10 Best Italian Restaurants near Alliston

“We went to Rocco’s bar for a birthday party on Monday evening. It was absolutely fantastic. We were immediately welcomed by all the lovely people that worked there. Specifically Rose who made sure we had everything we needed. We played pool in their large back room, was given access to the speaker to play our own music and had many good priced beverages. Most notably the incredible food truly made with love. I had the chicken parm sandwich and French fries and it was seriously the best I’ve ever had. Generous portions, fair prices, terrific people and overall outstanding place. I’m going to be returning for Karaoke soon! Thanks Rose and family ❤️“

“Fantastic Italian cuisine, friendly staff, excellent atmosphere. Highly recommend. 👏👍“

“Aman at Pizza Hut Alliston provides excellent customer service. She is friendly, patient, and always makes sure orders are accurate. Her positive attitude and professionalism really stand out, and she helps create a welcoming experience every time. Great job, Aman—Pizza Hut is lucky to have you.“

“I recently tried pizza from this store and it was very good. The taste was amazing and the quality was excellent. They also maintain proper hygiene in the kitchen. I noticed two staff members wearing black gloves while preparing the pizza, which shows they care about cleanliness. The short and slightly fat guy makes awesome pizza. Highly recommended! 🍕👍“

“Sabrina Italian food is amazing definitely a 5 star.“

“After a frustrating attempt to make a reservation at another local restaurant that made everything feel unnecessarily complicated, walking into Poppi’s was like a breath of fresh air. From the moment we called, they welcomed our entire hockey team with open arms. No hassle. No stress. Just genuine kindness and an eagerness to help. And they didn’t just “fit us in” — they went above and beyond in a way that truly blew us away. They put together an absolutely incredible buffet that was both delicious and beautifully presented. There was something for everyone — a wide variety of savory dishes and an impressive selection of desserts that had the kids (and parents!) going back for seconds. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and thoughtfully prepared. But what truly made the experience unforgettable was the personal touch. When we arrived, they had printed a picture with our team’s name and mascot, framed it, and displayed it right on the buffet table for the kids to see. That small but incredibly meaningful gesture made our players feel special and celebrated. You could see the pride and excitement on their faces. The staff was warm, patient, and so pleasant to deal with from start to finish. Hosting a big group of energetic hockey players isn’t always easy, but they handled it effortlessly and with genuine smiles the entire time. And to top it all off, the price was completely reasonable — especially considering the quality of the food, the generous spread, and the outstanding service we received. Poppi’s didn’t just provide a meal — they created an experience. If you’re looking for a restaurant that truly cares about its guests and goes the extra mile, Poppi’s is the place. We can’t thank them enough and will absolutely be back!“

“My wife and I just had a lovely romantic dinner here, and overall it was a great experience. The atmosphere was absolutely incredible cozy, warm, and perfect for a date night. The food was very good as well. The pizza was the star of the show: perfectly cooked, great flavour, and definitely worth coming back for. The pasta was solid too, around a 7 or 8 out of 10. Service was friendly and attentive without being overbearing. A strong four stars we’ll definitely be back.“

“We recently ordered from Spitfire Pizza for my daughter’s birthday, and I can’t say enough good things about the experience.
They went above and beyond by opening early just to fulfill our order and even delivered it in time for the party — such a thoughtful and accommodating gesture.
Now, let’s talk about the pizza... absolutely incredible. I even convinced my gluten-free (by choice) husband to give it a try. Not only did he love it, but he said it was the best pizza he’s ever had, and it reminded him of his Nonna’s homemade pies. High praise! He’s already decided that from now on, he’ll be making the drive from Nobleton to Tottenham to pick up Spitfire for our future pizza nights.
A heartfelt thank you to Mary & Sarah for all your help with our order, and a special shoutout to Kelly at Rusty Jade Ranch for the amazing recommendation.“

“Amazing food, welcoming atmosphere. Truly authentic.“

“I decided not to cook so ordered pizza veggie one asked for extra dip... but they gave me the better option rather deal. Which is not common. Yet special , as all was done in 5 min. As I have to pick my kids soon too... so yes me thrilled all done fast and peacefully 🙏🏼“