Restaurants in Eufaula

“This was our first time, ordering and eating from Mama Tigs Wood Fired Pizza, and we ordered the Westbrook (Supreme) w/Anchovies, to take home. Outstanding, appetizing and so delicious. It was a 14", the crust was tasty, the overall pizza including the anchovies, was wonderful. Fresh, delightful and so awesome. Thank you for your kind, fast service, wonderful atmosphere, and inviting restaurant, we will be back. Sorry we have not tried this first-class pizza restaurant, before. Thank you, Sincerely, Randy and Gayle Cook, Eufaula, Oklahoma. ❤”

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Captain John’s is hands down my local favorite restaurant. I eat here multiple times a week and can honestly say I’ve never had a bad experience and never had a bad meal. The servers here are some of the best in Oklahoma — an incredible staff that genuinely cares and checks on you every time you walk through the door. The atmosphere is always welcoming, positive, and uplifting, and they’re consistently open and dependable, which matters more than people realize. Captain John’s is a big part of what makes Eufaula such a great place — consistent, reliable, and continuing to grow while doing things the right way. I’m very thankful for this place and make it a point to bring every guest who comes to the lake here on their first trip… and without fail, they all return. If you’re visiting Lake Eufaula or live here and haven’t made Captain John’s a regular stop yet, you’re missing out. A true staple of the community. 🍽️👏”

“Visiting; most friendly back home hidden Gem place. I was there 18 and 20 March 2022; the young lady wearing shorts is a really hard worker, best service I had. She had wheels on the bottom of her shoes I think. Cheese omelet was awesome. Service was excellent. Will be back in May. Will stop by there every time, delicious.”

“Barista very pleasant and helpful with ordering!”

“Delicious food, fun atmosphere, and exceptional service”

“excellent nachos and fajitas, very friendly staff and one of the best in Mcalester”

“Love the apple fritters, the customer service, and the prices!!!”

“The queso is soooo good and their burritos are awesome! 😜 super friendly and when you order, they give you a buzzer to tell you when your food is ready to wait in the car!”

“The owner's are very friendly and they have a great selection. I personally enjoy their "special" donuts and garlic sausage rolls!”

“Make sure you get what you order if it’s a togo order. We ordered and didn’t get anything near what we ordered. Ended up with 2 enchilada dinners. 🤦‍♂️. Food was good just not what we ordered. We ordered the Degollado special and the Mexican Flag Combo.”

“Great service and cute bartender”

“Wonderful atmosphere! Waitress was so pleasant! Highly recommended”

“Everything was well seasoned & delicious!”

“Great food, great service!”

“friendly service, cheap prices, hope to keep catching you at North Beach. =)”

“A family favorite, one of the best chicken fried chicken and chicken fried steak in the area, chicken livers are perfect, service is excellent.”

“This is the gem of Eufaula! Staff is amazing. The pastries, breads, English muffins are all delicious! Worth the drive from McAlester for excellent croissants, cruffins, galettes, tartes, quiche and more!!!”

“LOVE local! Always friendly, fast service and the teas are so delicious!! Not to mention the staff is 10/10!! They definitely know how to hire great people!! ♥️”

“The Best Place Ever! 🎤🎶🤠”

“we ate their around 1230 9/17/2025 and the fries were rubber hard to eat like old potatoes, the toast is also stale was like rubber trying to get a bite of it. The chicken fried was good the okra was old also, and the omelet was good. we had to wait a good 30 to 45 min to get it then it was awful. Use to love that place.Sharron”

“This was our first time, ordering and eating from Mama Tigs Wood Fired Pizza, and we ordered the Westbrook (Supreme) w/Anchovies, to take home. Outstanding, appetizing and so delicious. It was a 14", the crust was tasty, the overall pizza including the anchovies, was wonderful. Fresh, delightful and so awesome. Thank you for your kind, fast service, wonderful atmosphere, and inviting restaurant, we will be back. Sorry we have not tried this first-class pizza restaurant, before. Thank you, Sincerely, Randy and Gayle Cook, Eufaula, Oklahoma. ❤”

“Tall skinny short hair Guy today at 1130 am kept washing his hands explaining the menu working hard fast and safe great customer service & cooking the food all at the same time. 👍”

“This is only our second spring owning a modest short term rental in CL. We love going to the meeting house for coffee and fresh breakfast on the griddle, but we just found out that it’s open in the evenings during all of spring break and other dates. Therefore, we had to get a smash burger and a beer, with friends, our first night back since NYE. While we were eating, staff lit the wood fireplaces outside. What a dream. We met one of the owners too, and she was such a delight. I can’t recommend this place enough. It gets busy in peak season so be patient. Park your golf cart, order up and relax on the patio. You won’t regret it.”

“Service was fast and friendly. Food prepared fresh, piled high with meat, vegetables and cheese. Toasted to perfection. Cost was fair and reasonable. Would recommend to others.”

“All their food is great! But their hand breaded chicken strips are my favorite!!!”

“Had lunch at Maverick's Cafe on Taco Tuesday before heading out of town and overall it was a pretty solid stop.
Place was surprisingly quiet when we went in, only saw maybe one other customer the whole time, which was funny because we had driven by the night before and it looked pretty busy. Service was friendly though, and our server made sure to tell us about the Taco Tuesday specials, so we added a couple birria tacos to go with lunch. Glad we did. Those tacos were really good with plenty of flavor and a nice little kick from the salsa on the side.
The enchiladas and flautas were filling and came out hot. The white queso was definitely the better choice over the yellow queso in our opinion. Only thing that missed the mark for us was the salsa, which had more of a spaghetti sauce flavor than the traditional Mexican restaurant salsa we expected.
Other than that, food was good, prices were fair, and the service was attentive. If you’re in Eufaula and craving casual Mexican food, it’s worth stopping by and especially worth checking out the Taco Tuesday specials.”

“Love Casey’s! They have the best pizza. Crust is chewy and wonderful. They were out of mushrooms for my supreme and I think the green peppers are cut too big. And too many. But very good pizza!! Good job guys!”

“Service is Great! Food is Awesome! The Fajitas are always Excellent! La Finca is the restaurant to go for Mexican food at Lake Eufaula!!”

“Simple Simon's Pizza-Eufaula, Ok. Thank you for making our Super-Bowl Evening, top notch. The Big 10 Large Pizza was outstanding. The taste, fresh ingredients, big slices, and wonderful customer service is outstanding. ❤️ We had two slices each and have plenty for tomorrow evening. Something to look forward to and was so convenient since we ordered it yesterday; . . .to be picked up at about 5:15PM on Sunday. Thank you again, for making our 'Football Super-Bowl Night. . . .awesome. ❤️ Sincerely, Gayle & Randy Cook Eufaula, Oklahoma. U.S.A.”

“We need more of these restaurants around tulsa , like around the east side of the state , they have great food , great prices , and i've always enjoyed the friendly staff.”

“Food was delicious and timely, but the best part was that I left my wedding ring in the restroom on a work trip. They put it in the safe and held onto it for me until I was able to get back a few days later. Thank you Barbara!!! You and the rest of the staff are amazing!”