50 Best Italian Restaurants near York

“The food is beyond amazing!! And they have a great selection of desserts as well. ✨“

“Came in from out of town to see family and stopped by the pizza pizza on Rodgers rd. Very clean environment and great hospitality. Thank you to Alex for your outstanding customer service and warm welcome. I will be returning, thank you and all the best!“

“The food was insanely good! Very well seasoned, fresh, good portion sizes, etc. The 2 associates were very friendly and gave us good recommendations (shoutout to them, they both had glasses). Service 10/10, Food 10/10. Drove 1 hour to get here and no regrets!“

“We randomly discovered this spot while driving, and it ended up being one of the highlights of our day. Great coffee, an amazing selection of fresh baked goods, and such a cozy atmosphere. The staff were incredibly kind, helpful, welcoming!“

“I visited Pizza Hut today to redeem the free pizza promotion celebrating Canada making it into the World Cup Round of 16, and I had such a great experience!

A special thank you to Ekta for her outstanding service. She was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and patient throughout the whole process. The service was quick, organized, and professional, and the pizza was fresh and delicious as always. It’s not often you receive service that makes such a difference, but Ekta truly went above and beyond.

Thank you, Pizza Hut, for the great promotion and excellent customer service. I will definitely come back again!“

“We got the mussels and sausage pizza. Both were delicious. The mussels tasted fresh and the broth needed to be soaked up with bread! Pizza was thin, crispy and had more cheese than I expected which was a pleasant surprise. Price was very reasonable for the quality of the meal. Our server was very nice and attentive. I will be back.“

“First class from beginning to end. We were lucky to reserve seats at the chef’s bar and see the detail and care that goes in to every dish. Great chat, buzzing atmosphere and fantastic food. A memorable evening ❤️“

“This was an amazing experience for us. The food, service, atmosphere and the view was spectacular. Thankyou David, Ashley and the rest of the staff for making us feel very special on the occasion of our 50th wedding anniversary.“

“I can never get tired of this place. I really enjoy their menu. Great atmosphere, great weight staff overall, I have a great experience visited the Sherway Gardens location first followed by the location by Colossus Both locations left me with great experience overall and will return again!“

“This is a great option if you're staying near the airport and looking to have a meal. Was in town for a conference and they easily accommodate groups and couples alike. Loved the vibes of the covered patio. Drinks were top notch and the service, particularly Sofia, was the icing on the cake!“

“Very cool place. All the staff was very good at their job, Taya was our waitress. She was awesome in my opinion. The food was good. The triple pepperoni pizza was really good. Make sure you get the hot honey sauce. The mozzarella sticks were really good and fresh. The rigatoni pasta was mid, The noodles were still a little hard maybe I just got a bad batch. The drinks were not strong but overall 5 stars still. I would definitely return!“

“Wow it was so good experience the service was good the good was so good it was my first time there all I can say I do recommend to try it my boys meet the chef very friendly“

“We had fabulous service. Our waiter Tim was fantastic. Very attentive and wonderful personality Would highly recommend going there if you are in Toronto“

“I ordered the wedding soup take out. $7.99 but the paper cup they give you is minuscule. Should be at least double the size for the price they charge. What a rip off. Too bad because I like there food overall“

“This place is amazing. The front street location is fantastic. The service is absolutely perfect! I would recommend this place to anyone who is looking for an Italian inspired dish. Our server, is what made this experience very special! From entering to exit, the atmosphere is to perfection. The food will speak for itself. Happy with the whole experience.“

“Amazing service and amazing food every single time. H“

“Exceptional food and Service every time .... Heart and Soul goes into each plate 🍴“

“Amazing food! Will be back!“

“Amazing food from a family run restaurant, large portions with inspiration from Italy. Tony is amazing!“

“Food is really great, clean and hygienic“

“Excellent food and incredible, friendly service. Highly recommend.“

“Tout est vraiment très bon!“

“My son and I were in town for the auto show and prefer to hot local places instead of chains, and this place is the exact reason. Our host was amazing, so welcoming and friendly, and genuinely seemed happy to have us. The atmosphere was great and our pizza and tiramisu were incredible. I wish this place existed where I live. Please get out and support local, our world is better having places like this around.“

“Good food and service, nice atmosphere 🍷“

“I went here for lunch with a friend today. The food was excellent, really delicious and good value. The tiramisu is outstanding and the pasta isn't too heavy or rich but offers a great portion.

The real let down was the service. We got the sense the server was overwhelmed but he was doing his best and based on other reviews I think this was an unusual experience. It took about an hour and a half to have lunch. We saw the server a lot he just didn't stop to see to us much. Overall a positive experience and we'll definitely give them another try.“

“Absolutely loved the vibe of this restaurant! The atmosphere was warm, lively, and authentic. It genuinely reminded me of being at a restaurant in Italy. The service was also excellent; everyone was friendly, attentive, and made the experience even better. We started with the pizza topped with cherry tomatoes and burrata, which was delicious. For pasta, I had the Paccheri with Guanciale, and my fiancée had the Mafalde ai Funghi. Both dishes were very good and had great flavours. My only small criticism would be that the pasta itself could have used a little more seasoning it tasted as though the pasta water may not have been salted enough. The sauces were fantastic, but a little more seasoning in the pasta would have made both dishes perfect. For our main, we shared the Vitello alla Milanese, which was also absolutely delicious and cooked beautifully. Overall, we had a fantastic experience. Great atmosphere, great service, and phenomenal food. I would definitely recommend this restaurant and will absolutely be coming back!“

“What a great experience last night dining with family and recommended by our granddaughter. The food and ambiance were wonderful.“

“Amazing pasta and pizza!“

“The food was excellent and the pasta was clearly made superbly and with great care. However, the waiter had a strange and uncomfortable manner that made the experience feel awkward. Despite how much we enjoyed the food, we found ourselves wanting to quickly finish and leave. This place needs to get their service on par with the food.“

“Best vegan food ever! Every time we visit Toronto, we stop for a great evening❤️“

“From the moment we first walked in, we felt truly welcomed. The staff treat you as if you are friends visiting their home — warm, attentive, and genuinely kind. The food is always delicious: you can rely on the classics but also discover new dishes every time. We first came here right after arriving in Toronto, and it gave us the rare feeling of being at home in such a big city. Since then, we return several times a month, and every visit has been a positive experience. The atmosphere is cozy, the service outstanding, and the hospitality remarkable. It honestly feels like visiting friends, not just going to a restaurant. A place we highly recommend — definitely worth a visit when in Toronto!“

“I had heard about the eggplant parmigiana through friends. So on my birthday we decided to try it. I got the veal parm also with all the sides, and when we sat down with my family to eat, my 91 year old Italian mom who was a very good cook, just kept raving about the food. She says, this is just like homemade, just like I would make it and she was right! We kept repeating with every bite. It was delicious, highly recommended. Definitely a staple and going back.“

“Went here Friday night with a girlfriend. It's a cute little Italian restaurant. Good menu, good food and good staff. The buratta was delicious, and so were our mains.
Our main server Victoria was so amazing and attentive! Highly recommend her.
But I gave 4 stars as we didn't like the attitude of one of the other servers who first denied us a table and second tried to rush us with ordering our mains. Also a 3rd server also seeemd to rush us and even tried to take my plate away when I wasn't done!“

“They had amazing food! Their pasta is absolutely incredible I would definitely eat there again! Service was amazing and it was just an enjoyable time! Their desserts taste amazing as well!“

“Great food excellent service very attentive even the owner came to our table super friendly and great atmosphere Drew M Albuquerque New Mexico“

“A beautiful 10th wedding anniversary celebration. The entire team created a flawless experience.“

“Via Allegro has been one of my favorite restaurants for many, many years. In 2022, they changed ownership, but the warm, family-like atmosphere remains as special as ever. Every visit is memorable, and last night was no exception. My girlfriend and I celebrated a milestone, and the staff went above and beyond to make it an unforgettable experience. Our server, Alex, made sure every detail was perfect (it’s the second time we've been lucky enough to have him). From the personalized reservation card on the table to the exquisite wine selection, served at the perfect temperature and topped up at just the right moment, everything was flawless. And, of course, the food was absolutely delicious. Thank you to Alex and Mohamad Fakih for making our evening truly magical. Via Allegro continues to set the bar for exceptional service and dining.“

“Today we celebrated my father’s 90th birthday and there is no better place to celebrate than at Tovico! The food is great, the staff is very professional and make you feel very welcoming. Our guests commented that they would be coming back soon making us feel that they also had a great experience. Thank Riccardo, Tessa, Leo and staff for a great time. See you soon, Mary“

“EXCELLENT Pizza! Friendly staff, LOVE their bread!! (it is their pizza dough) the Bread alone was worth the trip to the city! Highly recommended!“

“The staff was lovely, the food was good!! Would def eat her again!“

“Great food great atmosphere 👏🍷“

“Absolutely fantastic! The food was fresh, authentic, and incredibly flavorful. The homemade pasta was outstanding, and the service was warm, attentive, and friendly. Beautiful atmosphere and an overall wonderful dining experience. Definitely one of the best Italian restaurants we’ve been to—we’ll be back!“

“Absolutely wonderful ambiance, Vincenzo e famiglia completamente meravigliosi. Dinner was absolutely fantastic highly highly recommend this hidden gem in Etobicoke.“

“Went for the 1st time with some friends to celebrate our wedding anniversary. I felt really bad because there was only 1 waiter there and it ended up getting really busy. He tried his best to accommodate and get everyone's orders in. The arugula salad was AMAZING! I could've had more. The Nutella donuts were great . Overall was a lovely lunch!“

“A friend and I enjoyed lunch on Friday October 17. We had reserved and were seated at one of their window tables. Our server Quinn was friendly and efficient and was able to offer his opinion on main dishes we selected. The portions were more than generous and both of us were provided with take away containers. My friend has decided to book a family birthday here later this month. And I plan to return to Trattoria Di Parma early in November with friends who will be visiting from Calgary. Final comments: Great food, great service and very reasonable prices.“

“Food is great and reasonably priced ,great drinks and the staff are excellent ,well trained and have a laugh with you .The manager made me a Caesar (cocktail) and converted me …. Will definitely be back“

“Thanks for another fantastic evening. We really enjoyed our meal the food is always exceptional. The restaurant was really busy and the service was still outstanding. Well done everyone. 👏“

“Lovely venue, stylish ambiance, tasty Italian food choices, great wines offered by Vitalita www.Vitalita.ca Overall nice place in Woodbridge to dine or meet friend for lunch. I will revisit.“