44 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elmira

“The best panzerotti‘s in town“

“Great pizza, great price, convenient location for those of us who commute. Thank you for being the best!“

“Was driving back from a trip and thought to maybe grab a pizza since I havent really eaten thew whole day. I havent had Pizza hut for like 10 years but decided to try it now and litterally omg, the BEST pizza I ever had. I ordered the veggie pizza which also happened to be on special that day so it genuinely was a double win. Guys at the counter were chill and the pizza came out fast. Super super good, genuinely amazing pizza.“

“Very great experience! Ujjwal gave wonderful service and was very pleasant to talk to.“

“decided to make the trip down from Wingham and it was well worth it. I think it has to be the closest to Real Italian pizza around here. I will def be coming back. And yes I'm one of those Italians who eats pineapple on pizza🤣LOL“

“Excellent Pizza and friendly staff/“

“We drove from Toronto to see St Jacobs during Christmas and stoped here for lunch. The place is adorable, with even the bathroom full of charm. And the food was insanely good. Staff was friendly too. This is a must every time we are in the area.“

“This was the best pizza I have ever had. 100% get those garlic sticks. They are so incredible.“

“I have picked up pizza here sometimes and the store is always clean and organized. I recommend this place.“

“Edited: Previously, I had a complaint because there were some fruit flies flying near the pizzas. I visited this place again recently and the hygene was excellent. So either the owner saw my review and dealt with the hygene or I just visited on a really bad day before, in either case, I'm very happy to see improvement.

I recommend the takeaway special, it is freshly prepared and tastes excellent.“

“We just took advantage of the 2 Large 4 toppings with 2 drinks and 2 dips. Excellent! Fresh, generous toppings, great crust. Friendly, efficient service; family owned. An asset to the neighbourhood. Give them a try....you won't be disappointed!“

“very good pizza.“

“Great tasting pizza at a reasonable price. Prompt delivery and service!“

“I ordered online a thin pepperoni pizza and i didn’t know that comes with oregano, my son can’t eat it with different flavours. I talked with them and they make a new one right away, even though it was a busy night and they had lots of orders to do . the stuff here it’s friendly and great. they didn’t want to charge me for the second one. We get our pizza from here all the time . Please make sure to leave a great tip for the hard working guys.“

“Finally made it out to try this place, I’m disappointed we waited so long! Everything was amazing. The brisket was some of the best Ive had and the Brussel sprouts were out of this world. Great cocktail and beer selection as well. Our server Shana was fantastic, we didn’t need for anything ! Will definitely be returning.“

“when we went toma was helping out two other customers who could not speak English but he was very considerate and patient with them, no judgement and no frustration just a wonderful man running his establishment. price is unbeatable with a large pizza and two sauces feeding two people for 20$ total“

“Tried Canadian Pizza for the first time, and I was seriously impressed. I got a 5-topping pizza for just $14.99, which is a crazy good deal these days. But the best part? The pizza was actually amazing—loaded with toppings, cooked perfectly, and super flavorful. They even gave us a free dip.

If you’re looking for great pizza without spending a fortune, this place is 100% worth it. Definitely going back!“

“THIS IS THE VERY BEST PIZZA IN TOWN! AHMED IS THE BEST AT MAKING DELICIOUS PIZZA.“

“Pizza Bella makes fantastic pizza !!! There large oven makes for a delicious crust. if you like wings... they have great wings and lots of hot sauces I recommend the crimson creepy & Chipotle Ghost !!! I Definitely advice anyone to try them out !!!“

“I love my pizza...BBQ base, chicken, green peppers, onions, well-done, thick crust... this place is by far... the best pizza I've had in the waterloo region.

Its so good, I went back the next day...today! Well done guys! I wish I lived closer. My god...keep it up.

Cheers!“

“We ordered three types of pizza one veggie, Cesar chicken and chicken club. They all were amazing especially chicken Cesar was a total flavor bomb. Must try place if you are looking for good pizza. The owner, Vivian is a really nice guy too.“

“Yummy every time Awesome staff fast delivery hot food“

“My initial experience with this business was that it was just another pizza joint. However, yesterday’s experience changed that. I had ordered two pizzas, one of which was undercooked. I took back that pizza for it to be replaced with one that was cooked all the way through. The young lady at the counter was very polite and apologetic. What’s more is the freshly cooked pizza was ready right away and was perfectly prepared. Great service recovery. The last thing a dissatisfied customer wants to hear is an argument. Keep up the good work.“

“Great tasting pizza, love the cup and char pepperoni, especially with extra sauce! Crust is great. Always been consistent. A weekly meal!“

“* Wonderful pizza - delicious ! ? Great staff as well ? Very highly recommended ✨✅“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I had a great experience at this pizza place! The worker was very friendly and provided excellent service. He was respectful, attentive, and made sure we were comfortable. He was also quick with our order and kept a smile on his face the whole time. As for the pizza, it was absolutely delicious—the dough was soft, and the ingredients were fresh. I highly recommend this place, especially if you’re looking for great food and top-notch service. Big thanks to the worker for his kindness! I’ll definitely be coming back.“

“It’s honestly the best pizza in the KW region. If you’ve never tried their food. You’re missing out. The family is so friendly and want to satisfy every customer. When food is bad, I’ll say so. This is great food.“

“Scott was fantastic and the wings were wonderful, big screens and playoff hockey! Can't go wrong...“

“Tried last night on my neighbour's recommendation. Best pizza I have ever had in my entire life.“

“great service . fast and good presentation of the food they make .“

“By far hands down the best pizza I've ever had. They said it's a blend of sweetbread & pizza dough. They tried many various combinations to arrive at the one they use now. Wow they nailed it! Delish!!!“

“Always good and fresh Good service“

“Normally I am lazy, and just walk 50m to Pizza Pizza, but as it was a gorgeous evening I decided to walk the extra 100m up to Little Caesar's.

It had been a while since I had a pie from the Emperor, but damn was it ever worth it today!

I ordered a custom large, stuffed crust, with all my favorite fixings.

Absolutely drooling at the thought of diving into my masterpiece, I popped open the box when I got home and was treated with probably one of the most magnificent sights - A perfectly cooked pizza with an abundance of toppings!

You guys nailed it today! Thank you. I will be back soon 😁👌“

“There is a new owner. His name is Kumal. And he is wonderful. We had an error with a large order for a party and the front desk worker said we could have 50% off. I was happy with that, but the owner called US back to insist he make it right and refund us. While speaking with the owner weeks later he stated that they had purchased a new oven because he had a few other complaints as well. That is a HUGE investment to ensure customer satisfaction. We order there almost weekly and we have been repeatedly impressed with their customer service and quality. Check them out and give them a try! You won’t regret it!“

“We ordered 8 extra large pizzas from Vito’s at the last minute. Tony was so kind in confirming the order and making sure it was ready right on time for our seniors. They absolutely loved the pizza and finished all 8 boxes with not a crumb left. Highly highly recommend.“

“I'm very confused by all of the negative comments about this location. We have been ordering from here for about 7 years and have never received a bad order. Always fresh and delicious food. I ordered an xl with double cheese and pepperoni once and the driver came with 2 xl pizzas explaining that they forgot the extra cheese on the first one, made another correctly and sent both at no extra charge. Always polite and great customer service from staff at the store and the drivers.“

“Booked 5 pizza's using the on-line portal. Timing to pickup was offered at 1:47pm, but I changed it to 2:00pm. Once I arrived the person at the counter was upset we did not give more notice for a order that size. Why offer the times if the store gets frustrated to the point of embarrassing the customer in front of everyone?“

“The service and general atmosphere has not changed in the years of experience going from one New Orleans pizza place to another. However the one thing that I would like to note is the flavour seemed to have changed. The pepperoni was the one thing that was really noticeable in different taste.“

“best pizza I've ever had in my life“

“The best panzerotti‘s in town“

“Fantastic! Pizza was cooked to perfection. Now, my go-to spot to order pizza. Delicious from the dough to the sauce and cheese and toppings. Not only that, but it is an inviting, clean atmosphere that greets you like a warm hug. Excellent customer service on top of that! The manager is kind and insanely friendly. Most definitely will be a regular here. If I could offer you one piece of advice it would be to go to Twice The Deal Pizza and give it a try! 100% would recommend“

“Great food options for the whole family. Crazy bread was excellent, pizza was good, and the drinks were cold. Overall a good experience that I have gone back to multiple times since first trying it! Only problem I found was the atmosphere as there was literally no seating in the entire restaurant. Other than that I had a great time!“

“Had a wonderful curry lunch on the sunny patio! Particularly impressed that they use real plates and cutlery for dine in customers.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I had a small mix-up with my order at Papa John’s, but Kessabi handled it quickly and professionally! Mistakes happen, but what really stood out was how kind and efficient the staff were in making it right. The corrected order was fresh, hot, and delicious — exactly what I was craving. Really appreciated the great customer service and how smoothly everything was resolved. I’ll definitely keep ordering from this location! 🍕👏“