Fourstar Pizza & Fresh-Baked Subs
$ • Pizza
Hours:
1506 Old Butler Rd, New Castle
(724) 656-9222
About Fourstar Pizza & Fresh-Baked Subs
Customers' Favorites
Meatball Stromboli
Pepperoni & Cheese
Deluxe Stromboli
Chicken Parm Sub
Steak Stromboli
Steak & Cheese
Cheese Pizza
Bread Sticks
Deluxe Pizza
Chicken SM
Recent Reviews
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu
Hours
| Monday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 10:30AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 10:30AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Fourstar Pizza & Fresh-Baked Subs is a popular restaurant known for its amazing prices and excellent customer service. Their cheese and BBQ chicken pizzas are top choices, and the chocolate chip pie is a great dessert option, especially with a scoop of ice cream. Customers love the personalized service and delicious 12-slice pepperoni pizza. The chicken sub is highly recommended, with one customer willing to have it shipped from another state. This restaurant is considered the best pizza place in Newcastle.
The service at Fourstar Pizza is amazing, with the staff being helpful and accommodating. Customers have praised the restaurant for bringing their orders out to them in the parking lot, demonstrating exceptional customer service. The owner has also been commended for accommodating special requests, such as adding wings to the menu. Customers have described the experience as "elevated" and "5-star white glove service." The prices are beyond reasonable, with two pizzas costing under $20.
While some customers have noted that the pizza could be hotter or have more cheese, they still appreciate the fresh and fluffy bread, as well as the problem-free service. Overall, Fourstar Pizza & Fresh-Baked Subs continues to be a favorite among locals and travelers alike, offering delicious food and unparalleled customer care.