22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Stayner

“Best pizza if only I lived closer, will definitely be making the trip to Creemore Pizza Co more often. Thin crust style, amazing sauce, loads of toppings and variety, non oily, and Lori is just the best 🤗. Amazing creations cheese burger pizza, poutine pizza and the list goes on its sure to satisfy many! Skullzones so unique too YUM“

“Best Pizza Hut by far. The food is always fresh, hot, fast and delicious. The staff also make this location outstanding- they are always so welcoming and friendly. The Pizza Hut model for customer service should start here with these folks.“

“Pizza took a while to come out of the kitchen and the host made it right in a big way. Worth the wait! Beet and carrot slaw was excellent. Pizza was one of the best I have had anywhere in the world.“

“A great little pizza place. Located with a great little brewery. Staff was amazing!! Pizza was probably one of the best we have ever had. Good variety. Pizza by slice available. Highly recommend it.“

“So far the Pixxas from here have been AWESOME…Probably 4 or 5 Times ???“

“the inside is lovely, they have a pac man machine (not sure if you can play the game on it) and lots of vintage decor on the walls. I got the donair, it was a little dry but very filing. I would love to go back and try their pizza and wings, which I’ve heard many good reviews of.“

“Awesome job don we love the panzarotti 's thanks again brother have a good night“

“Best pizza if only I lived closer, will definitely be making the trip to Creemore Pizza Co more often. Thin crust style, amazing sauce, loads of toppings and variety, non oily, and Lori is just the best 🤗. Amazing creations cheese burger pizza, poutine pizza and the list goes on its sure to satisfy many! Skullzones so unique too YUM“

“Big thank you to Boston Pizza Wasaga beach today, for taking our 30+ walk-in group when another local restaurant pushed our reservation back by an hour. They worked with us even with another hockey team there to get us in and just over an hour and a half. Much appreciated from the Clearview Canucks U9MD team!“

“Always hot and delicious... dominos is our place to go for pizza.“

“No real problem just some guy I’m assuming was the manager or owner.
Standing around in the main lobby walks in and out of the kitchen but doesn’t say anything or even truly make eye contact like he’s above the general public“

“I loved the seating area. It did not feel like a pizza place at all. My friend and I ordered a small pizza each and were both amazed by how much toppings were on the pizzas. I had to take mine back to the resort because I couldn't eat it all. Unusual for me.“

“Went in for a slice at lunch, I had an amazing spinach & Goat cheese slice.'Priced very well, and the slice was huge! 10/10 recommend for a quick bite to eat!“

“THIS IS NOT PEPI'S!!!!!!!!!!!

I give it 5* because it is MOUNTAIN SHORES PIZZA
Pepi's was the pizza I bought in 2004 as a highschool student for $2.25 for double slice and a pop....

It was 3* at best but would get 5 for nostalgia.

This location is Mountain Shores and it's one of the best pizza's you will ever have.

Please respect Donnie and acknowledge it for what it is. Donnie did a wonderful job making excellent pizza & better yet, being a wonderful member of the Collingwood community.

This is Mountain Shores Pizza.

One more time so you don't forget...

MOUNTAIN SHORES PIZZA. And it's phenomenal“

“Every time i’ve come here or ordered delivery the staff have been so kind and friendly, answering questions kindly and happily. They’re always quick as well, not long waits for food. Pizza is absolutely DELICIOUS, definitely my family’s top choice for pizza dinners, highly recommend!!!“

“I ordered a pizza approximately 3:15pm 13 March 2021. I have no complaints on the pizza. But I have an issue with the service by the young lady. The young lady brought my order out to my car. I gave a tip and been tipping more generous during the pandemic to give back to community. Because I haven't been affected financially during COVID-19 that I am blessed for. I asked for napkins she said "Sorry we don't have any". I thought that was weird and we had little picnic and spilt some food on myself. I decide to go back to the store and guess what. I see napkins to the right of the cash register when i walked into the store. The young lady said oh they just arrived/came in from back room what ever she muttered excuses and said sorry. I would rather she said "I am was lazy or sir go in the store get it yourself" at the time she brought pizza out. I would have more respect for someone to tell me the truth instead of lying. Now talking about loyalty, integrity and ethical. Question I wounder if she split the tip with the other two young men working at the same time. (During phone order she said you can't add tip on VISA, I find that odd). Can't turn back time but hopefully the young lady reads this or management/store owner. She needs to owns up to fault/s not to me but her team. How her one action saying "we don't have napkins" affected the other two young men working when I addressed the issue and including another customer waiting in line. I am generous person however I will call out people's BS and you "young lady" I called yours today. You were lazy regards with napkins and remember I tipped you for it. You knew you had napkins in the store. You owe an apology to your co workers, management and store owner. Lesson learn hopefully young lady one person negative actions can affect others one your team. Result the one young gentleman took my phone number and offer Med pizza next time. Very nice offer thank you.“

“Went to little Caesars in wasaga beach on June 20th 2025
The best pizza I ever have very fresh taste awesome even when you eat it cold for a snack later on still fresh I will defiantly will be back to little Caesars in wasagbeach
The best pizza place in wasagabeach every one should try it the staff are friendly very nice to customers you don't wait to long good prices
good location over all awsom place
Thank you littela Caesars in wasagbeach
Brenda“

“Way better than most Little Caesars locations. This restaurant exceeded my expectations for both customer service and food quality. The staff were friendly, the food was fresh, and the overall experience was excellent. They’ve definitely raised the bar for what I expect from Little Caesars. Well done!“

“Come here for the homemade garlic dipping sauce! Easily in top 3 best ones I have ever had! Random find in a small town . Delicious pizza and amazing interaction with the guy. Pizza had lightly fluffy crust and fresh pepperoni. Will for sure stop in here again“

“The pizza was quite tasty, although it was a super big slice. It’s definitely not European or British portion, but it was delicious. Service from staff was good and overall I was happy with what I paid. I thought the slice of pizza was super cheap, only £2.“

“We love Toppers! Only reason for the 4* is because it is expensive and they don't offer sundried tomatoes! I know it seems silly but it's my fave pizza topping. I would actually give a 4.5 if I could because the fact you can add a medium sauce swirl on the pizza is INCREDIBLE! I hope they keep the garlic butter stuffed crust because WOW it is so good! There is actually a good amount of cheese, unlike other pizza places.“

“The pizza was as good as it gets for Pizza Pizza and the walk in special for an extra large pepperoni is only $13.99. You can't beat that. The place was clean, the service was friendly, I watched them prepare the Pizza, place it in the oven and take it out. All professional and proper. It's not the World's Best Pizza but it's pretty dam tasty for take out at a very low price.“