18 Best Pizza Restaurants in Carlisle

“I love EVERYTHING at @Napoli Pizza. I just had a Cold Sub (turkey/bacon/provolone) for early dinner and it was exquisite! It was just perfectly made and every element was cool & fresh - down to the danged mayo. 🤌🏾 UNBELIEVABLE. 🙌🏾“

“Accidentally ended up here today. Went to go to another place downtown. It now appears so many places are closed on Sunday. Sorry other downtown establishments didn’t get our business. We found our new favorite pizza. Beer was good too. Highly recommend.“

“I had such a wonderful, unexpected experience at this pizza place! By chance, I met the owners and they invited me and my husband to try their pizza, and it is now definitely my favorite pizza I’ve ever had! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and every bite showed the care they put into it. The prices were comparable to corporate owned chains but the quality was astronomically better than any other place I’ve been to. Having moved here from the West Coast I have been enjoying the opportunity to try new restaurants especially cuisine not as easy to come by back in our hometown. The owner spun the dough right in front of us, and it was clear how proud he is of his restaurant. He welcomed every customer with genuine warmth, making the atmosphere truly enjoyable. It felt like an authentic Italian experience, full of heart and passion. I can’t wait to go back and I am happy to know they even offer delivery! Looking forward to trying other items on their menu as well!“

“clean ,10 to 13 for subs.Subs where very taste 2.50 for slice of pizza .Good service .Will go again.“

“We were there for dinner last night for Mother’s Day and, as always, the food was absolutely amazing! The restaurant was extremely crowded, and those waitresses were HUSTLING all night long trying to keep up with the rush. Honestly, I was shocked to see some people get up and leave before their food came because let me tell you — this place is 100% worth the wait. We stayed until closing and even went back into the kitchen just to personally thank everyone. They told us it was the busiest they’ve ever been, and despite that, they still delivered a phenomenal dining experience. A huge thank you to the entire staff for another incredible Mother’s Day dinner. If you love Italian food, you absolutely must check this place out. ❤️🍝“

“Best pizza and sandwiches around! Clean, great service, great food and reasonable prices“

“I ordered a couple of pizzas today via DoorDash to feed my team. The quality of the pizzas and the flavor was top notch. My only issue was the “large” pizza is tiny. Which normally I would be ok but trying to feed a group at work with those tiny pizzas was a bit rough.“

“Picked up a call in order for lunch. Nice atmosphere. Clean looking restaurant. Friendly service. Pizza was freshly made and just came out of the oven. I didn't get to spend a whole lot of time there but I liked what I saw and plan on returning to check out some of the other items available Al's.“

“Food has always been outstanding!“

“Best pizza in town by far!!“

“Everything we have ordered from the Shippensburg location has been incredible! Super friendly owner and staff. Love this place! 😊“

“90% of the time, the food is great! But on April 16th, 2023, I got a delivery. The Fettuccine Alfredo was great, but the salad was AWFUL! I ordered a Grilled Chocken Salad and it DID NOT have any grilled chicken on it, it had NO croutons, & it had NO cheese on it! It was bland and awful!“

“90% of the time, the food is great! But on April 16th, 2023, I got a delivery. The Fettuccine Alfredo was great, but the salad was AWFUL! I ordered a Grilled Chocken Salad and it DID NOT have any grilled chicken on it, it had NO croutons, & it had NO cheese on it! It was bland and awful!“

“I had a wonderful time at Papa John's in Carlisle, PA. The workers are so kind, and they gave me an extra pepper in my box. Best pizza I've ever had!

Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza, veggie pizza, pizza without meat

Dietary restrictions: Red sauce, meat

Parking: Outside the store

Kid-friendliness: The workers were so sweet.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a slope for wheelchairs.“

“If you're looking for place where you can be yourself and get something to eat for good prices and the surrounding of what I would say a friendly welcoming atmosphere well at least welcoming to those who are around the area. Don't take that as a bad thing it's the comfort of home the feeling of familiarity. But if you're not from the area there's enough space and kind people to welcome you either way.“

“very pleasant people been going there for 10 years I would recommend“

“amazing staff and great food“

“I dont write reviews, but shout out to the guy with the red beard, A+ customer service. Absolutely made my day just by being a kind person and welcoming as I entered the store. This kind of energy and genuinely good customer service is hard to find these days.

Otherwise, never had any issue with this store. The food always comes out amazing and as ordered. Thank you to the whole team!“