8 Best Pizza Restaurants in Eufaula

Mama Tig's Wood Fired Pizza Pizza • $
123 Selmon Rd, Eufaula

Customers` Favorites

Lunch Special Half Single Topping Half Bread Sticks
The Famous Westbrook Supreme Pizza
Cookie Dough Dessert Pizza
Margherita with Pepperoni
Mama Tig's 10 Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Bruschetta Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Butter

“Mama Tigs is Awesome. Have had the supreme pizza and Italian sub. Excellent food using quality ingredients and excellent service. They really want to make sure you are happy with the food. You can. Sign up for discount points. The shop is kept clean. They have several locations. It's a bit hard driving by to see if they are open. That's the only fault.“

4.8 Superb76 Reviews
Island Xtreme Bar and Grill Bar • $
400 1/2 Lakeshore Dr, Eufaula

Customers` Favorites

Fried Pickles

“I visited for a community meeting held here and lunch was served. We had pizza made in the kitchen along with the full salad bar. It was great tasting pizza with an awesome thick crust and loaded with fresh ingredients. The salad bar was impressive with everything made available to choose from. I don't go to Eufaula very often but would return here for the pizza. I've not been here since the new owners and management nor during normal business hours (reserved for meeting midweek while they were closed) so I can't speak to the service. Good venue for the meeting with ample seating in separate area and presentation equipment available.“

4.8 Superb23 Reviews
Pete's Pizza & Wings Pizza • $
16651 OK-9, Eufaula

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza
Chicken Wings

“Bought 24 Daylight Donuts for 10yo birthday. Was able to pick out flavors and toppings and can't super customizable for our daughter. Her favorite was strawberry frosting with fruity pebbles. The ladies working are super sweet and patient and the donuts were great. More Krispy Kreme yeasty pillowy ones instead of the cake ones at Dunkin. So glad we have a place here in Longtown now.“

4.7 Superb47 Reviews
Godfather's Pizza Express Pizza • $$
1601 Birkes Rd, Eufaula

Customers` Favorites

Large Taco Pie on Golden Crust
Mini Specialty Pizza
Black Olives
Pizza Rolls
Veggie Pie
Hot Wings

“Godfather's is hands down one of the best places to get a pizza Eufala Oklahoma in loves travel stops I know the manager and she will do you right I had and Godfthers that I ran myself and had very good reviews. They had some new people but try to get Melissa Luna or the manager when you cal great stuff guys“

4.6 Superb14 Reviews
Mama Tig's Wood Fired Pizza Carlton Landing Pizza • $
31 Water St, Eufaula

“Incredible pizza and great atmosphere. Ignore the goofy people giving low reviews that just complain about misrepresented hours…the operators were unaware, acknowledged immediately, and worked to get everything updated. You won’t be disappointed with this place!“

4.4 Superb30 Reviews
Simple Simon's Pizza (inside Lakeview Grocery) Pizza Takeaway •
418990 Texanna Rd, Eufaula

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Stix with Cheese
Pepperoni Pounder Pizza
Cheeseburger Pizza
Supreme Calizone

“Wow! Best and biggest calzone I have ever tried. It almost filled an entire 12" pizza box. They don't skimp on the ingredients. One can definitely feed two people, possibly three.I placed the order through Doordash. It showed up quickly and was still piping hot. ? Thanks!Kid-friendliness: Almost all kids love pizza.“

4.3 Superb19 Reviews
Chaney's Pizza Pizza • $
119 Oak Ave, Eufaula

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch
Jalapeño Bacon
Lunch Bullet
Hot Wings

“Loved the buffet! We come to town once a month and will definitely be our new spot!!!! Amazing service great prices the pizza was delicious and a great salad bar!Kid-friendliness: Staff is great with children they make you feel at homeWheelchair accessibility: Easy access from car to door also easy to move around in wheelchair in dining room and at the pizza and salad bar.“

4.2 Good28 Reviews
Simple Simon's Pizza Pizza •
600 Main St, Eufaula

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Calizone
The Original Calizone
The Supreme Pizza
Stuffed Crust
Salad Bar
Alpine

“We got there when it first started at 5:00 pm. Salad bar had everything on it I like and was fresh. Pizza was hot and fresh they had pepperoni, supreme, cheesy bread sticks and an apple crumb for desert. Asked if there was something special we would like.“

4.2 Good32 Reviews
Loading...
map Map