14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Orillia

“They have the best pizza that I have ever had. They are great people as well. All of their other foods are fantastic too!!!“

“There was a short woman that works there, she answered my phone call and she was the most efficient and asking the right questions to get my order correct quickly and effectively. I ordered a Hawaiian pizza and some wings. She was amazing. She was stern didn’t really have a smile in her face, but who cares she delivered exceptional service I’ll definitely come back here again.“

“5 STARS PLUS ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️+ The BEST dining out experience in a VERY LONG time !!! Our waiter Mike was incredible 🥰 The service and food was exceptional and before we left we made another reservation. My husband and I are Italian and the food has such deep flavour all made to perfection, everything from the start to the very end (appetizers to dessert) was the BEST ! We both left there so extremely satisfied… experience it yourself - you will NOT be disappointed. It’s our favourite restaurant now, hands down beats any other restaurant in Orillia. Worth every dollar spent there. Can’t wait to go there again ❤️“

“Great night! I know you may not normally think to order a salad at a pizza place, but the Chicken Pecan Salad here is AMAZING—so good I am writing a review:) From the friendly service to the quality of the food, everything made for a great night. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Kate G was our server, and she was exceptional. Being someone that has served at an east sides myself in the past, and still serve in a different establishment today I can say from both sides of the fence that Kate was amazing. Fast, attentive, attention to detail, kind, and very informative. It was so nice to go out and get great service, especially as it was a holiday. Thank you for the experience. Great overall experience:)“

“Have had this pizza lots but over broken times I ordered and it was okay not grate.. I had a friend Spencer do a delivery order and intudce a new type to try it wasn't so bad it was good crust and toppings.. wish gluten-free had been a option for the size ...

I did a walk in order one day it wasn't really thrilling not a lot of interaction 😕“

“Theos has got to be one of my favourite restaurants! Tonight myself and 9 other family members dined in and had such a wonderful time! The food was fantastic, and our server Ally was phenomenal! Probably one of the best servers I’ve ever had! Wonderful personality and great sense of humour! We will definitely return soon, and will absolutely request for Ally’s service again! There’s a reason this place is always so busy!“

“Updated 2026:
A good-tasting pizza at a newly-inflated take-away price when on special. My current favourite Orillia pizza. Avoid the convenient pre-made pizza slices, as they are NOT as tasty once reheated by the staff.

You will find that regular priced or delivered items are much more expensive than in-store or app deals, so find the deals on offer before placing an order.

For example: a large, four ingredient pizza's carry out price was just $16.99 (May 2019) or less including tax. Change to a jumbo with the same ingredients and you'll pay double for a pie that is only a little larger. Note that in 2026 the prices have become MUCH higher.

Very friendly, family-owned location. They try really hard to please.“

“Wonderful pizza… crust was just right and toppings were awesome“

“I was up in Orillia today and thought why not try Pizza hut here. I must say I havent had it this good in decades. The ones in most other towns are hit and miss . They tend to be a white crust with no flavour. Todays reminded me of back in the day, when the dough was fluffy and it was a nice golden brown.“

“Hey Chris tell your mum the eggplant parmigiana was excellent. Thanks so much!“

“I was passing through the city and got an opportunity to visit this location for a quick pizza lunch and really amazed the way team was handling it another response with quick understanding of the order and delivery on time were really awesome I appreciate your effort and good wishes to your business.“

“Excellent pizza and service. the crust and dough under carriage is crispy. Doesn't taste raw like most places. Great job!! Great prices!!“

“Delivery staff are very friendly :)“