. It was summer and I have worked in ice cream stores before so I chalked it up to the heat coming in and said I'd give it another chance. The past two times (tonight included) that I've tried going, there's no parking. Between the surrounding buildings and hotel parking/valet, there's no space for customers. I give up. They are good but not park and walk a mile away good. I miss the Boxyard location. (And no, I don't go to to BA so I don't go to that location.) 4/5 stars for quality and flavors. 1/5 stars for ease/convenience and location.“

“Drove nearly 2 hours for some delicious Andy’s custard. Yes, it’s that good. Super friendly staff too. I got the Key Lime concrete and my wife got a banana and strawberry concrete- delicious! Can’t wait for the pumpkin pie to make a reappearance.“

“The expression from our Grand baby every time we bring these home. #littlest/biggestfan“

“Great place to get small groceries. We love their bread, eggs, bacon, and of course ice cream, but this is also the only place we buy milk, and we pit their ice in our icemaker, vs having it made...it's the perfect ice.

This is also my favorite Braums in the area.“

“Best pineapple whip I have ever had. I go at least once a week whenever it opens every year. Also the people that work there are always nice and the wait time is short!“

“My kids and I have been to La Tropical in Broken Arrow 3-4 times now. The Ice cream is superb, the popsicles are works of art, and the fresh fruit water drinks are delicious and refreshing.Service is always outstanding. If you haven't ever been to a Mexican ice cream parlor before you need to try it!“

“Bag of burgers is a go to meal for kids when money is tight. Also, their market store is a delight. They offer a full range dozens of ice cream flavors. In a pitch, or if you want to avoid the big grocery chains, give Braums Market a try. It's also the only place I've been able to find the more digestable A2 milk.“

“Food is typically always on point!! The workers themselves leave a little bit to be desired, very rude and like to act like your not standing there at the counter for 15 mins waiting for someone to take your order!!! Very rude and unprofessional!!! Managers included!!“

“Marble Slab is an absolute delight for ice cream enthusiasts! The moment you step into the store, the tantalizing aroma of freshly made waffle cones greets you, setting the stage for a truly delightful experience. The variety of flavors and mix-ins is astonishing, allowing you to create a personalized masterpiece that caters perfectly to your taste buds.The ice cream itself is rich, creamy, and incredibly satisfying, a testament to the high-quality ingredients they use. Each spoonful is a delightful journey of flavors and textures that keep you coming back for more. The unique marble slab technique they employ to mix in your chosen ingredients adds an element of excitement and customization to the process, making each visit a memorable adventure.The youthful employees, often high schoolers, bring a refreshing energy to the atmosphere. While they may still be refining their customer service skills, their genuine enthusiasm for the ice cream and their willingness to accommodate your preferences make for a charming interaction. It's endearing to witness their growth and development as they learn to navigate the world of customer service.In a nutshell, Marble Slab not only serves exceptional ice cream but also creates a heartwarming experience. The slight imperfections in customer service only add to the authenticity of the place. So, if you're seeking a delightful treat that's served with a side of youthful exuberance, Marble Slab is the place to be!“

“This is a really neat atmosphere! The menu is awesome and my kids really enjoyed it here!“

“Best tasting frozen yogurt with so many flavor options!!!! Always clean ! Friendly staff“

“Love this Great American Cookie location! The employees are always so kind, and we love getting the individual cookies or the double doozies ( & no such thing as too much icing)! They always taste fresh, are so soft, and a double doozie is the same price as any other gourmet cookie franchise cookie too!“

“All around fair experience. Breakfast menu includes some good choices, same with the lunch menu. The candy ice cream mix tends to be sickeningly sweet if you let it sit for a bit. Employees were hard working, with lines both inside and outside.

Dietary restrictions: Lots of diary options, so be wary before deciding if you are lactose intolerant.“

“The mini donuts are delicious, and the location is adorable!“

“Stopped in during a long trip and was a hot day. Good job on timely delivery of my food so that I could get back on the road!

Parking: Not super friendly for busses, but it works out if you know what you are doing

Kid-friendliness: Kids meals are great my kids love them“

“I dont know who the young blond woman is that works weekdays in the early morning, but she always recognizes me and greets me with a smile and I just want everyone to know what a beautiful job they did with my chili dog. The only one I've ever gotten from Sonic that looked picture worthy

Vegetarian options: There are vegetarian options

Wheelchair accessibility: Would not be hard to get a wheelchair to the tables outside. Also they have a handicap drive in stall“