35 Best Italian Restaurants in Scarborough

“Great experience. Our server Kiyya was on point from beginning to end, making sure that we were taken care of in a timely manner. She was very helpful especially with assisting me to create great options for the keto diet that I'm currently on. Great job!“

“My husband and I went for dinner last night and it was delicious. We ordered fried calamari as an app. I ordered the Linguine Mare and my husband ordered the veal marsala for the mains. Everything tasted fabulous. Service is excellent and Sal is amazing at welcoming everyone. This was our first visit but certainly won't be the last.“

“Fabulous food and service.“

“The Feast in the Box exceeded my expectations. I had placed a phone order and am I ever glad that I did - that place was slammed which is a testament to their business and the food hall in general. It was ready as soon as I walked in and I was pleasantly surprised when I went to lift the very hefty box. When I got home, I was pleased by the perfectly cooked eggs (runny egg yolks make a great sauce) and the delicious variety in cooked meats. It served three very hungry people with a bit left over for lunch tomorrow. Portions: great; flavours: great; service: great!“

“I had a great experience at East Side Mario's thanks to Stephanie! She was super friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect throughout the meal. Her service really stood out and made the whole experience even better. Definitely one of the best servers I’ve had, thank you, Stephanie!“

“Stopped in for a late breakfast this week and was very happy with the quality of the food and the pleasant staff. The waitress was friendly, efficient and attentive. Overall such a nice breakfast and I would recommend it.“

“They have some great food, the pizza slices are filled with so many toppings too. The dipping sauce is a little pricey, wish they had a smaller cheaper alternative. The stromboli was alright, I'd rather get the slices, much better deal. The people are friendly and the service is quick.“

“Great Value, Taste and Service. Jennifer and Leah are Wonderbar“

“I haven't been here in about 10 years, probably more, but I decided to take my family here to celebrate my mom's birthday. From the moment we walked in, it was just like it used to be - cozy homey and very welcoming. We were escorted to our table by a very friendly gentleman, and introduced to our waitress. I regret not getting her name, but our waitress was absolutely incredible. Her knowledge of the menu was unreal, and her attentiveness and hospitality had us enjoying the restaurant without even eating anything yet. We ordered a few appetizers, a few different pasta dishes, and chicken and veal parmesan. The collective census of my family was that everything was fresh, delicious, flavorful and very satisfying. I've been to a handful of Italian restaurants and I've been disappointed 90% of the time. But not this time! They also allowed us to bring a cake and kept it in the fridge for us. It was brought out with candles lit, a perfect end to a lovely meal. Everything about this experience was perfect, and my family and I will be back very soon. Never change, Remezzo!“

“I had a great experience at Pizza Hut! The staff were incredibly friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect from the moment I walked in. The service was quick, and they handled everything with a smile, which really made the visit enjoyable.

The food was just as impressive—fresh, hot, and full of flavor. The pizza was perfectly cooked with a generous amount of toppings, and everything tasted delicious. You can tell they take pride in both their food and customer service.

Overall, a fantastic experience. Big thanks to the team for their hard work—I’ll definitely be coming back!“

“Ordered takeout and had a great experience. Got two veggie pizzas (Veggie Lover’s and Green Pepper & Mushroom) on the BOGO deal — excellent value. Both were fresh, flavorful, and well-made. Order was ready on time and pickup was smooth. Would order again!“

“Was in with a large group a few weekends ago. Tried the square Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Was so good. Had the right kick to it. So the overall experience. We were a group of around 30. The service was prompt, the servers attentive especially with the challenge of such a large group. Was not too noisy so we were able go have conversations within the entire group. Overall was an outstanding experience.“

“I recently visited Pizza Hut at Sheppard & Brimley in Scarborough and had a great experience. The pizzas were absolutely delicious—fresh, hot, and full of flavor. The crust was perfectly baked and the toppings were generous.

The service was also very friendly and quick, which made the visit even better. If you’re craving good pizza in the area, this Pizza Hut location is definitely worth trying. Highly recommended! 🍕👍“

“I had a great experience at the Pizza Pizza location at Ellesmere and Midland. The service was excellent, and Jay was extremely helpful and friendly. He went out of his way to assist us and made sure everything was perfect. Really appreciate the great customer service. I’ll definitely be coming back!“

“Fantastic pizza and great neighbourhood vibe. thanks Joe!“

“Been here a few times. Great customer service. Friendly and quick. Quality is great. Couple of spots to sit down and eat which aren't usually too busy so you'll likely find a place to sit if that's what you want. Typically I see people getting take out.
Convenient location with plenty of parking and other shops close by to run multiple errands while you're here.“

“Just tried the pizza at the new Big Brothers Gourmet Pizza location - delicious! Fresh ingredients and scrumptious dough. Highly recommend it. - Brian McIntyre, Brian McIntyre Real Estate .“

“I picked up a few pizzas for our lunch at work, and amazing, met the lovely owner, and they run a good shop. We will be back. I had stopped ordering with pizza pizza years ago, but recently have given this location a try and really good stuff. Thanks!!“

“For over a decade, this has been one of our go-to places in the city, especially after trips to the Toronto Zoo. Our family loves the giant pizza slices, pasta, gelato, baked goods, and coffee. Seating is somewhat limited (for now, since they appear to be expanding to next door), and lines can get long, but they move fast. Service is always efficient and polite.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Best Pizza and Even Better Service!

I had an amazing experience at this pizza place! Not only was the pizza absolutely delicious—crispy crust, rich toppings, and perfectly melted cheese—but the service was what truly stood out. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile and friendly attitude. The staff was attentive, quick to take the order, and made sure everything was perfect throughout my visit.

They even took the time to check in after serving the food to see if we needed anything else. The place was clean, the atmosphere was cozy, and the team clearly cared about making every customer feel welcome. It's rare to find this level of service nowadays!

Highly recommend this spot to anyone who loves great pizza and top-notch customer service. Definitely coming back again! 🍕🔥“

“Never disappointed:)“

“my daughter recommended this place . I tried it today and will definitely be going to Rosa's again,the food is of great quantity and quality.“

“Tried this pizza spot recently and honestly, it was a solid experience. The pizza was fresh, loaded with toppings, and the crust had that perfect balance—crispy on the outside but still soft inside. You can tell they actually care about quality and not just rushing orders out.

Also shoutout to Gurpreet—she was super friendly and made the whole experience even better. Really patient, helpful with recommendations, and just had a great vibe overall.

Definitely a place I’d come back to when I’m craving good pizza 👍“

“Pizza Hut never fails to impress! The pizzas are always hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. The crust is amazing—perfectly crispy yet soft inside. Their variety of toppings and cheesy goodness make every bite satisfying. The service is quick and efficient.“

“on buffet all wayes freshly filling everything every few minutes customer not waiting“

“Just tried the pizza at the new Big Brothers Gourmet Pizza location - delicious! Fresh ingredients and scrumptious dough. Highly recommend it. - Brian McIntyre, Brian McIntyre Real Estate .“

“Great service and good quality meal.“

“You guys are always smiling while you serve and always maintain the quality of all the pizzas, I often come there for cheese pizzas and veggie slices (the slices are also very fresh everytime). Shoutout to the whole team and thank you, cheers!“

“Krish — the white guy with lots of tattoos — always made our visits to Pizza Pizza extra special. I used to come here often with my family, and he was always super friendly, respectful, and welcoming. He really brought positive energy every time we walked in.

The food is always fresh, the place is clean, and the service is quick. But having someone like Krish there made the whole experience even better. Big shoutout to him for being awesome!“

“went there to get a large pizza with 4 toppings.. and i must say they know how to make customers happy 😊
the guy named Sahil he took our order and he was really patient and suggested some good options..
the toppings were perfect and the pizza tasted really good thanks to Shivani who made it 😅
surely next time will order from there“

“Nice little place when looking for a change of pace. Not a whole lot of sit down Italian restaurant options in the area.

Service can occasionally be a bit slow. But we are rarely in a rush. Some of the chairs are kinda flimsy. Be sure to sit gingerly if you’re a customer of size.

Ordered the panzerotto for the first time. Decent. Might order again if in the mood. Meatballs tasted a bit processed. Was surprised by that.

Scoring 5’s across the board to bump the average because I don’t think 3.9 is a fair score per the current standings. But the location is definitely more of a 4.3 kinda place.“

“I've had the exact opposite experience as some of the others, the service is amazing, they're so kind and efficient. We've never had to wait very long and and if we do, they're super communicative and respectful. My mom refuses to go anywhere else for pizza.“

“Customer service was phenomenal — friendly and fast. The two pizzas I got were hot and the crust was cooked to perfection.

Pizza Hut and this location do not skimp on toppings and probably consistently give some of the most of all the chain pizza shops around. They’re the only pizza shop within a few blocks of McCowan and Eglinton so I’m glad they don’t take it for granted!“

“I would like to thank Sean and the rest of the staff for always providing polite, friendly, amazing, outstanding and awesome customer service. I always come to this location because I feel the food tastes the best, and it is very clean and a very welcoming environment. This is the best Pizza Pizza in the city.“