19 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tavistock

“Im not sure why I am only reviewing Titos Tavistock now.. it is consistently fantastic. Quality, pricing, and service are A+. Their wings are large and perfectly fried! Their pizza crust is delicious. We are very lucky to have such a great pizza place in our small town.“

“Wonderful location. They make a great pizza, it’s always on time and reasonably priced. But I would say that the amazing staff here is what keeps me coming back. Everyone here is so kind, friendly and create such a great vibe even with the shortest interaction. I would highly recommend NOP in Tavistock.“

“We placed a large pick up order for a family gathering at the end of August 2025. The pizzas were done right, at the right time. The staff was friendly, and acknowledged the milestone birthday we were celebrating. Customer service A+, Food Quality A+, Value for Cost A+. We highly recommend their restaurant, and we will be back again! Thank you!“

“Best pizza in town

Not gonna lie… I don’t post about food like this often.

Tried Pizza Arca in New Hamburg for the first time today and I liked it so much I couldn’t stop myself from sharing it here.

I’m pretty picky with pizza, so this says a lot. Always good to support a local spot that’s actually doing it right 🍕

First time trying Pizza Arca in New Hamburg today.“

“We were in town from Toronto to see shows and stopped in to get a pizza. It was excellent. The toppings were fresh, tasty, well distributed and there was lots of them. Glad we stopped!“

“Had Papa Johns from Stratford tonight. Excellent pizza. Very tasty. Lots of toppings. Manager is very friendly and efficient. The gluten free pizza was excellent with lots of toppings. Would 100% recommend this Papa Johns.“

“Placed an order for pickup through the app for the triple treat box and it did not disappoint! The order was correct and ready upon the requested pickup time. 2 medium pizzas, chicken bites, bread sticks, a giant chippits cookie and two dipping sauces for less than $45.00? Send me!“

“I had just about given up on take out pizza, but had a craving and thought I would try Dominos. I was so happy with the flavourful pizza with a great crust and good amount of toppings. I liked that free herbs were added for that extra flavour boost!“

“Try almost every one. Never dissatisfied great quality and flavours.“

“great place, great people amazing food“

“Harv and his team make the most amazing pizza 🍕! Fast and friendly service always!! 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“For a small town with so many pizza places, Ajit's New Orleans Pizza, has always been my family's go to. The store is always clean, pick up or delivery is available. I recently ordered in advance for my daughter's birthday party and it was a success. Ajit and his team of pizza makers are always accommodating for dietary restrictions and/or special requests . Thank you for continuing to provide amazing pizza for our community and my fam jam. We appreciate you!“

“Picked up a Large 4 topping 15.00. Have not had pizza this good in a long time.“

“I am giving Five stars to Pizza Hut in Stratford because you've got the best pizza delivery driver named Dave. He was polite, fast, and friendly. He even delivered pizza in horrible freezing rain and snow, risking his life as he was jumping over snow banks and slipping on ice. Dave deserves praise and maybe even a raise. Oh and your pizza is amazing too. Great job on your pizzas too“

“I signed my kids up for the birthday Kids Club! They receive a free slice of cheese or pepperoni pizza and a can of pop! The best part is the birthday coupon is good until the end of the year!\nThe kids enjoyed their free pizza and pop and sevice was good! \nRestaurant was clean and nice and cool on a hot summer day!“

“Visited Papa John’s around 11:15 PM today, and I was genuinely impressed by the customer service. The staff were extremely friendly, welcoming, and professional even late at night. They made the whole experience amazing.

The pizza was also fresh, delicious, and perfectly made. You can really tell the team cares about both the food and the customers.

One of the best customer service experiences I’ve had recently. Keep up the great work!
Thank you.“

“Tito’s pizza always comes in clutch! Since high school all the way through the hard Covid times! Tonight I tried to call new O’s in Mitchell and they close super early! Which sucks when you get hungry at 8:30… So I thought I’d take a chance on my ole high school favourite, and my gawwd did my heart ever melt when they told me they would deliver to Mitchell! Ahmed was sooo nice and made me feel like every pizza in the world was inspired by me! He gave me the best deal he could and made sure he had everything I wanted! (My passion for food is a solid 12/10) and most importantly.. he’s going to make my pizza with love!! Thanks for making my night Tito’s, the pizza was delicious as always!!“

“AMAZING Pizza and the GF crust is really good too, highly recommend! If you haven’t already, get the homemade chili, SO good!!! Always homemade and delicious !😋 😋😋😋😋😋“

“I’m from out of town (big city) and I haven’t ever had pizza with meat balls in them, and the cup pepperoni is also seldom seen, so when I saw New Orleans had these ingredients I just had to try. The pizza was great, we ordered for a late night meal and we snarfed it all down fairly quickly. The wings were great too. Meaty, nicely fried, and plenty of sauce on the side even for a small order. The pizza crusts were small and crispy making them great to eat, my kids usually throw away the crusts but not this time.“