Coney Island Stillwater

$ • Hot Dogs, American, Sports Bars

Hours today·

About Coney Island Stillwater

Coney Island Stillwater is a fantastic hangout spot with incredible space and even better food. The crawdaddy, cheeseburger, and loaded chicken bacon ranch fries are highly recommended. The chili dog and tots are also really good, served by friendly staff, although some wish the dogs were bigger. The wings are a must-try, with one happy customer proclaiming them the best ever. The food is delicious, and the area around the restaurant has Oklahoma State sport memorabilia and the colors of the university. Customers say the service is great, and one customer praised the hard-working cook who handled orders on his own. Some feel the prices are high for the food, but many say the chili dogs are the best and the pricing is a bargain. The environment is greatly enhanced by the staff, especially Taylor, the manager, who has earned praise for her dedication and passion for her work. Many customers feel that she is what makes Coney Island special and contributes to its welcoming atmosphere. Dining at Coney Island is a delightful experience in Stillwater, OK.

Menu

Add a Menu
Coney Island Stillwater Menu
Coney Island Stillwater Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Coney Island Stillwater
Coney Island Stillwater
View All Photos

Coney Island Stillwater Reviews

3.7
214 ratings
5
61%
4
7%
3
1%
2
3%
1
28%
Food
4.4
Atmosphere
4.3
Service
4.3

Share your opinion about Coney Island Stillwater

Great service and great food as usual! I’m terrible with names but shout out to guy in there this evening, working hard taking orders and cooking them up on his own! Fantastic job, just as my previous visit there, and I will be back again!
Stopped in for delicious coneys and chili cheese tots! The bar has great drinks and great service!
The service was quick. Food was amazing and the waitstaff very friendly!!

Read All Reviews(214)

Hours

Monday 11AM - 9PM
Tuesday 11AM - 9PM
Wednesday 11AM - 9PM
Thursday 11AM - 2AM
Friday 11AM - 2AM
Saturday 11AM - 2AM
Sunday 11AM - 9PM
Updated on: