14 Best Pizza Restaurants in St. Thomas

“We tried this pizza place for the first time last week, after recently moving to the area. It was by far the best pizza we have had! It absolutely trumps any chain pizza joint and will be our place when we are craving pizza. Thank you very much to the staff and we look forward to another delicious pizza!!!“

“Amazing pizza! Definitely recommend this place, great service too!! If you haven’t tried this yet, you definitely should !!!“

“Domino is a good experience when your hungry for something rib stickin. We needed pasta not pizza and their Pasta Alfredo is filling and delicious. It doesn't look like much on the outside. However, when you step in you see a major assembly line of culinary greatness. The atpmosphere is HUNGRY! The smell will make your stomach grumble with eager anticipation of the first mouth watering bit. Chunks of chicken in a perfectly soft pasta..not soggy at all( see photo/video). Try Domino's and call to see if they have a deal night. You won't know unless you go. Domino's Wellington Rd St Thomas. Luv Malcom???Stay strong St Thomas.“

“I picked up a pizza from Domino’s yesterday and it’s the best pizza I’ve had there in years. I feel it had a little more sauce and more toppings than ever before. My pizza order was ham, pineapple, mushrooms, and onions. It was soooo Good. I could eat this every day. I hope I get the same experience next time. Over the last years, I always found Domino’s Pizza to be very bland but not this time. Please keep up this quality. I am sure it will improve your business immensely. Your prices are also the best in town.
I just have to add that. I just ordered the same pizza today, September. Fifth and Jordan made my pizza both times and it was excellent again. Keep up the good work, man.
Maybe the manager should think about giving this young man a raise he’s good for business.“

“All-around great food and great people! 5⭐️“

“small but perfect place. pizzas made fresh as long as there is dough. can buy frozen to take home or order well ahead and get a hot one. oven is wood fired for high heat and quick cooking. excellent service - actually it was better than excellent.“

“Went in to get a large Canadian, was greeted nicely and overall staff are very nice. The pizza itself is amazing, always has been. The only thing you'll have to keep in mind if ordering in store and not in advance for pickup is it does take a long time if they're busy. Now, everyone there is nice about it, they apologize and do their best, but when they have a bunch of Skip/delivery orders and orders coming in in advance, your best bet is to also order in advance for takeout, which I will definitely do next time.

Overall, great people, great food, long wait time if you don't prep ahead on a busy day and just walk in.“

“Very friendly and great food and pizza“

“What an awesome experience at red swan st thomas. The store was super busy and still delivering the best results. Hands down to the best place in st.thomas.
I tried paneer tikka pizza. If you're vegetarian than you should try this...
I would given 6 stars if i had an opinion.“

“All-around great food and great people! 5⭐️“

“I pre-ordered my heart shape pizzas for 5pm delivery. They delivered my food right on time. My pizzas were hot. My delivery driver went above and beyond to meet my needs! The pizza was delicious and made very well.Only regret, I wish I got the delivery guy’s name because he was so very kind.I will be a return customer!“

“These guys have new menu items that are mouth watering good. Very much a family place with gluten free options.

Vegetarian options: I’m not a vegetarian however the menu specifies only vegetarian options for those who want it, also gluten free

Parking: No way you can’t find parking spot

Kid-friendliness: Kid sits, colouring books, crayons

Wheelchair accessibility: Easily accessible for wheel chairs“

“Mickey's Pizza has a great thin crust, lots of fresh toppings and lots of flavor. I recommend give it a try!!“