29 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newmarket

“Not only is this pizza place our favourite place to order from, but their customer service is top notch!
We order online for pick up fairly regularly and I unknowingly screwed up my online order.

I received an immediate phone call from them asking me to confirm what I had wanted to order.

They recognized my name and remembered our regular order and wanted to make sure we received exactly what we intended to order.

Not only do they make amazing pizza but they also really care about making customers happy!

Thank you for providing outstanding service!“

“All in one??????????“

“Amazing sandwiches! Great taste! A must try. Lunch or dinner or even catering. They won’t disappoint!“

“The best pizza ever, been going there since mid 80’s“

“The service is fast, and the staff is helpful. The pizza is always hot and fresh, with a good amount of toppings. Ordering for pickup or delivery is simple, and they usually get the orders right. It’s a great spot for a quick and easy pizza meal.“

“Very delicious pizza and wing. Very happy to see Halal Pizza in my town. Staff and owner are very friendly. Highly recommended. Guys must try and support this pizza shop. Many thanks“

“I requested an 11:45 delivery time and they were unable to delivery until 12:00. They threw in a free 2L bottle of pop of my choice for the inconvenience. I order from this location quite often for my workplace, it is our favorite pizza place in town! Highly recommend them.“

“The pizza in this store is very delicious, the dough is very soft, and the cheese provided is very thick, and you can pull out long cheese shreds. When my children and I ate here, the waiters in the store were very patient and enthusiastic. Come here to eat once a week.“

“Wow. What delightful service here. Very generous, the panzerottis are massive and will surely fill you up.

They use real sun dried tomatoes here and they're not stingy with it, unlike some places. The panzerottis also have a great flavor and are cooked very well. Does not feel overly greasy.

The only thing I would argue is that the dipping sauce containers are a little too small for the price, and in general.“

“Fast pizza with delicious crust. And a really nice staff member named Kashmir. I have lunch for 3 days this week - the pizza I chose is the Danforth (Greek). You gotta eat here!“

“I must admit that I often eat pizza. It is a favourite food of mine. I have been ordering in from Gino's Pizza on Leslie Street near Gorham in Newmarket for the last two years. Delivery is fast and courteous. Pizzas are delicious. They are generous with their toppings. I rate them 5 out of 5.“

“I have been coming to this location probably since I was 10 years old. I am 32 years old now for reference lol I mean it’s a Little Caesars what do you want this review to say? I highly recommend you order ahead of time even if you just want a plain old, hot and ready pepperoni. You’ll thank me later.“

“Great authentic pizza place. Lots of great food there! I had the classic, a pepperoni pizza. Its nice because Im right on that neighbourhood. Very clean and had real italian music playing. Great job 5/5

Vegetarian options: There's veggie slices already prepared so when you get there you don't have to wait!“

“I’ve visited there yesterday and i ordered the Family feast this is a great deal actually people should try that everything was so delicious and wood fired. Even the way they greet the customers i love that and i felt so welcoming i will definitely visit there again.“

“This was the best pizza I have ever had. 100% get those garlic sticks. They are so incredible.“

“Amazing!!
Came to Boston pizza after sitting for 20 mins and not getting served at jack Astor.

Our waiter was the best, soon as we sat down we got our drinks and appetizers sent out. I recommend coming to this location, lots of laughs“

“Always well done and very friendly service. Pizza actually has toppings and cheese, and is consistently great. I ordered for my father’s birthday today and joked with the associate on the phone to “make the pizza with love” and it somehow came out even better. Would recommend this location and I’ll continue going back ! (Only not adding a photo because we always dig in and remember halfway through that we forgot to take a picture for a review lol)

Parking: Parking is along Davis drive, if you park on the interior lot side of the building you’ll have to walk around“

“THE SERVICE IS Awesome The people are nice ESPECIALLY THE LADY THAT she’s always on the morning she’s very nice and kind if you’re sure like a dollar or something CHANGE THEY will tell you to take the pizza and bring me the dollar or two dollars that you’re short tomorrow very very very good service Best service in the area

Kid-friendliness: THAT WENT YOU SAID CHEESE ONLY BECAUSE IS FOR MY KID THEY DONT INSIST TO PUT ANOTHER TOPIN“

“If there’s a better sandwich within 50 miles than the amazing SPICY ITALIAN DELI, I’d love to know what it is (but I doubt this gastronomical work of art can be topped).
Fresh out of the oven bread, perfect combo of olive oil, balsamic, spicy meats, old school mozzarella, an incredible herbal coating…
I might just go for another one right now“

“We moved to Newmarket a year and a half ago and after trying every pizzeria, this wonderful town has to offer toppers took the top position and we remain fiercely loyal to them throughout the time we’ve been here. It’s the best pizza we’ve had this region. We’re going to miss toppers the most.“

“recently came and got a medium pizza, pizza was delicious nicely even on all sides of the pizza they were generous with the toppings and the lady at the front was very nice and offered candy canes to my son. most definitely would come here again“

“Called in first for a pick up had to call 5 times until someone picked up the phone....it was probably busy! luckily someone picked up and was nice and quick on the phone ordered a large veggie pizza with extra sauce on the bottom, extra cheese, garlic butter all over and parmesan cheese all over was ready in 15 minutes! the dough was fresh, toppings and cheese were also mouth watering delicious!!!!“

“I had one of the best pizzas ever, it was amazing. their work is professional and precise delivering the best in the shortest time. the place is spotlessly clean and the staff is friendly. everything I needed was provided, when I question about the price and menu everything was quickly provided to me. the pizza and the staff gave me the best experience ever.“

“This store is an absolute gem for the city. The service is exceptional, staff are super friendly and also know the craft of creating the perfect pizzas. What sets this place apart is the bold creativity in their pizza offerings. Each pizza features a unique flavour combination that showcases their commitment to pushing the boundaries of traditional pizza.The ambiance is inviting and trendy creating a delightful atmosphere for enjoying the food. If you're seeking a distinctive and memorable pizza spot, this is the place to be.“

“Thank you for catering our family event. The food was delicious! It was a pleasure working with Alex. Thanks again!!“

“This pizza is truly comfort. With the taste of home, there was a perfect balance of flavors that made every bite satisfying. The crust was crisp on the outside yet soft and airy inside, while the sauce had just the right blend of tanginess and sweetness. The toppings were fresh and generously layered, creating a rich and hearty experience. Whether you’re craving a quick bite or looking to unwind with something familiar, this pizza hits the spot. Highly recommended!“

“This place is one of the best restaurants in Newmarket, offering an excellent and unique dining experience, a very clean environment, and exceptional hospitality from the staff.
Thank you 🙏
And thank you for the Arabic music ❤️❤️❤️“

“I recently visited a new pizza place in town, and I was thoroughly impressed. The menu was diverse, offering a range of classic and creative options, all made with high-quality ingredients. What stood out the most, though, was the attention to detail. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, and the pizza arrived hot and fresh. The prices were reasonable for the quality, and I’ll definitely be coming back to try more of their inventive pizza options. If you're a pizza lover, this new spot is definitely worth checking out!“

“Very nice place with awesome food and service! Highly recommend to try it out. Will definitely be back! Good job Marco!“