Restaurants near New Buffalo

“We ordered a large meat lovers pizza and 1 Italian sub and 1 cheeseburger sub. The delivery was faster than expected and I did not have the pizza but my son in law said it was awesome. I had the cheeseburger sub. 1st the hamburger patties were amazing tender and juicy,2nd the roll hand made and soft and delicious. This roll did NOT come out of a bag. The sub was well put together and perfectly portioned additional toppings. I have rarely enjoyed one more. The delivery driver was prompt and polite, my sub was still warm . I highly recommend this restaurant. Great job all around quality food.”

“There is a reason this place is always packed. The food can’t be beat and the ice cream is always amazing. I wish they were open year round.”

“Amazing food. Their quarter chicken is absolutely to die for, along with their, grrenbeans, deviled eggs, smoked brisket chili ( not on the normal menu, might be seasonal and advertised at the register. $14 ), brisket, Peters Mtn pileup. Their ice cream is fantastic too. I got their Shoo Fly Pie ice cream for my husband and brought it home to East York. It took all I had not to finish it myself. We are located about an hour and a half away but I am so excited to bring him here to experiance it all soon. My coworkers know where to go when working in the area, thats for sure!”

“So delish! Went early morning so didn’t experience the long wait times mentioned in other reviews. The staff was friendly, the place was super clean. Smoothies and bowls were both so good.”

“I purchase breakfast from here at least twice a month. Always wonderful!”

“This is my Husbands favorite place….Food is fantastic and we love the workers.we look forward to seeing them.”

“I had the opportunity to try this place for the first time yesterday, I don't live in the area, but a friend recommended I try it. I have to say, the food was amazing!!! The customer service was also amazing!!! If you're ever in the area and you don't try this place, you're doing yourself a disservice!!! 10 out of 10 highly recommend Bellia's Pizza!!! I will definitely be back whenever I'm in the area!!!”

“They need more tables...it's that good people!”

“Love this place! Great food, prices, and service!”

“I met for lunch with a friend today. This was my first visit to Brewboxx and I will be back again! I ordered a tomato/basil panini on whole wheat & a hot mint tea. Delicious! We sat out in the greenhouse among the plants. The young ladies who took our order & prepared our food were very kind as well!🙂”

“This place is a hidden gem. delicious food and excellent service. The seafood bisque is the best anywhere.”

“10/10 Highly Recommend! Ordered The All Star Smash Burger for take out yesterday, to celebrate National Burger Day. Outstanding! Perfectly cooked and seasoned. I'm very picky, I know good food, I lived in NJ in the NYC Metro area for 10+ years.”

“Wilderlove Coffee Co. is the hidden gem every coffee lover needs to know about! Nestled in Duncannon, this coffee truck is more than just a place to get caffeinated—it's an experience. The coffee? Absolutely top-notch. Whether you're a latte lover or a purist with a thing for straight espresso, they have something special for every taste. And don't even get me started on their bakery items—they’re absolutely delicious! If you haven’t tried them yet, do yourself a favor and go, now! Wilderlove Coffee Co. is not just a coffee stop; it’s a must-have experience. Can’t wait for my next cup!”

“Our meals were excellent, along with service. Food came out quick and hot. Love it.”

“Incredibly welcoming and friendly staff. I highly recommend the Eggs Benedict (absolutely delicious hollandaise and served with a perfect side of breakfast potatoes)! Pair it with a delightful cup of diner coffee: *chefs kiss*”

“Food is great, service great and everyone is so personable! Now becoming our favorite place?”

“Overnight guest, googled restarants that deliver near me. This place came up- supereasy to order on line, great prices, and fabulous food. Very satisfied customer.”

“Great place to eat!!!!!!!”

“Traditional American restaurant. This restaurant already operated for 75 years and now is managed by the 3rd/4th generations. The food is so good! We ordered a few entree(chicken bowl, 6 Oz sirloin steak, liver and onion) , the portion is big and the food is freshly made. The vegetable of the day is sautéed tomatoes and the sauce is superb!”

“The best pizza and stromboli around! All their food is delicious, served hot, not lukewarm, and the owner's and staff are so welcoming.”

“The food was absolutely amazing! The servers were great! Fun atmosphere!”

“Great food! Enjoyed the live music!! Friendly staff!”

“Gonders is a wonderful restaurant. Great food and service. Great prices and a large amount of food.”

“excellent over stuffed subs .well worth the price .fresh and delicious everything on the menue is delicious”

“great good, very nice polite waitress staff. we will definitely be back! 5 🌟”

“Went there for our son’s engagement party with her family, amazing experience and night. Thank you Nick!”

“Passed by this pizza shop forever and today finally stopped in....EXCELLENT!!! The pizza & wing special was outstanding! Best pizza & wings I've had in a long time! 5 star 🌟 Recommend!”

“This was the first time there and the food was excellent! I will definitely be going back again.”

“We were waiting to go to Liquid Noise for a long time. So sorry we waited. The Ale smash burger was amazing and I upgraded to fresh fries instead of chips. My wife’s fish sandwich was impressive in both size and taste. The haddock was still moist and glistening even after being fried. We also shared some wings. We had the garlic parm and Korean ginger. They were crispy, just like we ordered and well sauced. I can highly recommend these as well. The beer was great too. My wife stuck to her canned cocktails but I had to try a few brews. Captain Murica is a light lager that is crisp and refreshing. Perfect for a hot day or post yard work. The Vienna Symphony was also much lighter than expected for a Vienna style lager. UnPlug'd is an English dark ale that is light but packed with flavor. I could have a pint any time. My favorite though was O’Brien’s Irish Stout. Move over Guinness. You’re in second place now.”

“Very good value. Their pizza and strombolis are very satisfying.”