14 Best Italian Restaurants near Mustang

“My wife and I went there for our anniversary. The atmosphere was really good. Loved hearing Dean Martin and Frank Sinatra playing while we ate. Our server, Chase, was very friendly, very attending. He even gave us a free cheesecake of our choice when finding out it was our anniversary. The only flaw was the taste my wifes fettuccini alfredo on the Tour of Venice was flat tasting. Everything else was delicious. I had the veal cacciatore and it was outstanding. Let me tell you that you get your moneys worth on the portions as well. So much food! We will go back again. Highly recommend.“

“The manager Robin is the reason we go here! Hands down best customer service and clean everytime salad bar always on point! My kids and I consider Robin and the entire Mazzio's Mustang crew family!“

“You have to leave town to find a comparable Italian Restaurant to Primo's“

“We love Emma Elle’s! The service is always extraordinary. The food is delicious, and the gluten free options are no extra charge.“

“Ate here for the first time tonight. Absolutely loved it and Brett our server did an amazing job! Will be coming back for sure.“

“I went there after a funeral of my sister-in-law. I was hoping for a nice calm dinner. Instead I got a rush job of get the hell out of here.
I used to go to the Olive Gardens in Colorado, due to I was a field tech for computer systems. Though I could complain to the manager in person, I never needed to.
Here in the OKC metro, all of the OG's have an attitude of hurry up and get the F$&#k out of here. Kinda of a real bummer for wanting a old fashioned dinner in an Italian restaurant..“

“From the moment we walked into Johnny Carino's, we knew we were in for a treat. The inviting ambiance combined with the aroma of authentic Italian cooking set the stage for a fantastic dining experience. I decided to indulge in the Johnny’s Burger, and let me tell you, it was nothing short of amazing! Juicy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection, it was a gustatory delight that left me fully satisfied. My wife opted for the create-your-own dish, selecting the Reggaetoni paired with creamy sauce, and she couldn’t stop raving about the freshness of the pasta and the rich flavors in every bite. Our son chose the Parmesan chicken, which he devoured gleefully, leaving no morsel behind. What truly elevated our experience, however, was our server... Jeff! He took the time to offer recommendations and truly tailor our meal according to our tastes. His attentive service and friendly demeanor made us feel like valued guests rather than just customers. He also was a manager which added to the overall feeling of exceptional hospitality. Overall, Johnny Carino's delivered an excellent dining experience with delicious food, impeccable service, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. We left with full bellies and happy hearts, eagerly planning our next visit. If you’re looking for a place where you can enjoy comforting Italian cuisine while being treated like family, look no further than Johnny Carino's. We can’t wait to return!“

“One does not simply eat one breadstick at Fazoli's.“

“The staff is super friendly and welcoming from the moment we walked in. Service is quick and attentive. And the food? So good! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Definitely coming back—highly recommend! Can’t forget the Mazzios Ranch!!“

“Good pizza, usually good service but tonight refills on drinks were nonexistent, they would come by and ask if you need anything but never brought marinara when asked for it and the pizzas came out without pizza spatulas.“

“It was our first time eating here and the pizza was AMAZING!!! We'll definitely be back.“

“I had to check this place out after seeing so many people prefer it over the chain stores. It didn't disappoint, the owner cooked the pizza himself, friendly, well presented, fresh and delicious! The pepperoni was the clear favorite- will.be back!“

“This local gem is everything you want in a pizza spot—authentic flavors, a small and cozy atmosphere, and super friendly staff. The taste is absolutely great, and the service is fast enough to make it a perfect go-to for a quick, delicious bite!“

“We just moved here and haven’t had luck finding good pizza, UNTIL we tried All American Pizza. Delicious!“