15 Best Pizza Restaurants in East Stroudsburg

“I'm a Sicilian guy. You can tell a good pizzaria by their Sicilians. I was impressed with toninos. I tried just about all the Sicilians in the area but Toninos was the best. The Sicilian slices are thick and not flat like the others. There's a good ratio of cheese and tomato sauce on top. The middle is soft and airy. At the very bottom there's a thin crisp. I recommend this place. The traditional slices are good too 👍“

“The best. I moved down to Easton and just haven’t been able to find anything that compares.“

“Always stop in for lunch on the road from Maine to Maryland. 20+ years. Always something for everyone. Ready & HOT -to go!“

“I've tried almost all of the pizza places in the Bushkill area and this one is the best. The pizza is made with high quality bread flour, the cheese tastes good and the sauce is understated, not overwhelming. The crust is baked to a crisp golden brown and there is minimal flop. Much higher quality than the other places around. Do yourself a favor get off 109 onto Winona Falls Rd and drive a few extra minutes to get better quality pizza. The owner is about the friendliest person I've met and always has a kind word. You wont regret it.“

“Stopped in with my wife for an early dinner and was not disappointed. I had one of the daily specials. and it was something very different and delicious. My wife had the Bolognese it was good but a little sweet for her. The service was great. I would recommend their dinners as we didn't try any pizza.“

“The food was soooo delicious! We ordered a large pie with crispy chicken. This was, no joke, one of the most delicious pizzas we have ever had. The gentlemen who run the place were very nice and generous. Thanks for the delicious juice and pizza, guys!“

“The best. I moved down to Easton and just haven’t been able to find anything that compares.“

“Typical pizza place. Staff was friendly and helpful. Pizza had a sweet sauce and the crust was crispy but you could still fold it.. The fries were nice and crispy. Cheesesteak was good flavored with a nice amount of meat. The chicken wings were crispy with a nice tasting sauce.
The garlic knots were soft and flavorful. There was seating available. All the food came out as ordered and was at a good price.“

“Best pizza locally! You will not be disappointed!“

“The best lunch ever $5 🍕.“

“Have been coming here for 40 years. Local establishment that has served the community for twice that long. Food is reliably good, waitstaff prompt and friendly. Good music. Pizza is a local favorite. Always a good time.“

“We visit the original Bovino's near the high school every couple of weeks. The food is reliably fresh and tasty. Always very good sized portions. Reasonable prices. Service is usually a little slow, but not so much that it keeps us from coming back. Wings are great (bone-in and boneless). Pizza is good. Pretzel appetizer is yummy!“

“LUV THERE PIZZA ! GREAT PEOPLE! GOOD SERVICE !!“

“Although I do like your pizza, its be great if your drivers could follow the rules of the road. This time, specifically at the light near KFC in Stroudsburg...please teach them that the right hand lane is to turn up Main street not to cut people off who are going straight across towards Ann St. They just had to get to 80W before us.“

“First time here on august 6th 2024 me my wife and 5 kids …coming from Philly where pizza huts all down there don’t have inside dining..we was surprised this one we saw up the mountains did ..we got the big box deal and 2 personal pan pizzas 2 /2 little all was pretty good got the food pretty fast with only 2 people that was only working too not bad if ever up this way I’ll be back but definitely appreciate there is a dining room !!“