Topper's Pizza — Newmarket

$$ • Pizza

Menu Order Online

About Toppers Pizza

Topper's Pizza in Newmarket is considered the best pizza in the region by some loyal customers. The pizzas, like the deluxe and pepperoni, are done to perfection with a dough that is much better than average. Options include thick crust, noted as a bit salty, and thin crust. The wings are good but small. For a quick, basic cheese slice or a full order, it is a great option, with reliable service and fast drivers. The owner is friendly and the experience is highly rated, making it a top choice for pizza in town.

Customers' Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza

Topper Sticks

Cheese Pizza

Pizzas

+1 more Show less

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

Toppers Pizza Reviews

3.7

121 ratings

62%

27%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about Topper's Pizza — Newmarket

Write a review

Went a little extra for my daughters birthday! Thanks Toppers!

Customer Service was awesome. Delivery guy was super nice. Even arrived a few minutes early
Both pizzas arrived nice and hot and not all mangled.
Canadiana & Montreal Steak Spice both tasted amazing!
No complaints in this house.

September 2026

Ordered pizza for the staff of our office
for my birthday and was treated to a free cinni-minnisticks! Might have to be our new regular spot! The owner of our company who went to pick it up said the staff was friendly and obviously went above and beyond. Thank you so much!

August 2026

Best Pizza place! Always great food and the owner and employees genuinely care about your food and yourself. Can't recommend enough

August 2026

Read All Reviews(121)