Lancaster Pie & Coffee
$ • Coffee Shops, BakeryAbout Lancaster Pie & Coffee
Customers' Favorites
Sour Cherry Pie with Homemade Ice Cream
Berries and Cream Waffle with Nutella
Banana Cream Waffle with Nutella
Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie
Fresh Strawberry Creme Pie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Latte
Onion and Mushroom Quiche
Chocolate Silk Pie
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Triple Berry Pie
Lancaster Pie & Coffee Reviews
196 ratings
Share your opinion about Lancaster Pie & Coffee
Deliciously Excellent pie and coffee!!! Warm and inviting atmosphere! People are absolutely amazing!
We travel from Staten Island and visit every time!
🩷
We travel from Staten Island and visit every time!
🩷
I recommend the chicken pieeee.
I recommend the chicken pieeee.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 5PM |
Lancaster Pie & Coffee is a cozy shop known for its fantastic food and welcoming atmosphere. This pie shop offers a variety of fabulous pies made from scratch with high-quality local ingredients. The berry pie is a masterpiece, with perfect consistency and a fabulous dough. The Liege waffle with berries and cream is a must-try, rated 11/10 for its texture and flavor, while the waffle with pistachio paste has become a favorite for many. The chicken pie and chocolate silk pie are also highly recommended. The owner and staff are super friendly and personable, creating a pleasant experience for customers. They greet customers warmly as if they are old friends. Customers have praised the exceptional pies and the staff's dedication to providing a truly special experience. The service is outstanding, and the coffee is spot on, making it a comfortable and relaxing place to enjoy pie and coffee. With indoor and outdoor seating, including a dog-friendly area, Lancaster Pie & Coffee is a gem worth visiting regularly.