7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Grove City

“Came in thirty min to close. Chicken sandwich was tasty, baked potato seemed microwaved, but still good. Server/bartender could’ve came around a turn or two instead of us having to go to bar to ask for something. She liked her tenders too. Nice they didn’t make us feel rushed. Laid back atmosphere. Comfortable low lighting and comfortable booths. Pickle spears were tasty too! Huge and hot. $35 for two of us. No beers.“

“Traveling from Wisconsin for a wedding in Newfoundland pa.we stayed in Grove City pa.found coffaro's on line.well worth ordering.was ready in about 10 minutes. The gentlemen working where very polite.its a must try..thank you for a delicious pizza...“

“I had their pizza on March 21st, 2025. It was DELICIOUS! The crust was crisp and crunchy, the sauce wasn’t loaded on heavily. You aren’t overwhelmed by it. Best pizza I’ve had since moving to PA.
The staff were all polite and friendly.“

“Absolutely delicious, staff was friendly, food was amazing. We got rectangular pepperoni pizza and was amazing and stayed hot for really long we also got their dippin sticks (cheese sticks) and they were super good. It’s a very comfortable environment and we’ll definitely be coming back.“

“Have a family of five and we all ordered different stuff and couple times. Never had a complaint. In fact probably the best steak hogie I've ever had.“

“Wish I new the delivery drivers name she deserves a way bigger tip then just 2.00 she was very nice and polite delivery was on time food was great“

“As far as Little Caesars goes it's definitely one of the better ones. I enjoyed my time and my meal. Good food and a good atmosphere. It's in another business but there are tables and plenty of room. However if you want to eat there you might want to bring your own plate. Lol....“