Italian Restaurants near The Blue Mountains

“We had a wonderful dinner at Magnone's. We ordered the Alfredo (Pappardelle), Carbonara, Polpette and Calamari.

- The Alfredo was amazing! Got only one word, perfect! 5 stars

- The Carbonara was also great - creamy and delicious. I'd say 4.5 stars

- The Polpette was good. There's three huge meat balls. They were tasty and nice, but I think there's something lacking in their sauce. 4 stars

- Lastly, the Calamari tossed with salt and chili flakes, and arugula. After a few bites, I was having different thoughts. I took a first bite, it was firm and chewy - awesome! But as I mix them to taste the whole flavor, I think it's just too salty and the chili flakes were strong it overpowered the taste of the calamari. The arugula couldn't balance the flavor - the saltiness was a let down. I'd give their Calamari a 3.

Overall, the dining experience was great! Service was fast, nice indoor and outdoor atmosphere. They have and upper level, but no accessibility push buttons, and not enough indoor space for baby strollers.“

“Just went to Firehall during a family vacation to Blue Mountain. I need to give my positive review - we had an exceptional experience from the ease with putting our names on the waitlist online, to the INCREDIBLE service we received from Jeff to the delicious food we all left with full tummies and smiles on our faces. In a day and age when it seems like customer service is declining it was refreshing to have such a fantastic experience. Thank your Jeff and the staff at Firehall!!!“

“We went to Meaford to see an ABBA tribute and were searching for a place to eat before the show. We stumbled upon this restaurant, and what an amazing experience it turned out to be. The hostess, Frannie, has some of the driest and funniest humour encountered anywhere, and she set the tone for the evening right from the start. The atmosphere was charming and quaint, creating a cozy backdrop for the meal. The food was delicious, with rich flavours that danced on the palate and delivered an authentic Italian taste.“