New American Restaurants in Lancaster, PA

Gibraltar Restaurant Seafood • $$$
488 Royer Dr #101, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Maine Lobster Fettuccine
Baked Blackberry Oysters
Gibraltar Caesar Salad
Whole Roasted Branzino
Housemade Gnocchi
Seafood Tower for
Crème Brulee
Tuna Tartare
Fish Special
Lemon Tart

“The whole dining experience was more than excellent; it was damn-near perfect! I'm not much of a raw fish person, but I tasted my wife's tuna tartare appetizer and loved it. My oysters Rockefeller appetizer was a delicately balanced, excellent preparation. For my main course I had the whole Branzino, expertly deboned for me at tableside, and it was marvelous. At that point we did not need dessert, but the list of available after dinner drinks was awesome! Kudos also to our server Casey, who helped to make the evening memorable.“

4.7 Superb371 Reviews
Harvest Seasonal Grill - Lancaster American • $$
1573 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Korean BBQ Chicken Lettuce Wraps
Vegan Sausage Flatbread
Butternut Squash Soup
Grilled Filet Mignon
Cedar-Roasted Salmon
Local Bison Meatloaf
Seared Sea Scallops
Braised Short Ribs
Pumpkin Ravioli
Sesame Chicken

“The staff was great !! Felt very welcomed and well taken care of.The menu is a bit pricey for SOME of the things. Of the food I received it was 50/50. Underwhelming burger and Mac and cheese but the appetizers were well made and worth the price (we ordered 3 to share with the table of 6 and it was plenty)The environment was clean and decorated nicely but even with being there after the lunch rush it was still very Loud. I couldn't talk to anyone not right next to me without having to raise my voice. So if you are looking for a quiet meal this may not be the place for you.I would recommend this place if you are vegan / vegetarian. There are a lot of options to choose from.I'd come back if invited but it's not somewhere I'd choose for myself.Dietary restrictions: Wait staff asked our food restrictions before taking our order and were very knowledgeable about what ingredients the meals had.“

4.3 Superb366 Reviews
Passerine American •
114 N Prince St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Butternut Squash Soup
Brisket Shakshuka
Patatas Bravas
Potatoes

“I need to talk about this cafe I found on a Thursday morning. I was the first customer there, and the atmosphere was immediately inviting, bright, clean, and full of positive energy. The Lebanese-style falafel wrap was unlike anything I've had before. It tasted rich, almost like a blend of lamb or beef, but it was definitely falafel. The addition of pickled radishes and fresh vegetables was a brilliant choice. The pita bread was the perfect balance of soft and chewy, holding everything together. The owner added to the experience by offering me a complimentary espresso. It was strong and smooth, a great end to an amazing meal. This cafe isn't just about food; it's an entire experience. The flavors, the atmosphere, and the service all come together to create something special. If you haven't been there yet, you're truly missing out.“

4.6 Superb73 Reviews
Silver Spring Family Restaurant Family • $
3653 Marietta Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Garden Omelette Rye Toast Marinara Sauce
Regular French Toast and Bacon
Fresh Tuna or Chicken Salad
Maryland Crab Soup
French Onion Soup
Cheeseburger Sub
Fresh Pancakes
Fried Chicken
Beef Barley
Greek Salad

“We came here for our honeymoon! After traveling from Philly, we stopped in Lancaster and asked a local what food they recommend. This was their first pick and they did not disappoint! It looks small, but there is a lot of space inside! It was packed but still had loads of seats to choose from so we could sit around people or find somewhere secluded. There were so many families, it warmed my heart. Our server, Jordan, had great energy, was fast with refills and had so many great recommendations. Our food was hot, fresh, and legitimately the best food we have had in the entire honeymoon. I had the French onion panini and my husband had the crab cakes, and we split some onion rings with spicy crab soup. It blew us away, and they were just the sweetest group ever! If I settled here I know I would end up being one of those couples there every Saturday night because it is worth it!“

4.4 Superb58 Reviews
The Pantry Restaurant Breakfast • $
2715 Marietta Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Swirl French Toast
French Toast Sampler
Eggs Homefries
Side of Bacon

“Went for a late breakfast with my boyfriend. I had the crepes and they were delicious. Unfortunately it looked like a tornado hit the restaurant when we walked in. They sat us at a "clean" table that had crumbs all over the chairs and food/ a dirty fork under the table. Looks like they could just use some extra help.“

4.4 Superb53 Reviews
Lancaster Brewing Company American • $$
302 N Plum St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

LBC Original White Chicken Chili
House Smoked Pulled Pork Sandwich
Philly Style Soft Pretzel
Black Bean Burger
Taproom Burger
NY Steak Frites
12 Beer Sampler
Brewery Wings
Craft Beer
Strawberry

“We were in town for a Rugby tournament and have been a long time fan of their beer so we took advantage of how close our hotel was to check out their taphouse/restaurant.The building has a presence but is extremely inviting but parking was a challenge. Ultimately we ended up with a spot in their lot but it took some time/patience.That minor nit aside, upon entering the restaurant we were warmly and quickly greeted. It was a Friday night during the NCAA tournament so it was predicably busy so it took a moment to get seated. We may have waited a few minutes at most before we were taken to a table.The ambiance/atmosphere definitely leans into it's Lancaster heritage ... warm, comfortable, and rustic. But that's an aside.After being seated we were greeted by our server almost immediately. He brought us water and showed us the specials. From that point forward our dinner just flowed. Orders taken, our appetizer served (corn dog fried shrimp) amazingly fast followed very quickly by our burgers, my wife got the LBC Cheeseburger with mushrooms and Swiss and I got the LBC and subbed out the meat for a black bean burger and added a cup of white chili).I can't overstate how fresh, fast and flavorful everything was. Overall, between the food and the beer it was outstanding.“

4.3 Superb130 Reviews
Lancaster Brewing Company Taproom & Grill American • $$
2323 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Smokehouse Brisket Sandwich
The Taproom Burger
Fish and Chips
French Fries
Brewery Wings
Pulled Pork
Beer Flight
Sandwiches
Salad
Pizza

“First time in. Popped in before a concert. Food was absolutely delicious! We got the pretzel to start. I got the black bean burger with sweet potato fries and a cosmo. My hubby got the lamb burger and a flight of beer. Everything was sooo good! Will definitely come back!“

4.2 Good100 Reviews
551 West New American • $
551 W King St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tenders and Fries with Honey Mustard
551 World Famous Peanut Butter Burger
Create Your Own Nachos or Pub Fries
Bacon Wrapped Grilled Cheese
Fried Mashed Potato Bites
All You Can Eat Crab Legs
Lucky Charms Cheese Cake
Peach Burger and Fries
Pittsburgh Steak Salad
Chicken Milano

“I’ve gotten their ribeye special the last few weeks and I say this with no reservation. The only place I’ve had a better steak is at 401 Prime, except this steak is at a fraction of the price. Whoever is cooking the steak at 551 west is doing a phenomenal job. If they have a ribeye special I will be here eating a delicious perfectly cooked medium rare steak.“

4.2 Good80 Reviews
Clean Eatz Health Food • $
1876 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries

“This place is a hidden gem, great convenient frozen meals that take the prepping, dishes, and time wasted cooking out of eating clean. The people are super nice and everything I have had has been great, and it’s surprisingly affordable compared to the price of groceries and time spent cooking.“

4 Good21 Reviews
Double C New American • $$
220 N Prince St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Bean and Rice Bowl with Shredded Beef
Chips & Salsa with Queso
Pork Belly Love Bowl
Beef and Lamb Burger
Taco Sampler Platter
Pork Belly Tacos
Pulled Pork

“Amazing food, very flavorful. The drinks are strong and delicious. The service was quick, with attentive staff. The restaurant is quite visually appealing. It is however quite loud and can make conversation a little bit difficult.Kid-friendliness: Would not bring my children here.“

4.1 Good74 Reviews
CoreLife Eatery Salad • $
1581 Fruitville Pike Suite 1, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Buddha Bowl
Chicken Cobb Salad
Salad Bowls
Rice Bowl
Salads
Steak

“Flavorful, diverse, fresh, fast cuisine with friendly service!! Healthy beverages - no fountain soda. Plenty of vegan options. Tofu as protein and well-labeled dressings (most are vegan!). Great music too - not too loud either.Vegetarian options: Vegan dressings & tofuParking: Go around behind Starbucks to avoid obnoxious Chick-fil-A traffic. Traffic at Belmont is nuts.“

4 Good42 Reviews
BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse American • $$
925 Plaza Blvd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Hickory Brisket and Bacon Burger
Honey Sriracha Brussels Sprouts
New New Orleans Jambalaya
Chocolate Chunk Pizookie
Monkey Bread Pizookie
Mozzarella Sticks
Avocado Egg Rolls
Ahi Tuna Salad
Chicken Wings
Nachos

“We haven't been here in 5 yrs but it was such a great experience. Pizza was delicious, cocktails to die for, and our server was amazing (Skye E). Her recommendations were delicious, my picky child ate everything from the plate, and she was so nice to substitute an item for her. Nice touch with the kids' appetizers! ? Appreciated! Excellent job, Skye!Vegetarian options: The veggie pizza was delicious, and I even ate the crust. Loved it!“

3.9 Good139 Reviews
Loading...
map Map