27 Best Italian Restaurants near Innisfil

“I can't say enough good things about Nonna's Cuisine! The food was absolutely incredible—flavorful, fresh, and beautifully presented. The service was top-notch; she made me feel so welcome. And on top of all that, she’s just a fantastic person and entrepreneur—so passionate about her craft. I’ll definitely be coming back for more!“

“Great Selection. Always Fresh. Highly Recommend the Smoked trout! great addition to the 400 market!“

“Stopped in for espresso and gelato on a hot summers day hanging out at Friday Harbour. It was busy but the service was fast. Very limited seating inside, but the a/c inside was worth waiting for a table.
The gelato is amazing! Your can taste the quality of the product. Espresso very good too. Only comment is price-smallest cup of gelato=one small scoop. We think a bit high in price, but guess comparable to other gelato shops. Just wish we got more for our money. Still delicious though.“

“Fantastic food and even better service. Always consistent and attention to detail. Love Avenue and owner always involved and helps out“

“There’s a girl that works here, usually the register and fryer, she’s a DIVA!! She’s so friendly and outgoing and she’s very attentive and takes the time to make small conversation, come to this pizza pizza!!!“

“Good food and great service definitely will be back“

“Have heard about Napoli on various media pages for years…. Have wanted to try but never pulled the trigger…..until last night! Absolutely fantastic pizza! Crust was still a bit soft (good)….not too thin…perfectly done! Ordered the deluxe (my standard since I was a kid), the toppings were over the top! Sauce stood out as a key satisfier, the perfect balance of tang and herbs…. To top it all off the engagement from our delivery driver set the standard for what we were to experience. She was pleasant, engaging, and very personable. You know you’re going to pay a bit more because of their County location and delivery charge - and you may have to wait a little longer for delivery…….but the pizza is worth it!! 9.5 out of 10…..Napoli is now our Go To for pizza“

“On one visit we had pecan encrusted lamb chops, with a side of the best seasoned frites ever! May not be on the current menu, but I would recommend The North on the basis their creative presentation of their appetizers, entrees, desserts, and drinks, and the friendly servers. The atmosphere puts you at once at ease. We left the restaurant with the feeling that our experience was excellent and worth what we paid for our dining night out!“

“The finest people own this venue. Priced very reasonable and the food is delicious. Great family restaurant with a superb family that owns it.! Great Food...Yummy Ice Cream!“

“Amazing food! Great waitress“

“We had an amazing dinner . Pasta and meatballs the best . I remembered when I was in Reggio Calabria Italy , the pasta and meatballs they served same taste , it's great pasta and meatballs❤️. The staff and place amazing . That night I feel like I was in italy with my family . I highly recommend this place ( Barrie)“

“Friendly staff, amazing food!“

“Popped in this past Friday after seeing a review and we were not disappointed! The veal parmigiana is amazing! 2 pieces of veal alongside penne cooked just perfect and the sauce? Like I remember it as a child 🍝 This little gem is amazing must try! Can’t wait to go back!“

“What a great experience tonight! We had an earlier appointment downtown, so, an additional trip would have been required to pick up our pizza. Instead, we ordered and and asked for the pizza to not be fully cooked and OH MY... Once we reheated (on a pizza stone), it tasted exactly like the original! Will DEFINITELY do that again! Highly recommend! Thanks again, Pizzeria Italia Restaurant!“

“September 16 our party of 5 visited Bacio Trattoria for the first time. What a delight! The menu is authentic and elegant Italian. The service was attentive but not over bearing. We enjoyed a complimentary Lemoncello with the Chef/owner for the perfect end to a great evening and dinner. We'll be back!“

“Best pie around. They are the best.“

“Went for the first time today as we had heard about this place from our daughters. The arancini are super authentic, the best we have had outside home made ones by Sicilian relatives. The veal sandwich is fantastic, the meat is tender, the topics not overwhelming, the bread fresh. Highly recommend this place.“

“We had visited Friday for dinner and we were served by Ollie. He was absolutely amazing!! Super Friendly, knowledgeable and professional. Ollie made my family feel so special. Thank you for going above and beyond. We will definitely come back & hopefully to be served by you again !!“

“Best Italian sandwich in Barrie hands down. So good I'm already craving another!“

“love this place and we treated our daughter and her boyfriend for a birthday dinner .Janine our server is so amazing and attentive and even remembered our names! we all had a few laughs and of course the food was perfect. you can always count on Rick the chef to deliver and Janine for going out of her way to pamper us ! great time“

“I ordered the cheese pan pizza, and it was absolutely amazing! It was baked perfectly, with a delicious golden crust. The pizza was hot, fresh, and incredibly tasty yum! I really enjoyed every bite and will definitely be coming back. Thank you!“

“I’m in the mood and the nose rader has been on highl!!!!“

“One of the best pizza in barrie. If you wanna try indian style best pizza thats the place. I visited on Sunday at 11pm night with my fried order butter chicken pizza it was amazing. The taste was so good along with the crust. Honestly recommend this place to go and give it a must try.“

“1st time ordering from Cocelli - had food delivered - fast and courteous service, and food was outstanding - will definitely be ordering from here again“

“Pizza hut , my 3rd time. Free dip for QR scan and review (which i was gunna do anyway) right at the till (: leave a lil change in the cup , cuz these guys are friendly , and this bein my 3rd Hut Zaa, its consistantly perf each time (: <3 i love the HUT.“

“Had a great experience at Pizza Pizza.The pizza was fresh, delicious, and prepared quickly. A special thanks to Sandeep Kaur for the excellent customer service. She was friendly, polite, and made sure everything was perfect. Her positive attitude really made my visit enjoyable.“

“When did the customer service cease to exist here.. this used to be my spot.. i scheduled my order for a time guarantee for 7:30 and the guy at the store said no we dont offer time guantees yet there CS said your ordee is now free.. waited 40mins for a cold Pizza. I feel let down! Customer first at this place died for me.. not ordering from here ever again!“