50 Best Italian Restaurants near East York

“lovely atmosphere. food was amazing!! The chef did a wonderful job. Joey, our host was attentive and made us feel welcome. I would highly recommend this restaurant.“

“We drive by this small shop a number of times. We order the Spaghetti meatballs and Parma Focaccia Sandwich. The Spaghetti is freshly made with chewy texture and the tomato sauce pairing well with the meatball. The pasta is very tasty. The Focaccia bread has a crunchy crust and all the ingredients are freshly and very delicious. We will definitely come back to try other dishes. The staff is very friendly!“

“I come here about once a week, and Ali always makes the experience great. He’s incredibly friendly, provides excellent customer service, and always takes the time to chat with us while making our pizzas. It’s clear he genuinely cares about the customers and takes pride in his work.“

“My daughter and I have been ordering takeout pizza every Friday for about a year now. Every visit we are warmly welcomed and take home delicious topping filled pizzas! A big thank you and for the love of pizza pizza at O'Connor & St. Clair.“

“First class from beginning to end. We were lucky to reserve seats at the chef’s bar and see the detail and care that goes in to every dish. Great chat, buzzing atmosphere and fantastic food. A memorable evening ❤️“

“This was an amazing experience for us. The food, service, atmosphere and the view was spectacular. Thankyou David, Ashley and the rest of the staff for making us feel very special on the occasion of our 50th wedding anniversary.“

“We came here for the first time and honestly had such a lovely experience! 🤍 Even though we came pretty close to closing time, our server Macai was so kind and welcoming. He and the rest of the staff were genuinely so friendly and made us feel comfortable.

And the Sophia Pizza… OMG! 🤌🏼 It was honestly the best! We absolutely loved it. Since it was our first time here, we tried the Happy Hour version, but next time we’re definitely ordering the regular one for sure!

Such a great first experience. We’ll definitely be back! ❤“

“We had fabulous service. Our waiter Tim was fantastic. Very attentive and wonderful personality Would highly recommend going there if you are in Toronto“

“Very cool place. All the staff was very good at their job, Taya was our waitress. She was awesome in my opinion. The food was good. The triple pepperoni pizza was really good. Make sure you get the hot honey sauce. The mozzarella sticks were really good and fresh. The rigatoni pasta was mid, The noodles were still a little hard maybe I just got a bad batch. The drinks were not strong but overall 5 stars still. I would definitely return!“

“Exceptional food and Service every time .... Heart and Soul goes into each plate 🍴“

“Just opposite Metro centre, great atmosphere, fantastic dishes. If you like truffle or eat gluten free they have some amazing options. TJ was a great host and accommodated our requests and helped us choosing items. Fantastic experience we will be back!“

“Amazing service and amazing food every single time. H“

“Amazing food! Will be back!“

“I ordered the wedding soup take out. $7.99 but the paper cup they give you is minuscule. Should be at least double the size for the price they charge. What a rip off. Too bad because I like there food overall“

“Excellent food and incredible, friendly service. Highly recommend.“

“Tout est vraiment très bon!“

“Pasta was cooked to perfection! Slight chew and that homemade feeling! We had the bread to start and it's like a mini personalized pizza without the tomato sauce & fixings, absolutely fresh! Would go back again. Service was great as well, not pushy and came by the right amount of times!“

“My son and I were in town for the auto show and prefer to hot local places instead of chains, and this place is the exact reason. Our host was amazing, so welcoming and friendly, and genuinely seemed happy to have us. The atmosphere was great and our pizza and tiramisu were incredible. I wish this place existed where I live. Please get out and support local, our world is better having places like this around.“

“Good food and service, nice atmosphere 🍷“

“Amazing pasta and pizza!“

“They had amazing food! Their pasta is absolutely incredible I would definitely eat there again! Service was amazing and it was just an enjoyable time! Their desserts taste amazing as well!“

“Best vegan food ever! Every time we visit Toronto, we stop for a great evening❤️“

“What a great experience last night dining with family and recommended by our granddaughter. The food and ambiance were wonderful.“

“From the moment we first walked in, we felt truly welcomed. The staff treat you as if you are friends visiting their home — warm, attentive, and genuinely kind. The food is always delicious: you can rely on the classics but also discover new dishes every time. We first came here right after arriving in Toronto, and it gave us the rare feeling of being at home in such a big city. Since then, we return several times a month, and every visit has been a positive experience. The atmosphere is cozy, the service outstanding, and the hospitality remarkable. It honestly feels like visiting friends, not just going to a restaurant. A place we highly recommend — definitely worth a visit when in Toronto!“

“Great food great atmosphere 👏🍷“

“Great food excellent service very attentive even the owner came to our table super friendly and great atmosphere Drew M Albuquerque New Mexico“

“My partner and I came to celebrate our anniversary and we had a fantastic time! Food was delicious, probably one of the best Italian places in the city, actually way better than some well known places. Loved the cozy and comfortable vibe yet their menu is really appealing. I would highly recommend“

“The food was excellent and the pasta was clearly made superbly and with great care. However, the waiter had a strange and uncomfortable manner that made the experience feel awkward. Despite how much we enjoyed the food, we found ourselves wanting to quickly finish and leave. This place needs to get their service on par with the food.“

“Excellent food. and very friendly staff. The mushroom salad, veal marsala, and the short ribs were fantastic. We highly recommend this restaurant.“

“Thank you, Chef Piotr Przykaza and your wife for phenomenal dinner and Tristian for an amazing service 😊🍷 Very highly recommend it 👍“

“EXCELLENT Pizza! Friendly staff, LOVE their bread!! (it is their pizza dough) the Bread alone was worth the trip to the city! Highly recommended!“

“A beautiful 10th wedding anniversary celebration. The entire team created a flawless experience.“

“I regularly visit Padella. Always a fantastic experience. The food, atmosphere, and service is nothing short of top notch! The owner Gio and his staff are very hospitable and look after their guests with pride. Service is exceptional and never miss a beat. They offer both indoor and outdoor seating which is great. Love this place and all the people that work in this establishment. Highly recommend Padella!!“

“I’ve never written a review before but this was probably the best pasta I’ve ever had.
Tucked away on a corner of Bathurst, a 5 minute walk from the station, Tiny Market Co. was a warm, cozy hug on a beautiful fall day.

When you first walk in, the smell is what hits you first. It’s what I’d imagine an Italian grandmother’s kitchen to smell like - but better. Garfield books line the shelves and a photo is framed of the husband-wife duo (Erich and Danielle) who lovingly run the place, sweetly swapping quick banter between the kitchen and the front.

Danielle was the kindest, expertly juggling the busy front and ushering me to a 2-seater table even though I was dining solo. Erich briefly stepped out of the kitchen, which
gave us the opportunity to sing our praises of the pasta.

And the pasta. The pasta! Wow.

Roasted squash scarpinocc with egg and spinach dough. Brown butter and sage. Pistachio and panko. Balsamic and lemon. Pecorino al tartufo. It was acidic and sweet. Light and rich. Caramelized and nutty. The dish somehow made every binary work. It was like autumn on a plate. Truly amazing stuff is going on here. Be sure to drop by because the menu changes every week!“

“Went for the 1st time with some friends to celebrate our wedding anniversary. I felt really bad because there was only 1 waiter there and it ended up getting really busy. He tried his best to accommodate and get everyone's orders in. The arugula salad was AMAZING! I could've had more. The Nutella donuts were great . Overall was a lovely lunch!“

“A friend and I enjoyed lunch on Friday October 17. We had reserved and were seated at one of their window tables. Our server Quinn was friendly and efficient and was able to offer his opinion on main dishes we selected. The portions were more than generous and both of us were provided with take away containers. My friend has decided to book a family birthday here later this month. And I plan to return to Trattoria Di Parma early in November with friends who will be visiting from Calgary. Final comments: Great food, great service and very reasonable prices.“

“I absolutely recommend Dalmoro’s Fresh Pasta To Go.. the freshest pasta that one can ever find in Toronto. their pesto is my all time favourite. Their housemade classic Tiramisu and Nutella Tiramisu deserves a special mention !!!“

“Sandwich was pretty good! If adding tomato’s was an option I’d be returning. Bread was ok. I liked the shape/size! Online ordering for pickup was easy. The outside area is nice in the summer but I assume takeout only in the winter.“

“What a beautiful place. The best experience my girlfriend and I had. The food OMG Nailed it. You have to come here and experience and trust me you won't be disappointed. The owner and staff treated us like family. Great night , will definitely have to come here again. You must come and try this restaurant if you like Italian food you won't be disappointed. Thank you for the great experience and amazing night. Remo and Stephanie.“

“Ostaria Giula has the most amazing staff our server was Giancarlo he was super amaziOstaria Giulia hang with great recommendations. He was very knowledgeable about all the food and was able to suggest dishes for food allergies. I was so excited to go to our first Michelin star restaurant to celebrate a birthday and an anniversary. I was hoping to be able to meet Rob Rossi but I didn't just meet him, he was aware of our celebration and he took the time to come and great us .....I am a foodie so I was truly star struck. David Minicucci went above and beyond getting us a perfect table and ensuring we had a wonderful celebration. Thank you all at Ostaria Giulia from the chefs to servers and bar tender and the wonderful sommelier who suggested the perfect wine. We had an amazing time that I will remember forever. BRAVO!!!!!“

“Staff are very friendly & welcoming. The owner/chef came out to chat with diners which is always great. Food was delicious & freshly made. The exterior is a bit misleading & could be enhanced with flowers, signage etc. Menu changes in the first of each month. Will definitely return.“

“Decent enough Italian food from a wide list of menu options. Not a high end dining experience but the food- for-price was great. Steak salad was excellent, and the seafood pasta was a great portion and tasty, although a proper Italian restaurant would likely made it with a olive oil/wine sauce instead of marinara.

Waiters were friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable (although dressed more for waitstaff at Woody's instead of a restaurant (but that's the Village for ya). A bit too hot in summer as front is open to patio, thus no air conditioning; just pick your days carefully. Would go back for sure.“

“would highly recommend going there.... Food... Excellent Service... Excellent Atmosphere... Excellent They ALWAYS aim to PLEASE.“

“Italian style, charcoal grilled food is good, I will come again next time 😜“

“Beautiful ambiance, delicious grub and sexy cocktails💃🥂Definitely coming back!“

“Food is great and reasonably priced ,great drinks and the staff are excellent ,well trained and have a laugh with you .The manager made me a Caesar (cocktail) and converted me …. Will definitely be back“

“We hosted our Mothers 70th birthday in the private room. I cannot express how PERFECT the evening was. From the food (OUTSTANDING) to the atmosphere but most especially, the service. Hannah was a star!! She was funny and professional and made the evening flow with ease. Highly recommend the private space for a dinner party. Thank you NODO. 5 stars!!“

“A Wonderful Evening at Carisma

We had a wonderful dinner at Carisma yesterday with a group of 8. The food was absolutely excellent, and we especially enjoyed sharing the delicious fried zucchini flowers among all 8 of us. The individual antipasto plates were also a wonderful touch and gave everyone the opportunity to enjoy a variety of delicious dishes.

A special thank you to Monica for setting up such a beautiful table for our group of 8. It was the perfect setting for a memorable evening.

Thank you to Margi and the entire Carisma staff for the warm hospitality, attentive service, and for making our evening so special. We had a fantastic time and will definitely be back!“