10 Best Ice Cream Shops in Gettysburg

“I’ve heard about Mr Gs for years but never had a chance to visit - then my bestie suggested it this afternoon. It was perfect for a warm afternoon in late September. The Apple Pie Ala Mode on the homemade Waffle Cone was such a decadent treat! If you’re in Gettysburg and craving a sweet treat - put it at the top of your list!!!“

“Best ice cream in Gettysburg! The owners/operators are extremely welcoming and kind, flavors are always delicious- we look forward to frequenting Cone Sweet Cone each season!“

“Thank you, thank you, thank you for saving the day. My granddaughter loves ducks. Our original plans for a cupcake cake shaped as a duck was terribly botched by the bakery. We walked into DQ on York Rd and they produced a beautiful “duck” cake on short notice. Special thanks to John and the young male server. They both went out of their way to help save the day“

“I love this Rita’s because it’s so convenient but the past 2 times I’ve come here they’ve given me the wrong flavored ice and it’s upsetting because I keep spending money and get what I didn’t even order. I went tonight and the guy was working alone and very busy and I understand things happen, but I ordered root beer ice and got the cola ice, which was a treat for my dad who unfortunately didn’t like the cola (rightfully so as he was wanting root beer). Just disappointing.“

“The ice cream was AMAZING. In my opinion the best around. the owner was so welcoming and the counter help was just the same. Do yourself a favor and try this place“

“Upon entering Lulu’s Finest Ice Cream, I was greeted by a nice woman named Amelia. She was very welcoming and actually was personable with flavor recommendations and was great with service even with it being busy! She recommended the toasted coconut as well as the cherry vanilla flavor to me; which are flavors I would never go for. They both were seriously good flavors! But, the service was better. Thank you Amelia for all of your help today and thank you Lulu’s. I will be back.“

“We had our first visit on 1/11/25, it definitely will NOT, be our last! My husband never had crepes, he is now a huge fan! Everything was amazing, I got the Spiced Chai Tea with the Strawberries and Cream Crepe. It was so big I couldn't finish. My husband got a coffee and Little Piggy Crepe, he's in love and already planning a day trip just to go to The Cottage Creperie! You gals Rock !“

“Ice cream was incredible and the fudge was so decadent & delicious. We also purchased the gourmet popcorn mix and it did not disappoint, huge pecans!! Staff was very helpful.“

“If you like cookie dough you will like this place. They do have different flavors each time you go, so you might not get what you want. But the staff was helpful to pick out something similar. This is in the food court area. Would come again. They do serve ice cream as well.“

“Bailey was our waitress… excellent with our group of 4 adults, 5 kids. All the orders and desserts were correctly prepared and tasted delicious.“