19 Best Italian Restaurants in Richmond Hill

“Waitress was excellent and food was good but the Tuscan Rib Eye was not worth it. Meat was undercooked and tough to eat. Restaurant appears very busy nowadays resulting in food taking much longer to arrive. 2 hrs to finish when it used to take just over an hour.“

“Excellent service (Reza), exceptional food, lovely atmosphere. Soho martini - amazing!“

“A Hidden Gem for Fresh, Custom Flavors

If you’re looking for a personal touch, this is the place to be—the kitchen is happy to accommodate custom requests, though their daily specials are the real stars of the show. They are consistently delicious and offer incredible value for the price.

• Rose Sauce Fettuccine: We tried it with mushrooms and asparagus; it was rich, flavorful, and clearly made with fresh ingredients.
• Greek Salad: Fresh, crisp, and perfectly seasoned.
• Garlic Bread: The highlight of the sides—perfectly toasted to a golden crisp without being overdone.“

“The minute you walk in, you can smell the delicious aroma of homemade food. The staff were friendly and helpful with our choices. Will definitely be back!!!“

“Great service friendly people Thank you“

“it was a good experience.“

“It’s rare to come across someone who truly cares about the customer experience the way Ali does. His professionalism and positive attitude made my visit even more enjoyable. I’ll definitely be coming back — and I hope to be served by Ali again!
Highly recommend this place, especially if you get the chance to have Ali as your server.“

“We had a large party in the Newmarket location recently and the service and food were excellent! The owner and staff were extremely accommodating to our needs, including being patient with the many children in our group. The food was plentiful and delicious. We will 💯 be back!!“

“Due to the fabulous vegan menu, we go here at least once a year, especially on my birthday for a special celebration. My mom recently got me a gift card to the Richmond Hill location, the staff were so helpful and sweet with her, it made me love this location, even more.“

“The owner was so friendly when we walked in the door. He gave us lots of time to look ofer the extensive menu and gave us a great education lesson on his fancy pizza oven. The pizza was fast and delicious and the garlic dipping sauce I could eat on its own!“

“The pizza is good, I’ve even seen puffed up crusts with good browning. It’s definitely much better than other Pizza Pizzas I’ve been to, which makes this place an even better value.

It’s always been ready for pickup within 15-20 minutes, and we’ve only had 1 or 2 issues in the last decade.“

“My family and I found this delicious restaurant on Uber Eats. I am so picky and I don't like any of the chain pizzas. We ordered the party size meat lovers for 2 adults and 2 large boys. I had one piece (since sadly I wasn't feeling the best). I need to order it again so I can enjoy more pieces. Yummy, local, small business - great all around“

“The store is nicely and clean. Convenient location also. The staff are friendly and quick. Enough seating space is there to sit comfortably if you want to dine in.

The food is consistently good—not just the pizzas. Their wings, garlic bread, panzerottis, and sides are fresh and tasty.

The store remain open till late, after midnight which helps to satisfy late night cravings. Ample parking space is there in the plaza.“

“pizza kits! great idea and a wonderful way for the community to help a small business :)“

“This is a good operation.
Decent interior, clean, friendly staff.
I typically get this medium one topping walk-in special. Butter chicken sauce, bacon crumble. Outstanding deal and they always make it proper. Check out the photo… that’s a nice pie.
Hats off to you folks. Keep the quality up please.“

“This chain is based in the Vancouver area and has not too many locations in the GTA. Fresh Slice is underrated, and I love that their typical cheese slice is the creamy cheese with alfredo. It’s a nice break from having typical tomato sauce on any other pizza I have. Overall, very good experience yesterday for my lunch.“

“Pizza Pizza at Elgin Mills is easily the best one around. The pizza is always fresh, and made just right every single time. I actually travel past two other Pizza Pizza locations just to come to this one — that’s how much better the quality and service are here.“

“Used to hate Pizza Hut cause I thought it was trash based on old experiences. However, this one is right by my house and I saw a sign for $2 personal pizzas. Reluctantly gave it a shot, and it was fire. I guess it’s true as they say “you can’t out pizza the hut.”“

“Today, I ordered pizza from Pizza Pizza for my family, and it was absolutely amazing the best pizza I’ve ever had! Everyone in my family loved it. The customer service was also outstanding, especially from Sara, who was incredibly kind and helpful. Thank you for such a great experience“