The Hoof, Fin & Fowl
619 Baltimore St, Gettysburg
(717) 542-9947
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Owners like to hind behind their business page to post political rants and verbally attack people..
We came in for dinner in hopes of a great drink and meal. 1st up the drink..I ordered a rum and coke and i am pretty sure it was straight rum with a splash of coke...so if you're into that go for it 2nd the food. I ordered the duck meal...potatoes were hard and had no flavor. duck was ok as well as the green beans. Husband ordered the New York strip definitely not worth $30..tasted like it came from a diner and an ice cream scoop full of not homemade mashed potatoes. I would not recommend
Small menu. Waited forever to get our food with maybe 10 people in the restaurant total, and the food wasn't really worth the wait
Was there on New Year's Eve. Our server Sue was excellent. The atmosphere was less than expected. More of a neighborhood bar rather than fine dining. Our meals were a mixed bag the NY Strip Steak was excellent as was the Pheasant. The sides were either boxed or canned and not good. The French Onion Soup was not bad but the Crab soup was bland. All and all the good balanced out the bad but for the price I expected more.
we got there late, 8pm. they gladly seated us. we got 2 appetizers, crab balls and calamari. i got crab stuffed shrimp and my husband got steak. the food was soooo wonderful, our waitress was just awesome and atmosphere was cosy and inviting. this was on Saturday, November 9th 2024
We had fantastic food. Our server Jim was wonderful and saw to all our needs, we had 2 small children with us. I would definitely recommend this restaurant and plan to return when in the area again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I had a wonderful time here! The service was amazing, the food was absolutely delicious with the perfect portions, and the atmosphere was so fun! We will definitely go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood, Maryland Crab
Nice bar tucked away from the crowds. Friendly staff and great food!
This a very cute restaurant. It's small but very welcoming. The crab dip was amazing. My main course was the duck, which I had never had before, but it turn out to be one of the best tasting meats I've ever had. I strongly recommend stopping in and having dinner. There's even some rumor that it's haunted so you might get a little extra bang for your buck. Prices are very reasonable too, even market price wasn't daunting.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Read the reviews about this place it was a little leery about trying them but they had an item on their menu that we liked and thought we would give it a try anyway disregarding the reviews that we read. Our server Macee, greeted us right away. We ordered an appetizer of clams steamed with butter which was absolutely delicious. I ordered one of the specials which was a ribeye with mashed potatoes and green beans, at the time I didn't say how I wanted it cooked but Macee came back and said how did you want your ribeye cooked I requested medium. The ribeye was cooked medium and was delicious as well as the rest of the dinner. My husband ordered the duck breast served with the fingerling potatoes and green beans and this too was delicious even though it was cooked a little too well for him that was his fault as he did not ask for it the way he liked it which is rare but everybody doesn't like that. Macee was very attentive to us, and pleasant. The bartender in the back of the hoof Fin and fowl at hungry run Cellars was very nice and had a great selection of Pennsylvania brand Liquors. We had a fantastic experience here! The next time we're in town will be sure to visit the Hoof Fin and Fowl as well as Hungry Run Cellars!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steamed Clams, Duck Breast
Restaurantji Recommends
We looked at the menus on line but did not know dinner was limited, did not know we were sitting in the area where we had to go to the bar for our drinks, did not offer hamburgers they said only for kids. Took over an hour for dinner to be served. Soooo disappointed will not be back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Very cozy place, delicious food we got an array of things, everything of so good and was good portion sizes no to big or small. Not too expensive we got 2 apps 3 entrees and a dessert for around $100. I would definitely recommend this place
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips, Tuna, Calamari
Terrible crabs under cooked service was bad got ignored the whole time
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We drove by The Hoof, Fin and Fowl and saw that under the sign it advertises with Steamed Crabs, Seafood, Steak & Exotic Cuisine. Well this was a no brainer we wanted to try it out. We looked at the menu online and were excited! Until we saw the menu in person - no burgers, sandwiches etc
The highlight was the bartender and server. Both were nice and friendly. We had the duck breast and Fish and chips. Both were supposed to come with a side salad and rolls. We received the side salad (very small but fresh), no rolls were served. More did any other table get rolls and we overheard them saying “We haven’t have rolls in a long time”.
The duck breast was good, however was sprinkled with duck sauce - not bad, just odd. The Fish and chips were ok, fish was good, coleslaw tart but fresh, and the fries not edible. The fries were double or triple fried, they were hard and saturated with oil.
We had high hopes for this mom n pop restaurant. Hopefully they can fix the issues and make it work.
Again the bartender and server were the best part of our dinning experience. Very kind and nice!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
I am not sure the reason why the ratings in this restaurant aren't better. My family and I really enjoyed the environment, music, but more importantly, the service and great food.
Not overpriced and no waiting in line to be seated. We will definitely come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...