37 Best Italian Restaurants in Scarborough

“We came here for the first time and honestly had such a lovely experience! 🤍 Even though we came pretty close to closing time, our server Macai was so kind and welcoming. He and the rest of the staff were genuinely so friendly and made us feel comfortable.

And the Sophia Pizza… OMG! 🤌🏼 It was honestly the best! We absolutely loved it. Since it was our first time here, we tried the Happy Hour version, but next time we’re definitely ordering the regular one for sure!

Such a great first experience. We’ll definitely be back! ❤“

“My husband and I went for dinner last night and it was delicious. We ordered fried calamari as an app. I ordered the Linguine Mare and my husband ordered the veal marsala for the mains. Everything tasted fabulous. Service is excellent and Sal is amazing at welcoming everyone. This was our first visit but certainly won't be the last.“

“Wow!! New ownership is making the difference. We used to go here years ago because the food was inexpensive. But back then, the quality of the food was horrible. Now with the new ownership, the food is amazing!! Within a short few months the new ownership has turned this place around! Stephanie, our waitress, provided us with excellent customer service! Come back and enjoy a family restaurant...We will be coming back again and again!“

“I had a really great experience at Pizza Hut and wanted to take a moment to properly recognize how good the overall service was. From the moment I placed my order, everything went smoothly and efficiently. The customer service was excellent, and the staff were friendly, helpful, and professional throughout the entire experience. It’s always nice when you can tell that the people working there genuinely care about making sure customers have a positive experience.

What impressed me the most was the speed of the service. My order was prepared much faster than I expected, and despite how quickly everything was done, the quality of the food was not compromised. The pizza came out hot, fresh, and exactly how I wanted it. There’s something especially satisfying about getting your food quickly and still receiving a pizza that tastes like it was made with care rather than something that was rushed.

And of course, the pizza itself was delicious! The crust had a really nice texture, the cheese was melted perfectly, and the toppings were generous and flavorful. Everything came together really well, and it was exactly what I was hoping for when I ordered pizza. It was hot, cheesy, fresh, and genuinely satisfying. I definitely finished the meal feeling like I had made the right choice.

Overall, this was one of those experiences where the food, service, and speed all came together perfectly. Great customer service, quick preparation, and a really tasty pizza made for an excellent experience. I really appreciate the staff for doing such a great job, and I would absolutely order from this Pizza Hut again. It’s always worth mentioning when a restaurant gets everything right, and this location definitely deserves the recognition. Highly recommend!“

“Fabulous food and service.“

“I recently placed a large order for a company event (20 pizzas, chicken bites, sauces...) and was extremely happy with the quality of food we received! Each pizza was warm and prepared exactly as ordered. Sukhmani was a pleasure to deal with and ensured the order was ready right on time! Definitely reccomend this location!“

“The Feast in the Box exceeded my expectations. I had placed a phone order and am I ever glad that I did - that place was slammed which is a testament to their business and the food hall in general. It was ready as soon as I walked in and I was pleasantly surprised when I went to lift the very hefty box. When I got home, I was pleased by the perfectly cooked eggs (runny egg yolks make a great sauce) and the delicious variety in cooked meats. It served three very hungry people with a bit left over for lunch tomorrow. Portions: great; flavours: great; service: great!“

“Great meal at lunchtime. Good price point. Good service - lovely female server Stephanie.
But the music was really loud and more like club music than lunch appropriate. The other diners were elderly so I’m not sure the music is appreciated. A manager came by and asked how everything was, and I mentioned the music which he said was controlled by the bar side of the restaurant. But he did say that they could lower the volume in the dining room and the bar could still be noisy.
Even that was an improvement.“

“They have some great food, the pizza slices are filled with so many toppings too. The dipping sauce is a little pricey, wish they had a smaller cheaper alternative. The stromboli was alright, I'd rather get the slices, much better deal. The people are friendly and the service is quick.“

“I recently visited Pizza Hut at Sheppard & Brimley in Scarborough and had a great experience. The pizzas were absolutely delicious—fresh, hot, and full of flavor. The crust was perfectly baked and the toppings were generous.

The service was also very friendly and quick, which made the visit even better. If you’re craving good pizza in the area, this Pizza Hut location is definitely worth trying. Highly recommended! 🍕👍“

“As a regular customer, I want to thank all the stuff who work at this location. Great customer service. Very polite while serving customers. During hot summer days they offer water (free of cost). I am very thankful and grateful for being your regular customer.“

“Great Value, Taste and Service. Jennifer and Leah are Wonderbar“

“Been here a few times. Great customer service. Friendly and quick. Quality is great. Couple of spots to sit down and eat which aren't usually too busy so you'll likely find a place to sit if that's what you want. Typically I see people getting take out.
Convenient location with plenty of parking and other shops close by to run multiple errands while you're here.“

“Excellent breakfast!“

“Fantastic pizza and great neighbourhood vibe. thanks Joe!“

“Just tried the pizza at the new Big Brothers Gourmet Pizza location - delicious! Fresh ingredients and scrumptious dough. Highly recommend it. - Brian McIntyre, Brian McIntyre Real Estate .“

“Nice resturant for metting up with friend and having a nice meal. Servers were very pleasant and welcoming. The food tasted amazing. I especially like how after all the years the interior decor has not changed. It kept original character and charm.“

“We got the big slice a couple weeks ago and it was absolutely incredible. Easily some of the best tasting pizza I've ever had, and the experience is a ton of fun. The staff is really nice and cares about you having a good experience. Highly recommend Lamanna's for their big slice / pizza especially, but I'm sure everything else on the menu is fantastic as well.“

“Great customer service 👏 infact I grab the napkins it came out lots I gave back said sorry, the boy did say that's fine with politeness, without rudeness ,really appreciate it keep up the great service 👍.
Definitely go back.“

“Pizza Hut never fails to impress! The pizzas are always hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. The crust is amazing—perfectly crispy yet soft inside. Their variety of toppings and cheesy goodness make every bite satisfying. The service is quick and efficient.“

“Never disappointed:)“

“Bought 2 extra large pizzas yesterday and my family and I were extremely satisfied with the product, the pizza was fresh and tasty. The man that served us seemed a bit annoyed and that might’ve been because we made a couple changes to our order or because they were a bit busy with the phone orders. Either way, we appreciated the overall service. We live more than an hour away from that location, but would visit again if we happen to be in the area.“

“Great tasting food all the time, but the ladies serving the food sometimes can be a bit intimidating, they are not friendly at all. After 15 years working in the area and always having lunch there, I have to state, is time to smile little!“

“my daughter recommended this place . I tried it today and will definitely be going to Rosa's again,the food is of great quantity and quality.“

“Great service and good quality meal.“

“Absolutely loved my experience at Pizza Pizza!
The pizza was fresh, hot, and loaded with flavor—perfectly baked crust with just the right amount of crispiness. The toppings were generous and tasted really fresh, which made every bite amazing. 🍅🧀
What impressed me the most was the quick service and friendly staff. Even during busy hours, everything was handled smoothly and efficiently.10/10“

“Just tried the pizza at the new Big Brothers Gourmet Pizza location - delicious! Fresh ingredients and scrumptious dough. Highly recommend it. - Brian McIntyre, Brian McIntyre Real Estate .“

“on buffet all wayes freshly filling everything every few minutes customer not waiting“

“Excellent experience at Pizza Hut thanks to Vinny . She was friendly, professional, and went above and beyond to ensure my food allergy concerns were taken seriously. She carefully reviewed my order and made sure it was prepared with the necessary precautions. The food was fresh, the service was quick, and the overall experience was outstanding. Thank you, Vinny, for your exceptional customer care!“

“I had a great experience at Pizza Hut thanks to Manager Raj. He was professional, friendly, and made sure everything was perfect. The customer service was excellent, and you can tell he genuinely cares about his customers. Thank you, Raj, for making our visit enjoyable. Highly recommend this Pizza Hut location!“

“Great experience at Pizza Hut! The pizza was fresh, hot, and delicious, and the restaurant was clean and welcoming. Special thanks to Karm at the front for the excellent customer service—friendly, professional, and made the visit even better. Will definitely be back!“

“Supra- The middle-aged employee was working very hard and showed great patience while dealing with customers, even when one customer was extremely rude. During busy hours like this, Pizza Pizza should consider hiring more staff—having only one person manage everything is not enough.

At first, the cashier seemed a bit off with us, but after seeing the kind of behavior he had to deal with, I can understand his frustration.

Hats off to him for staying patient and continuing to do his job under pressure.“

“We had an amazing experience at this pizza store! The customer service was outstanding, and Rippon deserves a special mention. He was incredibly kind, friendly, and genuinely went above and beyond to accommodate us.

He tried every possible way to make sure we were taken care of, and his attitude and willingness to help really stood out. It’s not every day you come across someone who puts this much effort into making customers feel valued.

Thank you, Rippon, for the excellent service! You’re a great guy, and we truly appreciate everything you did. Highly recommend this place for both the pizza and the wonderful customer service! 🍕👏“

“We have been ordering from this location for close to 10+ years and even today - the quality of Pizza has always been awesome & scrumptious. The only draw back is the tips that the delivery guys ask at the door even when we keep repeating that the bill has been paid - sometimes with or without tips. It is really annoying, bothersome, embarrassing & humiliating to explain - especially whn tips are excluded. Appreciate if the management from this location professionally address this issue with the delivery guys.“

“Went in on a cool evening amd was easily seated for 1. I ordered a raspberry lemonade martini, the truffle wedges, and the spicy chicken carbera (sp?). The wedges were perfectly crispy, and had that good crunch to them. I'd happily go there again :)“

“Great pizza and excellent service! The staff were friendly, my order was ready quickly, and the pizza was hot and fresh. The crust was crispy, the toppings were generous, and everything tasted amazing. I’ll definitely be coming back. Highly recommend this location!“