33 Best Pizza Restaurants in Barrie

“This place is the best pizza in all of Barrie. I’m always shocked it’s not more busy. They have handmade desserts and everything is incredible. It’s family owned and you can literally taste in the food how much they care. If you haven’t tried this place yet - do it!“

“excellent quality and very tasty“

“You will never find another pizza place that offers a massive XL with 1 topping for 11 dollars after tax at the door.

The pizza is decent enough.

Best bang for your buck if you don't care all that much for finding the most authentic pizza experience.“

“The Mapleview store in Barrie , ON always great food and quick friendly service

We have been a reg customer for years !

Never have we had a pizza that wasn’t gobbled up quick by our family !

Keep up the great work !“

“The ambiance was cozy and perfect for a casual meal with friends or family. The service was quick, and our food arrived hot and fresh. Overall, Pizza Hut exceeded my expectations with its tasty food, excellent service, and comfortable atmosphere. I highly recommend it for anyone craving a satisfying pizza experience!“

“Stopped by to get some eats after our Restoulle camping trip. Our cashier, Athira , was very polite and welcoming, ordering was very straightforward and simple. My only concern is that there are only 3 chairs and we came in a group of 5 all crammed inside a car. It would definitely be nice to have some extra seating arrangements, however it was very clean to say the most. Food was prepared very fast and fresh. If i lived here, I would come back again. Also free dip if you leave a review, so nothing wrong with some freebies.

Parking: Many parking spots in front of the restaurant itself. There are also Disability parking locations open close by.“

“best pizza in town. I use to drive from north end of tiny,(awenda park) to get pizza from here, now drive from Collingwood ! best around. never disappointed!“

“I had the pleasure of dining at Ameera Pizza and Cafe today with two friends, and I must say it was an exceptional experience. The pizza was delicious, with a perfect blend of flavors and a crispy crust that was simply irresistible.
What truly made the visit special was the outstanding service we received. Susmita greeted us with a warm smile and was incredibly attentive throughout our meal. Her friendly demeanor and excellent customer service made us feel right at home.

Thank you, Susmita, for making our dining experience so enjoyable. We will definitely be returning soon!“

“I've been a Domino's pizza eater for longer than I remember, but a friend suggested I try Papa John's and now I've been converted. The owner was helpful and friendly and the pizza was amazing!“

“Great pizza! My new favourite! A must try.“

“Best in town, competitive prices if not better, and very friendly. Great job guys!“

“My wife and I ordered from Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta last weekend for the first time , and we were blown away by how tasty everything was. The selection of food was amazing, the prices were very good, and our order was prepared very quickly. We will definitely be ordering from Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta again! Thank you Papa Rez and your entire team! - Tatyana and Keith“

“I recently ordered a pizza from this restaurant for a small gathering with friends, and it was a hit! The pizza arrived piping hot and smelling absolutely delicious. The crust was thin and crispy, just the way I like it, and the cheese was perfectly melted and gooey. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and there was a generous amount of them on each slice. I particularly enjoyed the blend of flavors from the Italian sausage, onions, and roasted red peppers. The service was prompt and the pizza was still hot when I picked up. Overall, a fantastic pizza experience that I would highly recommend to any pizza lover. I will definitely be ordering from this place again in the future!“

“Quick service, friendly wait staff and great food!! Big portions.“

“My son and I have been going to this restaurant for 10 years now. The staff are absolutely amazing. My son has Autism, and they treat him like a family member. I cannot say enough good things about this restaurant.“

“Amazing food! Great waitress“

“Absolutely the best pizza in Barrie. Have been going to Papa Joes since 2007 (st. Vincent location). Love their pizza“

“This pizza was the best I have had in barrie by far good price i paid like $16 for large 3 toppings i would kiss the chefs hands....I love this new joint my go to for pizza also the service is amazing and staff is super friendly. I will next time try their burger with bacon ? ?“

“We always order from the Letitia Dominoes and without a doubt, it's always great. There was a slight mix-up last night and the store immediately fixed it and made the outcome better than anyone should have expected. Management and staff went far beyond the norm. This is quality service, and pride in their store, their customers, and product. There's no need to go to any where else for great pizza.“

“We have been ordering from Pizzaville for several years now, they have successfully become our current go-to for pizza (we order from Pizzaville 2-3 times a month). The food is always fresh, hot and delivered promptly. Our favourites are their deep fried panzerotti and spicy loaded baked potato pizza (with extra sauce). Be sure to order the creamy garlic ranch sauce as well, it's awesome for dipping!

Dietary restrictions: They offer a medium gluten-free crust which we have ordered on several occasions. Although they cannot guarantee no cross-contamination, I believe that they are quite careful as we have never had an issue.“

“I have visited the place multiple times now. The pizza is amazing in taste, smells enticing and looks are 10 on 10. I have tried almost all the pizzas they have and never had any complaints.

Vegetarian options: There are a couple of vegetarian options that you can choose from. Personally, I like the Indian Style Pizza.“

“I visited this Domino's Pizza branch and had a great experience overall. The pizza was delicious, and the sitting area was clean and comfortable. However, the washroom could use some attention as it wasn't very clean. Otherwise, it was a positive experience.“

“I must say that I ordered for an XL 4 topping pizza, that was so utterly delicious and mouthwatering. The pizza was perfectly well done and was at its best temperature. Kaushal and it's team really served me my taste at its best peak, really thankfull to the team for this taste. Additionally
The staff had his uniform completely neat and tidy, they were very polite and very interactive with giving suggestions for the dips as per our pizza ordered. Made the pizza as if making for his own. Really thankful to the kushal and his team

Vegetarian options: People who are looking for vegetarian options must try this place, as particularly this outlet staff is very polite, Friendly and gives really good suggestions“

“I love going to Pizza Hut, especially on weekends and special occasions. They always have great deals, and the pizza is delicious. The staff are super kind and welcoming, which makes the experience even better. Whether I eat there or take it home, I always have a great time.“

“I had a wonderful experience at Pizza Hut recently. The pizza was absolutely delicious, with a perfect blend of flavors that left me wanting more. What truly stood out, however, was the exceptional customer service. The staff were attentive, friendly, and made sure that every aspect of my visit was enjoyable. It was a delightful dining experience that I will remember fondly.“

“Love you guys!!! Great quality and made with love...“

“Recieved a gift card from a coworker. Went in on a Friday and as I walked in I could smell the fresh tomato sauce and basil. I chose to get a panzerotti and meatball sandwich. The meatball sandwich was delicious and oozing sauce. Mozzarella was gooey and fresh. 8.1/10. Panzo was a bit underwhelming. Toppings inside were a bit light and pepperoni, as it wasn't baked and crispy was more like baloney flavored. The star of the show is their marinara sauce which I believe you can purchase. Overall a great experience.“

“It's not the best pizza but it's good, and the hot and ready option is great. I do love the crazy bread!

Vegetarian options: I ordered a cheese pizza but received pepperoni which wasn't great since I was feeding vegetarians, they did exchange the pizza which was great but I did have to make an additional trip. I would advise to check your order prior to leaving.“

“This place, ESPECIALLY, have their pizza the same taste and shape for the past 3 years... we tried other places but everytime they do it differently...BUT this place makes the BEST THIN CRUST PIZZA with light sauce.. please stay the same and don't change.. the whole family and the whole nieces and nephews LOVE YOUR pizza..“

“I opted for takeout from Papa John's, and I am very happier with my experience. The staff was friendly and efficient, ensuring that my order was ready exactly on time. When I got home and opened the box, I was greeted with a mouthwatering sight. The pizza was still piping hot, with gooey cheese and perfectly cooked toppings. The crust had a delightful crunch, and the flavors were spot on. Papa John's definitely knows how to deliver quality even with takeout orders. I'll be coming back for more!“

“I recently visited this pizza pizza, and I have to say, it was an exceptional experience! Vishal, who took our order, was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable. His recommendations were spot on, and the pizza he suggested was absolutely delicious. The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh, and the flavors were well-balanced. The atmosphere was welcoming, and the service was quick and efficient. I highly recommend this place to anyone who loves great pizza and outstanding service. I’ll definitely be returning!“

“Wife and I really had a great time! Definitely would to back to the restaurant! 5/5 for us for sure!“