26 Best Italian Restaurants in North York

“I ordered the wedding soup take out. $7.99 but the paper cup they give you is minuscule. Should be at least double the size for the price they charge. What a rip off. Too bad because I like there food overall“

“The staff was lovely, the food was good!! Would def eat her again!“

“Great food great atmosphere 👏🍷“

“We had a family event last night at their restaurant. I can't stress how great the value is here, and the food quality was top shelf. I have eaten food cooked by some of the best chefs in the world and this was every bit as good. the staff were attentive but not at all intrusive. very accommodating for our large group of 15 people. Their shrimp and calamari platter was cooked perfectly, not at all rubbery, with a divine sauce to dip. Pasta nicely al denté. Calabrese antipasto, nice bread spread. Perfect, and I do mean PERFECTLY, cooked steak, chicken, and sausages. Their pizza is simple but lovely balanced between crisp and chewy. Not too thick, not too thin. Arancini were great. I highly recommend them for your next family event, or just a quiet night out for the family! Thank you to all the staff and the chef for making our family event a success, and we look forward to seeing you again soon!“

“Thank you, Chef Piotr Przykaza and your wife for phenomenal dinner and Tristian for an amazing service 😊🍷 Very highly recommend it 👍“

“Delicious food. Good friendly service“

“The food is terrific - unpretentious classics, obviously passed down through generations. Ask if Albert will be there when you make reservations; trust me, he makes the entire evening just that much better.“

“Enjoyed an amazing dinner on the patio Will definitely be back“

“Excellent food, great atmosphere and service!“

“An old restaurant with history and a proud tradition. The food is good. The honest kind of good. They offer a generous spectrum of texture and flavour even with simple dishes like the minestrone. The setting can easily transport you to where your imagination goes.“

“Had a wonderful dinner at Otto Trattoria. The food was phenomenal... the wood-fired pizza smelled incredible, and my risotto was absolutely delicious. Our server was amazing and attentive, and the atmosphere was cozy, intimate, and lively. Also, surprisingly well priced for the quality. Would definitely go back!“

“The food was absolutely amazing. My 3 daughters and I went there for dinner during Summerlicious 2022. We didn't have reaervations and the options were a 1 hour wait to sit inside or be seated right away on the patio. We chose the patio. We were served our drinks and appetizers within 1/2 hour but our main course came about an hour after but it was worth the wait. We will definitely return🍾🎉“

“Just went there to grab a quick bite couldn’t be happier with the service, very fast and very nice service, the food was amazing and it was also very clean and a very charming place you could tell that the food was made with love and passion. If you’re on a budget this is a great place for you personally I will definitely be coming back absolutely loved it“

“One of the best places I have been to lately Toronto, great authentic Italian food, with amazing service. If I go to a place with the most amazing food and I don’t get great service that just changes my entire experience. At Tutto Pronto eventhogh our servant was not Italian but he gave us the Italian restaurant experience. I love my appetizer, we loved the main and we love the grappa at the end. I just wish we were seated on the main floor as the second floor felt a little too low of a ceiling and didn’t give me the true restaurant experience. Overall definitely recommend 😋“

“Amazing fresh pasta, staff are wonderful and helpful. so glad i found them“

“Been eating at Cali's since I was a kid downtown at the original location.

I always anticipate a decline in the quality, but they have managed to keep the same experience for as long as I could remember.

It's a tad on the expensive side, but in all honesty, I never leave unsatisfied. I'll go for the veal, at least a few times every month.

No matter how many other places I try a veal, they never really match up how Cali's makes it.

Keep up the great food California Sandwiches, thank you.“

“I visit this restaurant from time to time, and it never disappoints. It’s a truly authentic Italian spot with incredible food — everything tastes fresh, flavorful, and made with care. The service really stands out too. Carmela is especially wonderful — always welcoming, kind, and makes you feel right at home every time you walk in. Overall, a great atmosphere, spectacular food, and genuine hospitality. Highly recommended“

“We hosted our son's baptism at Boaccacio- Italian Restaurant this past weekend and from the food, to the service, to the hospitality, the whole experience was fantastic. The team executed our vision, which exceeded our expectations.

Extra special shout out (and thank you) to Mario and Enrique who created such a wonderful dining experience for our guests, to Giovanni who made the event seamless, and to Chef Luciano for the exceptional food!

My husband and I look forward to hosting future events at Boaccacio- Italian Restaurant.“

“I had a great experience at Pizza Pizza on Wilson Avenue! The staff was friendly, fast, and made sure my order was perfect. The pizza was hot, fresh, and had just the right amount of cheese and toppings. I really appreciated how clean the store was and how quickly they handled everything, even during a busy time. Definitely one of the better Pizza Pizza locations in the area — I’ll be coming back for sure!“

“Generous portions. Got pizza this time, which was good and filling (took half of it home). Last time, I had their pan-seared salmon fillet topped with a honey garlic sauce and served with roasted potatoes & vegetables, which I highly recommend. Great outdoor patio spaces too. Quiet. Parking fills up fast in their small lot but you can park on the side streets for free. Service was friendly & attentive. Ask for Mike, he's great!“

“Great little neighbourhood bistro, very good pizzas, pastas and appetizers Friendly service Good value Good location at Wilson station“

“Portions generous. Price reasonable and food tasty“

“Deliious food,charming service. Will definitely eat here again!“

“Pizza Pizza is a solid choice when you want something quick, affordable, and satisfying. The menu has a wide variety of options, from classic pepperoni pizzas to wings, fries, and even plant-based choices, so there’s something for everyone. The ordering process is simple, whether you go in-store, online, or through their app, and the service is usually fast.

The pizza itself is consistent—freshly made with a good balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. While it may not be gourmet, it delivers exactly what you expect from a reliable chain: hot, tasty food at a reasonable price. Their dipping sauces are also a standout feature and add extra flavor to every bite.

Overall, Pizza Pizza is a dependable option for a quick meal, especially when you’re on a budget or need something convenient. It’s not fancy, but it gets the job done well.“

“I got off at Sheppard–Yonge Subway Station and found this pizza store just outside. Tanu was very helpful in guiding me through the order and recommending delicious toppings. The atmosphere was relaxed, with seating that faces the street, offering a nice view. Overall, a great spot—I highly recommend this pizza place!“