50 Best Italian Restaurants near Collegeville

“Today was our first visit. Very good food but complete chaos and the staff wasn't very friendly.“

“We enjoyed our dinner at OG, the OG of chain Italian food restaurants. In the suburbs of Philly, with ten different restaurants that will deliver a pizza to my address, bold move, sir.
Our waitress was named Ireland, she was nice; all the food was great.“

“We have always had good service and great food at Osteria. One of our local favorites!“

“10 out of 10. You can’t go wrong. Antonio knocks it out of the park. Great specials. Great menu. Great atmosphere. If you’re looking for a family spot that will deliver great Italian food, this is it. My wife and I love it!“

“Great pizza - new fav place. The sauce isn’t sweet and the dough is perfect.“

“friendly staff and great food! highly recommend“

“I love my local pizza shop! They have a great taco pizza, perfect spice!! I can’t wait to try other menu items. Oh! And this staff is so friendly! The food is always ready on time and the price is right! Love it here“

“First time customer. I ordered pizza with sausage and pepperoni and a specialty pasta dish with grilled chicken, Italian sauce and shrimp in a Rosa sauce. Everything was delicious and top notch!!! Great atmosphere, clean, friendly and very accommodating workers. We will definitely be back 💯“

“Pasta Norcina was excellent. Have made this dish at home and theirs was better. Just the right spices and sauce it was yummy.“

“Great place and great people, if you are in the area you need to check out Tredici Italian Market“

“I’ve recently had several meals and drinks in the bar area. Food was delicious and drinks were great. Their house salad and pasta dishes are amazing!“

“ordered food at Christmas time it was absolutely awesome thank you“

“we just moved to the area and tried other places but your place is our go to, food is awesome!! our delivery driver is a Rockstar!! always nice, courteous and delivers it hot. we don't know his name but please give him a big thank you from us! thank you, your new neighbors“

“Love the food and the bar/wait staff are top notch. It’s a great spot to watch football or baseball and even do karaoke!“

“Everything from tallutos is the very best,I usually don't buy pre made sauce,I make my own,but I decided to buy the alfredo and rose sauce,was not disappointed at all,the ravioli are delicious, will not buy any other brand ever again,Talluto I thank you for such good products, also the sandwiches are absolutely one of the best,you are my go to place ?“

“My biggest regret about our visit here is that it wasn't sooner. We've truly been missing out on some delightful food. I have yet to pass this place during business hours and not see them packed. Last night we had reservations at Versante for two for our anniversary. Jamie and Anna were our servers, and they were so friendly. They listened to our questions and made (excellent) suggestions. Initially, it took a little longer than expected for them to greet us, but it was a fairly busy Saturday night and that's to be expected. Not a dig, but be prepared to wait if needed... I promise you, it's worth it. We started with the tuna tartare, burrata salad and arugula salad. The tuna tasted fresh and the mango it was paired with was so refreshing. The burrata, prosciutto and red peppers was another great pairing- simple, clean, fresh and balanced with some arugula and olives. The arugula salad with orange vinaigrette made for a lovely palate cleanser between rich courses. My better half had the seafood pasta special and it looked incredible- homemade pasta with Chilean sea bass, scallops, shrimp in a lobster sauce... he looked like he was in heaven while he was enjoying that dish. I had the pappardelle bolognese, thinking it's a very simple dish... and while yes, it was simple, it was still outstanding and flavorful. You can tell a lot of thought (and love) went into these meals. Then there was dessert.... homemade cheesecake with a raspberry sauce, and homemade chocolate mousse cake. Both of them would be worth a trip back for on a whim.“

“Great pizza. I think the best locally. Grandson‘s insist on eating Johnny’s Pizza every time they visit. Excellent Italian dishes Great salads and sandwiches. Reasonable prices Family owned and operated“

“Definitely recommend the cheese steak hoagie panini. It is fantastic!“

“Highly recommend Villa Caterina for your catering needs!! Excellent chicken Marsala!“

“What a great time! Awesome food! Awesome service! The waitress was fantastic!“

“Outstanding food hands down the best food, pizza was delicious, and wedding soup was on point !!“

“Great food and drinks! Always consistently good.“

“Bella Fiona has become one of our favorite places to eat in the area. The food is ALWAYS incredible. Unique specials, pleasant staff, not over priced. The the saying still is true that you get what you pay for, the here you get more. Keep up the great work👍“

“One of the most impressive Italian meals I've ever had. Everything we ordered was superb. cannot wait to go back!“

“As a regular customer, Lisa's Pizza is great!! Staff are friendly, the girls hustle there & the food is delicious!“

“A family owned Italian restaurant whose owner is a chef and not just a cook.“

“good food, great people. Thanx Frank, you are a good host, keep up the good work,“

“Fantastic experience 9/13/25. Party of 10 in the wine cellar room. Our waiter Clifford was amazing ! Food was spectacular from presentation to taste.“

“Wonderful dining experience! Manuel our waiter was attentive and great waiter- helping us pick excellent compliments in the menu. Very festive environment. Definitely recommend!“

“My husband and I both think they have the best chicken parm. I am obsessed with their penne pasta with vodka sauce!!! Sometimes I get the vodka sauce on my chicken parm as well. The lemon cake is a must have dessert! George and his team have Been working all through the pandemic making sure the community could count on them! So many restaurants ended up closing down and we are so glad that Piazza Presto was able to make it through. The food is always Fresh and delicious. Great place for a date night or with the family. It is BYOB which is nice since you can pack your own favorites and saves a lot too!“

“Delicious food, great atmosphere, great live music. Bar tender and servers were awesome too.“

“great food and service everyone is so friendly“

“Great food � great service � I Love this place It has a great atmosphere I highly recommend it �“

“Sea bass was incredible! Friendly staff and great environment. We’ll be back!!!“

“Thank you for providing superior service and love the sandwich and fresh bread and delicious Italian food“

“Large menu to choose from. Great drink menu too“

“Very delicious food! Really great service with an easy going wait staff. Waitress was attentive & checked on us often. Food was so good! 5 STARS!“

“The Nino’s grandma pizza was great! Chicken fingers and fries were really good as well. New customers highly satisfied. Delivery is a bonus!“

“We frequent Oaks Italian Deli, living around the corner. Being from NY, we really like the Italian food, which normally, in PA is quite disappointing. (Cannolis filled with whipped cream and whatnot- this is NOT okay.). My husband and children were stuck in airports for two extra days recently due to weather. They finally made it to Philly and oaks was closing soon. I was almost in tears when I called asking if they could deliver so close to closing. They didn’t even hesitate, thank you so much. You made a hellacious multiple days end a bit better. The kids went to bed full and everything was okay…. Thank you.“

“Great Eats. had lunch and got a pie to go. Always a pleasure to see Gus and Nino.“

“We hired Amadeos for our baby shower and people are still talking about how great the food was weeks later! Beth went above and beyond to help us with choosing a great menu and even came to our house to make sure everything would be set up correctly beforehand. Joanna and Missy helped serve and clean up during our party and they were the sweetest helping our older guests! We ate leftovers for a week that’s how generous portions were. You truly made our special day so much better and we are so grateful for your top notch food and service! We will definitely hire Amadeos again for our events.“

“Save your money! The cheesesteak was just OK, and the French fries were literally NOT cooked. Seemed like they just took them out of a frozen package, and warmed them up slightly. They had a weird color. Extremely disappointing.“

“Tina was the highlight of my experience. The food and wine was exactly what we wanted on a Friday night but Tina’s service was friendly, warming, welcoming, and she was very knowledgeable. She helped us guide through the menu, she didn’t hover over us she let us enjoy our meals and wine and really made our experience memorable. 1st time here and won’t be the last. Thank you Tina.“

“National treasure! Always amazing. Had to pick up last minute lunch for a group of volunteers and Corropoloese made it super easy to satisfy everyone’s needs. Store had paper plates and utensils for purchase too which made lunch extra successful. ❤️🤍💚“

“friendly kind considerate staff. delivery is never a issue. if there is ever a issue with food, the problem is handled in a timely matter and never with grief! highly recommend!!“

“Huge fan - their thin crust pizzas are my family’s favorite in the area. We also love the Nonna’s pie - square, but thinner crusted than a Sicilian pie with a excellent cheese blend and just a bit of heat/spice. Also, save room for the tiramisu - home made by Paola and seriously the best I’ve ever had!“

“It's is great to say hello and be greeted warmly anywhere. What vibes I felt is mainly what I remember about visiting the restaurant and that's hugely positive. Pizzas are decent B/B+ with the vibes. Sauce is solid, restaurant of menu usually follows that IMHO. Support your locals.“

“Stopped in and had the chicken cutlet Italiiano. One of the best sandwiches I have ever had. I would definitely recommend this place.“