18 Best Italian Restaurants in Newmarket

“Came to this restaurant, I had the pesto shrimp pasta and it was delicious 😋, was so good, I recommend this great place, good place for dinner.“

“It was our 1st time there and believe me we were not disapointed. Very clean place,Enza our server was excellent! Already planning a party for my husband's 50th birthday in January, we will be going back in another week! Bravo Orsini's“

“first time eating here and it won't be the last time !!!“

“Amazing sandwiches! Great taste! A must try. Lunch or dinner or even catering. They won’t disappoint!“

“We had a small wedding reception at Villa Risi and they did a fabulous job. The food was incredible, the service was friendly and prompt and the atmosphere was wonderful. We were so pleased with the attention to detail they provided. Peter and his staff were amazing.“

“absolutely amazing food , great atmosphere and very generous quantity. been there many times and never had an issue . the chef & his assistant are terrific 5⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“If I could rate this restaurant 10 stars I would. The service was absolutely incredible and I strongly invite anyone with allergies to take the time to read my review.

I have a severe shellfish allergy and I can’t describe how appreciated and noticed I felt eating here. From the waiting staff to the kitchen, everyone was so accommodating and incredible. They even went as far as to help me come up with a custom meal and went as far as adding anything I particularly liked into the dish without hesitation. Honestly, I was moved to tears with how compassionate the team was, and didn’t feel judged for a second.

The food was absolutely amazing in addition to the incredible staff who serviced us during our visit here. I would 100% recommend coming here.“

“i’ve been going here since they first opened! I don’t have a negative thing to say - i do however wish they had delivery service so i could order their pizzas for delivery 😀 as they are in the other end of town for us.

We really enjoy their pizzas but our all time favourite is their veal sandwich’s and the chicken greek salad. Soooooo good! I sometimes order a side of their hot peppers to throw on my salad.

The veal is tender and it’s very filling, the bun is fresh and soft and it pairs so well with their tomato sauce.
i do wish though that they would also do eggplant as an add on but they’re a successful business so i’m sure they have there reasons not too.

My son absolutely loves their rose sauce so we do often buy their jarred sauce to go. It’s one of our favourite italian bakery’s. The staff are so kind and it’s always a busy place to go so you know it’s great food when you see tons of people there

Here’s a picture of a Hawaiian and pineapple pizza half eaten. It was very good!“

“The best pizza ever, been going there since mid 80’s“

“I just got back from Italy a week ago, and while walking around Upper Canada Mall, I came across VERO Italian Sandwich Co. I was curious to see how their sandwiches would compare to the ones I had in Italy, and I have to say, I was genuinely impressed!

I ordered the Truffle sandwich and asked if they could replace the original meat with grilled chicken. The staff were incredibly friendly and happily accommodated my request, which I really appreciated!

The sandwich was absolutely delicious! Fresh ingredients, amazing flavours, and perfectly prepared. It honestly tasted just as good as the sandwiches I had in Italy. It brought back memories of my trip!

Such a pleasant surprise to find authentic Italian flavours right here in Canada. I highly recommend this place, especially if you love Italian sandwiches. I'll definitely be coming back!“

“Had a fantastic experience at Doughbox,
I was pleasantly surprised at the level of professionalism when it comes to the halal sections - separate stations for cutting, toppings and baking trays.
A very warm welcome and recommend it to anyone that enjoys a good pizza slice.
I came in for the walk in special which was reasonably priced and will come again soon.“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ An all-around fantastic dining experience! The food was outstanding, the service was top-notch, and the atmosphere was just perfect. Add in a prime location and a wonderful, attentive staff, and you’ve got a restaurant that’s hard to beat. Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to over and over! Best restaurant around!“

“I recently ordered from Pizza Pizza and had a great experience. The delivery was on time, and the pizza arrived hot and fresh. The crust was soft yet slightly crispy, and the toppings were generous. I also tried their garlic dipping sauce, which was really tasty. Overall, very satisfied with both the food and service.“

“The food is amazing. The service is great. I have been coming to this pizza pizza for a long time now. I am greeted with a “hello how are you doing today” It feels like a very warm and happy place. These guys work so hard. Keep it up. 👍 🫶“

“The Little Caesars on Leslie Street in Newmarket is a solid option if you’re looking for a quick, no-fuss meal. It’s the kind of place you stop by when you want something easy/ pizza, wings, Crazy Bread - without waiting too long or spending a lot.

Service tends to be pretty fast, especially if you’re picking up one of the Hot-N-Ready pizzas. That said, depending on the time of day, the quality can vary a bit. Some days the pizzas come out fresh and just right, other times they feel like they’ve been sitting for a while.

Online ordering through apps like Uber Eats and SkipTheDishes makes things even more convenient if you’d rather not go in person. Overall, it’s a decent spot for a quick bite, especially if you’re already in the area and don’t feel like cooking.“

“I often come on my way home from work late at night and the gentlemen that work here are very polite. They are always very welcoming and kind when I come in. 100% recommend this location! Shout out to the two guys who are here when I come in!“

“Had pizza hut in Newmarket on davis Nikki help us out with ordering she was awesome.. we got 2 can dine small pizzas with wings deal all I can say the pizza was amazing and the wings were cooked perfectly.. I will definitely be going back to this location I been to others and this is by far the best I don't understand all the negative reviews cause I definitely didn't see it would recommend this location and great service from all the staff“