40 Best Pizza Restaurants in Barrie

“azaming original pizza with beautiful new and convenient location. highly recommended“

“Just tried my first Jimmy Chews pizza; it won't be my last! It was yummy. :)“

“Normally the pizza is good with lots of toppings, this order was a slight disappointment. There was very little toppings and no extra cheese as we ordered. We were quite surprised as the last couple orders were very good.

Vegetarian options: Looking For a consistent topping coverage“

“TLDR: The pizza and boneless bites are great, and they deliver with care.

These guys have been good to us ever since we started ordering pizza from them. They have made mistakes regarding our orders, but they made up for them promptly (it usually helps to be polite to them first) and brought us correct food. Recently, there was an ice storm and power was out all over our region, but Pizza Hut was still open (unfortunately no delivery, but that made sense at the time). There's only one table and two chairs inside so I wouldn't recommend dining in. I waited longer than I would have liked, but (and I reiterate) it couldn't be helped because of the natural disaster, and other customers were so self-entitled and seem to have forgotten that while waiting. I eventually got my pizza, chicken and a salad, and my wife and I could eat during a time where there was no power. Thank you everyone who worked those days, and know that we appreciate you.“

“Prices are up everywhere and portions smaller but Dominos with coupons is keeping it minimal hurt on regular people. Love the revamped sauce and regular hand tossed is perfect amount of dough. Toppings never undercooked nor too crispy unlike many other za joints. There is now free oregano, crushed spicy peppers, garlic to add which together are amazing. pic is with my absolute fav brooklyn pep (this is what double brooklyn pep looks like)“

“Fantastic Pizza!“

“Great experience at Pizza Hut! The pizza was hot, fresh, and full of flavor. The service was friendly, and the atmosphere was welcoming. Highly recommend for anyone craving delicious pizza and quick, reliable service. Will definitely return!“

“I had a really long week and was so excited to have an easy night and order pizza! My pizza was missing one topping that I ordered which is why I give 4 stars not 5 but I hardly mind because the service I received was so exceptional. I picked up my pizza around 7:30pm on a Friday and it was busy-the staff was smiling, kind and genuine. The staff member who helped me seemed to honestly be enjoying themselves as they worked which is so rare. It was very refreshing and actually turned my mood around after a very long tough week. Thank you!
Even missing one topping my pizza was INCREDIBLE! With how busy they were I don’t blame them for missing one silly topping.

Thank you to the staff at this location, I hope they are rewarded for their exceptional service“

“Great for a quick, affordable bite! The crust is crispy, toppings are fresh, and there are plenty of options, including gluten-free and plant-based. Delivery is usually fast, but quality can be inconsistent across locations. Cheese could be a bit better, and dips are pricey for the size. Overall, a solid choice for casual pizza lovers! 🍕“

“Once in a while my wife and I will stop in here for a quick pizza. It's always good and fresh. Yesterday for the first time we ordered for pickup. Pizza was good but the honey garlic wings I ordered were not honey garlic. They were plain with two packs of ranch dressing on the side. Confused as to what the ranch dressing was for leaving the store, I soon figured it out when I got home. If this had been my first visit they would have received two stars only salvaged because the pizza was reasonable. Lesson to me: Eat in here only. Lesson to this dominos location: learn how to make wings!“

“The Meadow Lake pizza hut is awesome and the stuffed crust 5☆“

“We always order from the Letitia Dominoes and without a doubt, it's always great. There was a slight mix-up last night and the store immediately fixed it and made the outcome better than anyone should have expected. Management and staff went far beyond the norm. This is quality service, and pride in their store, their customers, and product. There's no need to go to any where else for great pizza.“

“Amazing food! Great waitress“

“Was up late coding and came to take a break with a slice of pizza before starting up an Google Ad Campaign for clients.
WOW what a great pizza spot! I’ll be back for sure, had no idea of this hidden gem I see why they’ve got so many reviews this place is great!“

“I've been a Domino's pizza eater for longer than I remember, but a friend suggested I try Papa John's and now I've been converted. The owner was helpful and friendly and the pizza was amazing!“

“Best pizza in the downtown core“

“We had a great first time dining experience at Pie! The wings were delicious! They aren’t deep fried but rather smoked and cooked in the pizza oven. Yummy honey coating 😋 The mac and cheese was creamy and garlicky…perfect comfort food 🥰 Katherine, our lovely server, was a genuine gem and was personable and attentive our whole visit. We sat outside on the patio, overlooking the active waterfront 🏖️, enjoying the summer vibe. Fantastic overall! Highly recommended.“

“Pizza Pizza Downtown Barrie did an awesome job today. Their tandoori chicken pizza was outstanding. Generous toppings, perfect cheese pull and drizzled with BBQ sauce. I am impressed. The staff is so nice and decent. Their delivery staff was heading out with bags but made way for us first. Every single employee treated us with respect and kindness. They are well mannered and trained professionals. I am definitely coming back to them! My go-to for any kind of pizzas from now“

“Absolutely the best pizza in Barrie. Have been going to Papa Joes since 2007 (st. Vincent location). Love their pizza“

“1st time ordering from Cocelli - had food delivered - fast and courteous service, and food was outstanding - will definitely be ordering from here again“

“Being on vacation and staying at a local hotel, I had to walk in to order and pick up our pizza. I found this out the last time I tried to order from the hotel. We ordered a large 12 slice with pepperoni, fresh mushrooms and green olives. The pizza was very tasty. The sauce was very traditional and was not bitter or acidity. Fresh mushrooms is a plus as some pizza places use canned. It makes a big difference to the flavor.“

“Best in town, competitive prices if not better, and very friendly. Great job guys!“

“Always good pizza from here..it never disappoints. We ordered two large one just double cheese the other with mushrooms red onion with bbq sauce..yummy it was so good. They always use fresh ingredients and are very generous with the toppings. This is our go to pizza joint for our pizza delivery!“

“Love ❤️ the pizza and the crust“

“My son and I have been going to this restaurant for 10 years now. The staff are absolutely amazing. My son has Autism, and they treat him like a family member. I cannot say enough good things about this restaurant.“

“I recently tried the pizza and was really impressed! The crust was perfectly baked—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The sauce had great flavor, and the toppings were fresh and generously portioned. I especially liked the balance of cheese and seasoning. Overall, it was delicious and definitely worth ordering again.“

“My wife and I ordered from Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta last weekend for the first time , and we were blown away by how tasty everything was. The selection of food was amazing, the prices were very good, and our order was prepared very quickly. We will definitely be ordering from Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta again! Thank you Papa Rez and your entire team! - Tatyana and Keith“

“Great pizza! My new favourite! A must try.“

“This pizza was the best I have had in barrie by far good price i paid like $16 for large 3 toppings i would kiss the chefs hands....I love this new joint my go to for pizza also the service is amazing and staff is super friendly. I will next time try their burger with bacon ? ?“

“I've eaten a lot of quality, delicious pizza, so it's awesome that Little Caesar's is both super affordable AND incredibly delicious. It's definitely a favourite of mine. Their quick-pickup pizzas are always hot and fresh, and their stuffed pretzel crust pizza is AMAZING!! My whole family loved it. I'm trying to pace myself, but I can't wait to eat it again. Also, the staff is always kind, friendly, and so efficient. It's truly outstanding how quickly the staff works while maintaining positive and kind attitudes towards all customers. I've always had great experiences here for over three years now.“

“I had a wonderful experience at Pizza Hut recently. The pizza was absolutely delicious, with a perfect blend of flavors that left me wanting more. What truly stood out, however, was the exceptional customer service. The staff were attentive, friendly, and made sure that every aspect of my visit was enjoyable. It was a delightful dining experience that I will remember fondly.“

“Wife and I really had a great time! Definitely would to back to the restaurant! 5/5 for us for sure!“

“This place, ESPECIALLY, have their pizza the same taste and shape for the past 3 years... we tried other places but everytime they do it differently...BUT this place makes the BEST THIN CRUST PIZZA with light sauce.. please stay the same and don't change.. the whole family and the whole nieces and nephews LOVE YOUR pizza..“

“Always fresh, always clean, always friendly and always the way you want it!“

“I opted for takeout from Papa John's, and I am very happier with my experience. The staff was friendly and efficient, ensuring that my order was ready exactly on time. When I got home and opened the box, I was greeted with a mouthwatering sight. The pizza was still piping hot, with gooey cheese and perfectly cooked toppings. The crust had a delightful crunch, and the flavors were spot on. Papa John's definitely knows how to deliver quality even with takeout orders. I'll be coming back for more!“

“Love you guys!!! Great quality and made with love...“

“Just tried ordering a party size pizza for the first time because it was kind of cheap and didn't expect the quality to be that great but it turned out to be one of the best pizzas that I have ever had in my life super amazing pizzas you should give it a try.“

“Just had a burger and fries to support the fundraiser for a local family It was hands down one of the best burgers I’ve had in a long time“

“Food was great. BOGO Wednesdays.
We did wait about 10-15min for someone to take our initial drink order.

Once they realized what happened, our server Jake did a fantastic job. Acknowledged the issue and made us feel very welcome and attended to.“