30 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newmarket

“Amazing sandwiches! Great taste! A must try. Lunch or dinner or even catering. They won’t disappoint!“

“Probably the best "chain store" pizza in Canada! Love to get a slice or two when visiting Toronto. Hope they open branches in Ottawa soon (we need better pizza slices in the nation's capital).“

“All in one??????????“

“The best pizza ever, been going there since mid 80’s“

“They definitely live up to their name. This is the best pizza place around. Their cheese pizza and pepperoni pizza are both amazing. We’re already looking forward to coming back and trying their sandwiches. The owner and his family are very welcoming as well.“

“The service is fast, and the staff is helpful. The pizza is always hot and fresh, with a good amount of toppings. Ordering for pickup or delivery is simple, and they usually get the orders right. It’s a great spot for a quick and easy pizza meal.“

“I had a great experience at Papa John’s on Yonge Street in Newmarket! The customer service was excellent, and I really appreciated the late-night discount they offered. Even though I arrived just before closing time, the staff were welcoming, friendly, and provided outstanding service without making me feel rushed.

It’s great to see employees who care about their customers and go the extra mile, even at the end of a long day. Thank you for the excellent service and the great deal! I’ll definitely be happy to visit again. Highly recommended their Philly cheese Steak piza! 🍕👏“

“Fast pizza with delicious crust. And a really nice staff member named Kashmir. I have lunch for 3 days this week - the pizza I chose is the Danforth (Greek). You gotta eat here!“

“I must admit that I often eat pizza. It is a favourite food of mine. I have been ordering in from Gino's Pizza on Leslie Street near Gorham in Newmarket for the last two years. Delivery is fast and courteous. Pizzas are delicious. They are generous with their toppings. I rate them 5 out of 5.“

“Came to this restaurant, I had the pesto shrimp pasta and it was delicious 😋, was so good, I recommend this great place, good place for dinner.“

“Had a fantastic experience at Doughbox,
I was pleasantly surprised at the level of professionalism when it comes to the halal sections - separate stations for cutting, toppings and baking trays.
A very warm welcome and recommend it to anyone that enjoys a good pizza slice.
I came in for the walk in special which was reasonably priced and will come again soon.“

“I ended up at Econo with my daughter yesterday evening after a year or so . Quality of food has improved significantly at this this place.

The pizza we ordered was delicious and definitely worth the money. Staff was very friendly and accommodating.“

“I recently ordered from Pizza Pizza and had a great experience. The delivery was on time, and the pizza arrived hot and fresh. The crust was soft yet slightly crispy, and the toppings were generous. I also tried their garlic dipping sauce, which was really tasty. Overall, very satisfied with both the food and service.“

“I always have a great experience at this Domino’s location! The store is super clean every time I visit, and the staff keeps everything running smoothly. My orders are always fresh, hot, and consistently delicious. It’s clear they take pride in their service and food quality. Highly recommend this location for anyone looking for great pizza and a reliable experience! 🍕“

“On a very busy night during world series and a jam packed order lineup, I saw these guys thrive in excellent customer service, not an inch of their ovens where there was not a pizza cooking and they still kept the time commitment and still delivered an amazing tasting pizza.

I have never seen a pizza store this busy.“

“This is our favourite post concert spot! We love coming here the day after our concerts all summer long for pizza! And almost every time we love seeing our server Jenn Z! She is so fun and kind! She always provides super fast service and is very attentive!“

“I don’t normally write reviews, but I absolutely love this Pizza Nova! The food is always amazing, the service is quick, and everything is consistently delicious. But what really makes this location stand out is one of their employees, the gentleman with curly hair and glasses. He is genuinely the nicest human being.

I stopped to get pizza during a bad day and his kindness, warmth, and personable nature genuinely brightened my day. You can tell he truly cares about the customers and takes pride in what he does.“

“The food is amazing. The service is great. I have been coming to this pizza pizza for a long time now. I am greeted with a “hello how are you doing today” It feels like a very warm and happy place. These guys work so hard. Keep it up. 👍 🫶“

“This was the best pizza I have ever had. 100% get those garlic sticks. They are so incredible.“

“Hands down one of the best Little Caesars locations in the entire area! Every single time I order from here, the food is piping hot, fresh, and made to perfection. The crust has that ideal balance of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, and they never cheap out on the cheese or toppings!

Their Crazy Bread is always hot, buttery, and packed with garlic flavor, exactly how it should be. The Hot-N-Ready items are genuinely fresh and ready to go without any long wait times.

What really sets this store apart is the staff—super friendly, quick, and highly professional even during peak rush hours. The store is always clean, well-managed, and welcoming. If you’re looking for fast, top-tier quality pizza at an unbeatable value, this is definitely the place to go. Huge shoutout to the team working here—keep up the amazing work!“

“I often come on my way home from work late at night and the gentlemen that work here are very polite. They are always very welcoming and kind when I come in. 100% recommend this location! Shout out to the two guys who are here when I come in!“

“absolutely amazing food , great atmosphere and very generous quantity. been there many times and never had an issue . the chef & his assistant are terrific 5⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“The Little Caesars on Leslie Street in Newmarket is a solid option if you’re looking for a quick, no-fuss meal. It’s the kind of place you stop by when you want something easy/ pizza, wings, Crazy Bread - without waiting too long or spending a lot.

Service tends to be pretty fast, especially if you’re picking up one of the Hot-N-Ready pizzas. That said, depending on the time of day, the quality can vary a bit. Some days the pizzas come out fresh and just right, other times they feel like they’ve been sitting for a while.

Online ordering through apps like Uber Eats and SkipTheDishes makes things even more convenient if you’d rather not go in person. Overall, it’s a decent spot for a quick bite, especially if you’re already in the area and don’t feel like cooking.“

“Absolutely delicious! The sandwiches were fresh, flavorful, and made with great quality ingredients. The customer service was also excellent—friendly, welcoming, and attentive. Everything was great from the food to the service. Highly recommend Haida Sandwich!“

“Went a little extra for my daughters birthday! Thanks Toppers!

Customer Service was awesome. Delivery guy was super nice. Even arrived a few minutes early
Both pizzas arrived nice and hot and not all mangled.
Canadiana & Montreal Steak Spice both tasted amazing!
No complaints in this house.“

“Best place in town. Music or sports they have it and the very best wait staff ever.“

“was at your location on saturday, I really liked the services offered, and the Pizza was something out of this world, I like the way I was treated by your staff, highly professional, answered all my questions, suggested other menu too. I find this exceptional. Keep it up.“

“Had pizza hut in Newmarket on davis Nikki help us out with ordering she was awesome.. we got 2 can dine small pizzas with wings deal all I can say the pizza was amazing and the wings were cooked perfectly.. I will definitely be going back to this location I been to others and this is by far the best I don't understand all the negative reviews cause I definitely didn't see it would recommend this location and great service from all the staff“

“Food from this location is always delicious but today they exceeded my expectations. I ordered the bacon cheeseburger pizza but changed the sauce from ranch to tomato/bbq & hands down this is the best pizza I have ever tasted. I will definitely be ordering this again. Drivers are always friendly as well. Thank you“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ An all-around fantastic dining experience! The food was outstanding, the service was top-notch, and the atmosphere was just perfect. Add in a prime location and a wonderful, attentive staff, and you’ve got a restaurant that’s hard to beat. Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to over and over! Best restaurant around!“