New American Restaurants near Middletown, PA

“Food is top notch. Service is top notch. This place is awesome. Last time we were there was mothers day, busy and service was a little slower but they were packed! Lobster rolls were worth the price, shrimp tacks were on point and the burgers are never a bad choice!“

“Lovely and plentiful food at great prices and friendly service!“

“It’s been a long time since I can give a raving review on a local restaurant. The Mill did not disappoint. It was clean the drinks were strong and the food was delicious. Highly recommend to anybody looking for a great dining experience!“

“Was in the area for a seminar and decided to stop by for dinner and watch football game. Service was excellent and food was outstanding. The restaurant is a amazing place. Highly recommend it“

“The good and the bad- I love the atmosphere. Really cool old brick building hidden off chocolate Ave. decor was nice and booths are comfy! We ate on the indoor/outdoor patio. It was really nice. I ordered the hot honey salmon which was delicious (at $30 I am glad of it). Really nicely plated and delicious! The raspberry lemon dessert was also so yummy! My husband ordered the cheesesteak which unfortunately came out cold. I would say the main negative of our experience was the service — it was such a disappointment. For the cost of a meal my expectations of service were admittedly high, it’s not a diner so things like removing dirty plates, refilling waters, responding to requests in a timely manner, being able to answer menu questions, etc — none of that was part of our experience. It’s a shame because service is an important part of eating out, and I’m not sure the cost here is worth the risk of the poor service.“

“Staff are awesome!! Very friendly!!! Food is amazing and smoothies OMG!!! Very cute place!!! Bathrooms very clean so is the restaurant. I highly recommend!!!“

“The hotel manager at Hampton Inn recommended "What IF" for dinner. He was spot on. Excellent service and our table just off the end of the bar provided a quiet place to enjoy an excellent meal.“

“Ate dinner there about a week ago. Food was good but their telephone rang at top volume the entire time we were there making it difficult to talk or enjoy our meal. Complained to waitress who said it had to be that way so they could hear in the back for take out orders. The restaurant was far from busy for in house dining so I guess the owner doesn't care about us; only the take out customers! I have eaten here for years and tried to support them during covid but never again.“

“Went there for our son’s engagement party with her family, amazing experience and night. Thank you Nick!“

“We had a delicious lunch today, and the best jalapeño margaritas I’ve ever had, including those I’ve had in Mexico. Everything is homemade, fresh, and delicious. The owner Maria is just lovely. A highly recommended restaurant.“

“Stopped in because Tröegs was way too crowded. Food was great, beer was even better and I can’t say enough about the service. The bartender was incredibly knowledgeable and super friendly. I have never had better service! Crowd at the bar was great too. Highly recommend!“

“We just came back from dinner at Ferrarelli’s and everything was amazing!! You cannot go wrong with anything you order. Portion sizes are plenty (we all bought home plenty for lunches this week). You will not be disappointed! Service was also wonderful!“

“Went here for the first time tonight to see a show & immediately loved the atmosphere! It was absolutely packed with people & I found a seat at the bar; I was quickly blown away with the bartender Emily & her immaculate, attentive, and speedy service! Even when things got overwhelming she was an absolute ROCKSTAR!!!“

“I stopped in this brewery while on a business trip in Harrisburg. The food and beer were good, but nothing spectacular. The service at the bar was a little lacking. I ordered the 1/2 rack of ribs which was about 4 or 5 ribs. After I placed my order, I heard the bar tender announce to someone who sat next to me that there was a wing special that night. That would have been nice to know before ordering.“

“They do a great job - beer, food, service, atmosphere. The beer is great and rotates. The food is great and delicious. Service is always great. The space is beautiful.“

“Excellent service. Our server was Billy. Great food.“

“I was just there from Ohio on the way to Wildwood, NJ the smashburgers are great! The waitress was wonderful and pleasant. She was blonde forgot to get her name. Great place yummy!“

“It is always full of happy memories at the Hotel. Our family has enjoyed the hotel since I was a child. The staff is awesome, friendly & happy. Thanks for a great memories in our family. Jeri & Jeffrey“

“The goat cheese & artichoke poppers were the first truly unique taste I have experienced in years. Our waitress Wendy was very thoughtful and proactive in helping my wife navigate the menu with her food allergies. The burger meat is a combination of brisket, chuck, and sirloin. I am a very picky burger eater and even grow my own grass fed grass finished meat so when I say their burger is amazing, their burger is AMAZING. 11/10, cannot recommend enough. We will be back!!“

“Depends on the time of year. In the summertime you can be out on the deck and it's a fantastic atmosphere. During the college season I would say the college kids ruin the atmosphere a little bit, but to each their own. Food and service is great no matter when you go.“

“Atmosphere, beers, food, and service are all very good. We had the brisket sandwich and chilli.the sandwich was very dry, but nothing a packet of BBQ sauce couldn't fix. The chilli was surprisingly good and we definitely recommend it. Next time we're ordering two of those.“

“Took our kids to the water park, got to stay close to water works, great for kids“

“Took our kids to the water park, got to stay close to water works, great for kids“

“Great fast service ..great food and atmosphere..very reasonably priced“

“I’ve eaten here a couple of times before, today was my second time and not only was the food good, our waitress, Kasey, was amazing! Super kind and helpful. I’d definitely love to come back here sometime.“